3 ms·
I know the comment is today taken as the high of HN negativity, but to me the comment seems very reasonable. - Back then there were FTP clients that automatica
by wongarsu 8y ago
I know the comment is today taken as the high of HN negativity, but to me the comment seems very reasonable.
- Back then there were FTP clients that automatically kept server and client in sync, which is the main feature of Dropbox. Dropbox adds a website, but Windows Explorer already supports FTP nativly. Of course easily creating shared links turned out to be a major thing, but I don't think we can blame people for not predicting that (especially since public folders are a feature of FTP servers, so it's not a new feature, just a lot more convinience). And of course Dropbox makes all that convinient and approachable, but that's easily overlooked by the technical user.
- The comment points out that contrary to the headline Dropbox will not replace USB drives. And here we are, a decade later, and Dropbox indeed didn't replace USB drives.
Of course in hindsight it's clear that Dropbox was a great idea with great execution, but that wasn't obvious at the time at all.
- acdha 8y agoI was just thinking that having used various FTP/SFTP-as-a-filesystem, not to mention NFS and SMB, over a decade or so before Dropbox arrived made the sales pitch immediately obvious: do you want everything to be slow and unreliable, with frequent jank even on fast networks, or not?
- gsich 8y agoWell, SMB worked a decade ago and still does. Main difference is that it works better on local networks.
- acdha 8y ago“Works” in the sense that the experience is acceptable but anyone who's used it knows that while things have gotten a little better over the years there are still a wide range of programs which handle latency by blocking. If you use a network home directory, you just get used to Outlook, Word, etc. sporadically hanging for a few seconds before the UI paints, etc. That's going to be worse as a function of latency and packet loss so it's far more tolerable in an enterprise environment using wired networks with tons of bandwidth and, at least theoretically, a professional support team. Over WiFi or consumer-grade internet (i.e. probably a strong majority of Dropbox's customers) the gap in experience is going to be more substantial.
- gsich 8y agoI am not sure if SMB is used over the Internet by "customers".
- acdha 8y agoIt's heavily used over VPNs. I have seen SMB over the internet by [ill-advised] companies but the various waves of exploits have probably put an end to that. The main point was just that something like SMB or NFS is not a good fit for a network which is not extremely fast and highly reliable because too many programs do blocking I/O. Dropbox works really well in that situation because it's asynchronous and that advantage was huge when they came out because everything was even worse back in 2007.
- gsich 8y agoI wrote "customers", not in the sense of "companies". With the later ones I get paid to wait if I have to use SMB.