2 ms·
We should try shutting down most bus systems outside major dense metro areas and start over. For example, I used to live in Orange County, California. There i
by logicgateandor 8y ago
We should try shutting down most bus systems outside major dense metro areas and start over. For example, I used to live in Orange County, California. There is no rail there, only buses. But whenever I saw the buses on the road, they were empty. And I rarely saw anyone at bus stops. But they have a huge budget, $290 million per year (https://www.octa.net/News/About/OCTA-Board-Approves-$1-3-Billion-Balanced-Budget/ https://www.octa.net/News/About/OCTA-Board-Approves-$1-3-Bil...) for bus operations. What a waste of money, empty buses driving around in circles.
Imagine if that money went to this instead:
* Estimate of $15 round trip per day for Lyft Line/Uber Pool for commuting to/from work. That's $300 per month. Create special Lyft/Uber cards and distribute to low income residents. $290 million/$300 = 966k low income residents. Note that the population of OC is 3 million. And this would be free for low income residents. Whatever they spend on commuting now can be spent for other non-commuting transportation.
* These MUST be used with Lyft Line/Uber Pool. Also these rides will be only pickup/drop off at bus stops. These requirements allow for massive routing efficiencies and the bus stop infrastructure is already designed for a lot of pickup/dropoffs.
Eventually Lyft/Uber will notice that certain stops are very popular. They may start asking drivers of minivans to cover these. As demand increases more, they may run shuttles. And some extremely popular bus stops may even have high capacity buses. But this will be a natural growth that reacts to demand. Ironically, the end result is a functioning bus system for some popular stops. But the key is that we get there by growing the system and the demand, instead of just throwing buses out there and hoping someone will use them.
- rovolo 8y agoYou're mixing per-month and per-year. * $300 (/person /month) -> $3.6k (/person /year) for your estimated Lyft Line. * $290m (/year) bus salaries / $3.6k (/person /year) lyft subscriptions = 80.5k people.