2 ms·
>Economics doesn't assume that actors are perfectly rational actors At the undergrad level, it often does. I had a friend who had just become an assistant prof
by BeetleB 8y ago
>Economics doesn't assume that actors are perfectly rational actors
At the undergrad level, it often does. I had a friend who had just become an assistant professor in economics. He was teaching an undergrad class, and wanted to pose a few scenarios to them. While preparing his lecture notes, he called me up and gave me the scenarios and asked how I would behave. These were not "hard" or "wild" scenarios. Mostly day to day stuff.
I gave my answers. On several of them, he told me I was giving irrational answers. This was a problem for him, because if his students answered likewise, they wouldn't support the points he was trying to make in the lecture.
He and I had a similar outlook on life. So I asked him: "Would you behave differently from me?"
Him: "No"
Me: "So what is the value of the economic model you're teaching if even you would not behave the way the theory indicates you would?"
As an aside, and this always comes up when we talk about rationality and economics. The disconnect is often that basic economics courses have a narrow view of people's motives and desires. It is often simplified to "optimizing for money" or "optimizing for time". Rarely things like "optimizing for mental stress". Pretty much everything someone does is for some perceived gain. That gain is often not what economists teach it is.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> At the undergrad level, it often does. Even introductory economics classes don't do this. One anecdote about a friend of yours who's an inexperienced instructor notwithstanding, if you look at any of the most widely-used and reputed introductory textbooks for undergraduates, you'll see discussion of rationality and the ways in which those assumptions can be relaxed. Just as people study Newtonian mechanics under idealized circumstances before they learn about friction and Van der Waals forces, people learn about the outcomes of rational behavior first, but it's ludicrous to judge an entire field by an outsider's perception of the topics covered during the first few weeks of an introductory course.
- tvanantwerp 8y agoI was once asked in an economics lecture what I would do in a particular situation. So I told the professor how I would try to proceed, only to be told that I was wrong--I would instead do this other thing that hadn't occurred to me at all.
- Noumenon72 8y agoEconomics is often right about that kind of thing. You think you will not snack as much if you put your M&Ms in a faraway place, but you end up doing the incentive-predicted thing and eating more M&M's each time you go to get some.
- zoomablemind 8y agoA similar observation on irrational choice vs. optimization can be borrowed from GPS navigation. Most of the time GPS offers an optimized shortest fastest way to reach a destination. Yet, often I may prefer a familiar route, or an 'easy' one (e.g long straight runs), or a 'scenic' ('cause it's that time of year) or some other irrational choice. Then would just absorb any resulting inefficiency as a fact of life (chalk it up in Debit column, if at all). So ultimately it's kind of optimizing for personal satisfaction (at the moment). Sticking to a rational discipline does bring satisfaction too.
- BeetleB 8y ago>or some other irrational choice None of those is an irrational choice.
- zoomablemind 8y agoSure, it makes sense to the actor himself. But to an external observer (say, who's going to the same destination) such choice does not follow common reasoning (arriving at the shortest). Gains of such choice are intangible (indeed personal satisfaction is subjective). At the same time, the 'loss' is very specific and measureable (extra time, fuel etc.) Thus in the context of a common measure such choice could be seen as irrational, especially when a rationally optimized choice is equally available.