4 ms·
"So the number of nukes has gone down, but the destructive power is quite similar" is very, very false. The military efficiency is quite similar, however, the
by PeterisP 8y ago
"So the number of nukes has gone down, but the destructive power is quite similar" is very, very false.
The military efficiency is quite similar, however, the destructive power has dropped significantly - these targeting improvements resulted in much less powerful warheads being necessary to achieve the same goal, so not only there's much, much less warheads (10000 vs 60000 at the height of cold war, and "only" 3000 of those 10000 are available at short notice) but also each warhead is much less destructive, the "default" warheads have gone down from multiple megatons to 100-150 kilotons.
This means that an all-out war will not only have much less fallout than in 70s, but also much less civilian casualties, much less destruction of cities, etc, etc. In the 70s, if a military base near a city would be targeted, then the city would be eliminated along with the base; now it'd likely be targeted with just something like 100kt bomb with much smaller impact; if the target was in the middle of the city, then most of the city would survive.
- pastage 8y agoIt is still perverse that we allow some few countries to stockpile 100 of thousands of Nagasakis. All of the world is held hostage to the whim of a hand full old men in the US, China and Russia.
- PeterisP 8y agoA big reason why this stockpile is considered necessary is to prevent questions in the form of "why should we allow ..." - if you have such a stockpile, then the obvious answer to any such questions is that you don't have to ask for permission for anything ever, as nobody can force you to do anything or prevent you from doing what you want, you have the ability to not care about what someone would "allow" you to do. This is the ultimate guarantee of "noone orders me around" sovereignty; if it was technically possible for the world to disallow USA, Russia or China "to stockpile 100 of thousands of Nagasakis", then it might become possible for the world to disallow USA, Russia or China some other actions against other countries or their own people, and that's not acceptable to their leaders.
- pastage 8y agoIt's good that you make the distinction between leaders and population, because when it comes to nuclear weapons we are all losers.
- nyolfen 8y ago“allow”?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- i88y6 8y agoThat is a really interesting point. We've been so conditioned that nuclear war == "end of humanity" that if it happened as you described, everyone would lose their minds for no real reason (inasmuch as the consequences would be no worse than for a conventional war). But taking that further, what is the point then, of taking out your enemy's bases or bunkers? I realize how dense that question sounds. But in the context of a surgical nuclear strike, ok you wiped most of their airbases off the face of the earth...now what? It seems rather pointless unless you intend to actually invade, in which case you're in for millions of very hostile civilians and not much to gain
- HarryHirsch 8y agoThe hostility can be dealt with, if you are sufficiently bestial. Reinhard Heydrich did suppress the resistance in Czechoslovakia, and the reprisals after his assassination convinced Allied leadership never to mount another assassination attempt of Nazi top brass.
- elipsey 8y agoThank you for mentioning this. It is an astonishing story that I did not know. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinhard_Heydrich#Assassination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinhard_Heydrich#Assassinatio...
- PeterisP 8y agoThe realistic scenarios of nuclear war occur as an escalation of some large scale conventional conflict. If you take out enemy airbases and nuclear capability, then you can use tactical nukes (or, more likely, you already started using them) to win that conventional war and achieve whatever goals you had in it. There's no reason to invade - just as with Japan in 1945, you can subjugate a country without invading it
- bryondowd 8y agoThat would seem to indicate that reducing civilian loss wouldn't be a likely result of targeting improvements. After all, we ended the war in Japan by intentionally inflicting civilian casualties to force surrender. Seems likely future leaders would make the same calculation. So, the strategy would likely involve destroying the opponent's ability to retaliate add then start massacring civilians until you get an unconventional surrender.
- mikeash 8y agoI'm not terribly comforted by this. The outcome would still be a disaster on a scale never seen before, and would wreck modern civilization. It baffles me how the threat of nuclear war has essentially disappeared from the public consciousness. People seem to think that the danger evaporated with the USSR, but it's still there, as likely as it ever was, quite possibly more so now that there are so many more nuclear powers.