10 ms·
Why Public Transportation Works Better Outside the U.S
- logfromblammo 8y agoBecause U.S. cities treat transit as a business or a utility rather than as infrastructure.
- osdiab 8y agoI think treating it as vital infrastructure is one way to get it to work properly (assuming federal, state, and local gov't can get their act together enough to do a good job of it), I don't know much about the historical precedent but I would imagine a lot of public systems in Europe work that way. But private companies seem to have done a good job of making Tokyo's system work well (see my comments above about how since they own the land on stations, they have a huge incentive to make it painless to get to them and derive profit from that); I wonder if given the general ineffectiveness of American bureaucracy right now, if a private approach with the right incentives would be more politically feasible. That all said, I think the article brings up plenty of good points about how transit has been hobbled in the USA, that aren't entirely attributable to the business vs infrastructure mindset.
- s0rce 8y agoCertainly doesn't help that car companies actively worked to dismantle the public transit systems and promote personal vehicles.
- rayiner 8y agoIt doesn't help, but it probably doesn't make much of a difference in the grand scheme of things. Why is the D.C. Metro or Atlanta's MARTA so bad? I don't think car companies had anything to do with it. Americans are just bad at transit. The people don't care, and the people running it have bad taste, are bad at management, etc.
- jeieo3949 8y agoDepends on what “grand scheme” you’re speaking to. Liberal and conservative think tanks have both concluded that the Interstate and road projects have never paid themselves off. The oil and gas companies have been hiding studies that there has been significant environmental impact due to burning those fossil fuels in all those vehicles for decades. And you seem to be waving away lobbying and concluding “America is just bad at it.” That’s a naive take on the history.
- noirbot 8y agoI'm not sure about DC, but for Atlanta at least it's really a question of density. Atlanta's one of the least dense major metros, so outside of the major corridors that MARTA already runs on, there's not a lot of big wins to be had by adding more stations. In my opinion, Atlanta's actually pretty well-built in a lot of ways. While MARTA is awful for commuter/everyday use, MARTA is effective for a lot of other things like getting to major events downtown, or getting residents and tourists to/from the airport. I'm not sure you could really make it all that much better without some fairly insane investment.
- smileysteve 8y agoAs a Marta daily commuter, it's all about where you choose to live and where your work is. Training from Midtown to Buckhead is easy, it's 5 miles (half the length of manhatten), getting to the airport is easy, exact times of 27 and 37 minutes, getting to Decatur for dinner is easy. Getting to Dunwoody and Sandy springs are easy, except when you get there everything except for State Farm is a long outdoor walk away though 4 lane car traffic and inadequate sidewalks. I used to even ride from Alpharetta to Buckhead when the buses had priority in the shoulder; it was much preferable to morning Rush hour(s) if you got on the highway after 7am
- noirbot 8y agoOh, I definitely agree and Atlanta's generally done well recently at building more things nearer to the stations. That said, unless you live in one of the areas you just mentioned, there's not a lot you can do. There's a ton of Atlanta along 85/75 that's mostly unserved by MARTA, let alone a lot of stuff outside of 285. Atlanta has a pretty rough last-mile problem just due to its density. Outside of midtown/downtown, a lot of the stations are pretty far apart by NYC/Euro standards. You mention Midtown to Buckhead, which is 3 stops on MARTA, being half the length of Manhattan. That's more than the length of Battery Park to Penn Station, which is 12 stops on the 1/2/3 line. MARTA is fine if you're mostly going from major area to major area, but if you want to go to somewhere like Little 5, you're kinda out of options in a way that the MTA seldom has issues with. I don't so much see this as something MARTA could really fix, but more just innate to Atlanta's sprawling geography. It's getting better, but MARTA pretty much cannot be what people want it to be.
- amyjess 8y agoYou're thinking of a common misinterpretation of the GM streetcar conspiracy. Everyone's heard of it, and it did happen, but there are two big misconceptions most people have of it: Misconception 1: GM and their cohorts bought out and shut down all the streetcar lines because they wanted to destroy public transit and promote personal vehicles. Reality: GM and their cohorts wanted to promote buses as a replacement for streetcars, because GM and their cohorts were the largest suppliers of buses and bus parts in the country. They stood to get filthy stinking rich off the replacement of streetcars with buses. Misconception 2: Streetcar lines were doing just fine and dandy before GM came along. Reality: streetcar lines were failing, and GM was able to do what they did because the owners of streetcar lines were desperate to sell before the bottom falls out. And keep in mind that GM was successfully prosecuted for this, too (and they absolutely deserved it).
- astrodust 8y agoNow we have Uber and Elon Musk's batshit stupid tunnel project nibbling away at it again. If they ever make a new Roger Rabbit for the 2020s I've got a villain for you...
- rayiner 8y ago> But there was a big difference between America’s approach to big urban metro projects and that of Canadian and European cities: Even when the United States built expensive rail systems, it never took care of the basics. This is a really important point. In many U.S. cities, even the public transit is more of an adjunct to driving. Here's the eastern terminus of one of Munich's S-Bahn lines: https://www.google.com/maps/search/munich++erding+train+station/@48.3040278,11.911279,192m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/search/munich++erding+train+stat.... Despite being about 25 miles outside the city, the area around it is developed and you can walk to the train station. In contrast, here's the eastern terminus of D.C.'s orange line: https://www.google.com/maps/search/new+carollton+metro/@38.9493696,-76.8738014,1305m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/search/new+carollton+metro/@38.9.... Even though it's only about 10 miles from downtown, you can't walk to anything from there. You can't even get a cup of coffee except at the little shop in the Amtrak lounge. Like much of the D.C. Metro, it was designed primarily for people to drive there and park. And somehow, even for people who drive there and park, it's off putting. There's a vast expanse of concrete you have to traverse just to get to the train from the parking lot: https://www.google.com/maps/search/new+carollton+metro/@38.9480302,-76.8718511,142m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/search/new+carollton+metro/@38.9.... It's so bad I actually started driving to a slightly further station on the blue line to get to one that doesn't make me want to kill myself every morning: https://www.google.com/maps/search/morgan+blvd+metro/@38.8936083,-76.8691199,362m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/search/morgan+blvd+metro/@38.893.... It's still got this completely unnecessary vast swath of pavement out front, but at least there's some trees. Compare those monstrosities to Munich, where the parking is right next to the tracks: https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjJkbyzqfzdAhWOTt8KHfNvDcMQjRx6BAgBEAU&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.merkur.de%2Flokales%2Ferding%2Ferding-ort28651%2F3-unternehmerkonferenz-stadt-erding-ringschluss-riesenschub-fuer-erding-9939555.html&psig=AOvVaw0XMsc7gyGC8oE6pESfC25o&ust=1539276316706943 https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=image.... A lot of the post-1960s "public transit" development is like the D.C. Metro's. These concrete edifices surrounded by vast swaths of concrete sidewalks and surrounded again by highways.
- ams6110 8y agoSome of it isn't that bad. Here's Lockport, Illinois Metra station. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Lockport+Metra+Station/@41.5842457,-88.0609657,368m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Lockport+Metra+Station/@41... Most of the suburban Chicago stations are similar. (Edit: I'd agree that most of Chicago's rail system is not "post 1960s" though). Chicago is a rail hub and most of the suburbs developed along the rail lines.
- tokyodude 8y ago> Figuring out how to improve transit isn’t like curing cancer or inventing a quantum computer, either. There are good, viable models of transit systems that already exist in cities that look a lot like U.S ones. They are successful both at attracting riders and at being financially viable, from places that have more in common with American cities than one might expect If that's the case then you'd think some company would step in to grab that "financially viable" market Tokyo's transit system is run by multiple companies. There are at least 10 different train companies many of which also run bus services. AFAIK they are hugely profitable. Many of them also open retail spaces and office spaces in and around the stations they run.
- osdiab 8y agoThe value of transit isn't the fact you rode on it, but the fact you get somewhere you want to go. Tokyo rail companies, and those of many other countries as well (Hong Kong comes to mind), also hold the ability to build shopping and apartments on the stations they build (if you've been, you've probably been to Atré, Lumine, Kirarina, Tokyu etc. station malls, and you've probably spent money in them), which more than reimburses the cost of the rail itself, because ultimately the point of riding a train is to get somewhere—and if the transit companies get the ability to own that "somewhere" themselves, it becomes immediately obvious how valuable transit is. In the case of San Francisco, hopefully the State of California Bill AB 2923 [1] passes—that's one step in realizing this model of integrated transit, housing, and commercial development, that just makes sense. [1] https://sf.curbed.com/2018/8/24/17778648/ab-2923-bart-housing-senate-vote https://sf.curbed.com/2018/8/24/17778648/ab-2923-bart-housin...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- downrightmike 8y agoGermany's Hauptbahnhofs are awesome. I saw a circus troupe preform inside one. They setup on the bottom floor and did acrobatics and you could watch them from the main floor a couple levels up.
- 8y ago
- throwaway456321 8y agoDoes public transportation always work better outside the US? Metra in Chicago is a heck of a lot more reliable than the likes of South West Trains and Govia in the UK. Metra even works in the snow! And in the 15 years I've been using it has not had one strike. Whereas London suffers rail and tube strikes every few weeks. Add to that commuting from the Chicago Burbs costs about 1/3rd of what commuting from the London suburbs does.
- astrodust 8y agoSome American cities get it, but even those are struggling because their systems are full of legacy problems that are expensive to fix yet don't provide any visible benefits. Changing the wiring on your subway so it doesn't catch on fire is really expensive, but nobody's going to notice if the subway doesn't catch on fire. London and New York have subway systems that are extremely complex and on the verge of self-destruction most of the time due to budget constraints. Other, newer systems have decades to go before they face the same crunch.
- osdiab 8y agoExcept it's on fire really frequently—track fires caused by garbage are a fairly common cause of NYC subway delays. NYC is also riddled with inefficiency and corruption that bloats the price of everything they build, which create and exacerbate those budget constraints. Costs per mile of new track and maintenance are consistently an order of magnitude or more higher in NYC than in other parts of the world, with higher rates of encountering problems; this may be partially due to the complexity of building there, but given that fantastically busy and complex cities throughout the world don't have these same problems, I'm much quicker to blame it on the political and economic system (which, tangentially, is why I think stuff like Musk's Boring Company are targeting the wrong issue when it comes to urban development, unless he's just trying to use that as a trojan horse for municipal influence). It's odd to see that such an extravagantly lucrative city can't seem to put together the money to maintain a core part of its infrastructure, that much much much poorer cities are able to achieve in other parts of the world.
- 40acres 8y agoLesson #1 seems deliberate to me. Post war, many urban centers in the US experienced white flight, it seems rational to assume that since these folks moved away from the cities to get away from minorities they would be against infrastructure that would allow minorities to "follow them" to the burbs. But these workers needed a way to get to the city for work, leisure, etc. What better way to circle that square by building massive infrastructure which requires a middle class income (which allows you to buy a car) to use? Even now we see lots of resistance by suburban communities to public transportation. In the Portland, OR metro area there is a upper middle class community called Lake Oswego, the residents have continuously lobbied against any form of public transportation in the town, lots of folks complaining about the "crime train". The metro transit authority which designs new lines has succumbed to the pressure and the newly proposed line while in the vicinity of Lake Oswego avoids the town completely.
- ip26 8y agoIt's a shame to see people campaigning against new regional transit lines, but I have to be at least a little sympathetic. BNSF runs through my town, and it does bring transients, plenty of whom do bring drugs, needles, & crime. No matter how you feel about train hoppers, that is a matter of fact in our town. To the downvotes I face, I'd be curious what you feel is incorrect in what I've said.
- astrodust 8y agoThis is exactly the mentality that makes getting public transit built a problem. Trains don't cause crime. The crime was already there because of a whole heap of deeply embedded issues in America that, for various reasons, Americans on the whole prefer to completely ignore. The problem is that trains make these problems visible. If you rip out the trains you're just sweeping it back under the carpet which is how America tends to deal with these things. If the best economic opportunity afforded by the trains for someone is crime that's saying something about your society, not the trains.
- 40acres 8y ago
- hprotagonist 8y agoWe also have a strong first-adopter problem: our rail systems were among the first, so we're stuck with some inherent design limitations that weren't an issue in 1890 but sure are now. For example, if you want high speed rail between major cites in new england, you're out of luck; the rails were laid out with curves and shapes that will not allow you to go fast. You can solve this, but the solution is to straighten out the rails -- and that means eminent domaining several billion dollars worth of Connecticut. I don't see that happening.
- StreamBright 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_State_Railways https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_State_Railways We had rails sooner yet we did not get stuck. Do you think that the size of US is limiting here?
- hprotagonist 8y agoThat's the other big problem, yes. See also the Netherlands. In the 70s they decided that bikes were good, and that paving over canals to let big trucks and cars take over was bad, and it was time to stop doing that and move to a better way. They got away with it because the Netherlands is 19 times smaller than the state of Texas.
- illvm 8y agoThere were other rails which ran between NYC and Boston which have since been shuttered, but were far more efficient. Problem is that there isn't a populated, straight line between NYC and Boston. So the curved rail road won out due to where people live. But that's not even the real problem. The real problem is that passenger trains do not have right of way on these lines. That belongs to the freight companies. So, on average, even Acela ends up averaging 65-70mph.
- hprotagonist 8y agoTo your first point: yes, that's part of why worcester and springfield have been dead since before the Civil War. And it's part of the context for "Ethan Frome". For better or worse, CT port cities proved better than rail to the hudson, especially once farming moved west. Right of way is another big issue, but even if it wasn't, Acela can't hit full speed north of NYC. It'd derail if it tried.
- forapurpose 8y agoI think to discuss it as a technical problem is to put their heads in the sand. It's a political problem - one of the two major American political parties opposes government spending on principle and also opposes public services in particular; they favor policies that increase profit to big business. In this comment I'm not saying that the party is right or wrong, but that these are the consequences of their policies, for good or ill. I understand that many would like to avoid politics. Citylab wants to focus on technical issues; Bill Gates cares about education, but AFAIK ignores how the same problem is one of the largest obstacles to improving education in the U.S.; people on HN are the same - they don't want to discuss politics. Don't discuss it then, but then the discussion you do have is as pertinent as talking about technical solutions to your overloaded bandwidth, which are well known, when the real problem is that the CIO intentionally underfunds it.
- baybal2 8y ago>Why Public Transportation Works Better Outside the U.S. Well, I have a much simpler answer than the article: 1. In US, the skill of public administration is not high enough to handle a complex system of public mass transit. 2. Any effort to just bring the transit to level of material parity with Europe is done the Soviet way: "I pretend to work, and you pretend to spend money" And explanation on point 2: why it takes a public transit authorities from two to three times more money to buy a bus than its market price? A bus costs more in paperwork, services, and interest than the price of its hardware to them! This is why American cities can't have clean new busses that say Germany have. It will need them a multiple of their budgets to do something a German city can do at 1/3 the cost.
- Salamat 8y agoBlame it on the auto industry they created the idea "jay-walking" which was introduced in the 1920's by them part of a propaganda campaign to claim the roads for cars and shift the blame in accidents from cars to pedestrians. They forced other countries some in the middle east to abandon public transport to promote cars. https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-26073797 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-26073797
- WhompingWindows 8y ago1. Low overall population density 2. Newer cities designed when cars were already king 3. Redesign of cities with the car in mind, due to fierce lobbying by car industry. 4. Hidden subsidies for cars, like untaxed carbon, untaxed smog leading to respiratory illnesses in cities, and of course free ubiquitous parking in so many areas. 5. Continuing lack of innovation, policy hold-ups, partisanship leading to gridlock, not to mention a public disinterest in using public transit.
- logicgateandor 8y agoWe should try shutting down most bus systems outside major dense metro areas and start over. For example, I used to live in Orange County, California. There is no rail there, only buses. But whenever I saw the buses on the road, they were empty. And I rarely saw anyone at bus stops. But they have a huge budget, $290 million per year (https://www.octa.net/News/About/OCTA-Board-Approves-$1-3-Billion-Balanced-Budget/ https://www.octa.net/News/About/OCTA-Board-Approves-$1-3-Bil...) for bus operations. What a waste of money, empty buses driving around in circles. Imagine if that money went to this instead: * Estimate of $15 round trip per day for Lyft Line/Uber Pool for commuting to/from work. That's $300 per month. Create special Lyft/Uber cards and distribute to low income residents. $290 million/$300 = 966k low income residents. Note that the population of OC is 3 million. And this would be free for low income residents. Whatever they spend on commuting now can be spent for other non-commuting transportation. * These MUST be used with Lyft Line/Uber Pool. Also these rides will be only pickup/drop off at bus stops. These requirements allow for massive routing efficiencies and the bus stop infrastructure is already designed for a lot of pickup/dropoffs. Eventually Lyft/Uber will notice that certain stops are very popular. They may start asking drivers of minivans to cover these. As demand increases more, they may run shuttles. And some extremely popular bus stops may even have high capacity buses. But this will be a natural growth that reacts to demand. Ironically, the end result is a functioning bus system for some popular stops. But the key is that we get there by growing the system and the demand, instead of just throwing buses out there and hoping someone will use them.
- rovolo 8y agoYou're mixing per-month and per-year. * $300 (/person /month) -> $3.6k (/person /year) for your estimated Lyft Line. * $290m (/year) bus salaries / $3.6k (/person /year) lyft subscriptions = 80.5k people.
- kodablah 8y ago> When transit service isn’t good, few will choose to use it. [...] improving American transit doesn’t necessarily demand multi-decade, hundred-billion-dollar infrastructure projects Yes, but it's not free either. Americans, for better or worse, just don't want to pay for public services they might not use. You see the private sector entering into agreements with localities to build toll roads knowing there is profitability. You don't see the private sector looking to enter mass transit presumably because of lack of profitability. One can argue for the social good to be borne by all, but surely there is a limit. Like it or not, you need majority support for public works projects, and it's not coming. Many of those who have flown to the suburbs have done so because of the propensity for their smaller city governments to not spend money on projects like these (or their increased voting influence to prevent it). So, unlike what the article states, you either have to give up on the suburbs or risk being voted out for giving up on the citizens' wants there. So your left with dense-urban-only transit because they are the only ones that want it. And it's ok. The want for quality mass transit outside of dense urban areas should be subject to the will of those that live there despite the objections by the ones that don't. If you want to tackle pollution as a matter of policy, so be it, but you can't make people ride a bus without doing so regressively.
- NotCamelCase 8y agoIs it really bad in the US or really good in Canada? I have a friend who has moved to Canada from Europe some time ago and he was complaining how it's not so efficient and you need a car eventually.
- bleair 8y agoI think it's also a cultural thing. Americans do _not_ like public transit. They'll tolerate it maybe (though they will complain about how taxes are too high, the transit itself costs too much, and how it's inconvenient). If you are successful, if you're happy, you own a car and you drive. As a example, if you've lived in LA just imagine how humorous it would be if a successful person you meet at a party or dinner said "yup, I took the bus to get here". Only the low income and undesirables are forced into using public transit. So station locations, and transportation that feeds into the public network will always be second or third tier. In Japan they have the ridership and society generally thinks good thoughts about their public transit.
- nine_k 8y agoThis is because LA is basically a giant suburb with a few city-like areas. USA have very few "proper", dense cities, in the European sense of the world. In these cities, like NYC and Chicago, public transit does quite OK. A lot of successful people don't own a car exactly because they can afford not to. Of course, most of the US territory, including most cities, and areas as important as major cities (see Silicon Valley) are suburbs, if not outright countryside. At a low density, public transportation makes much, much less sense, so it's not get built.