9 ms·
Capitalism is becoming less competitive
- S0ckpupp3t 8y agoIs it still Capitalism when there is regulatory capture?
- Buldak 8y agoTo the extent that regulatory capture is itself an inevitable outcome of capitalism, maybe.
- llcoolv 8y agoThis is the same as suggesting that organized crime is an inevitable outcome of human ambition. So sad.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoYou can't have regulatory capture without regulations! That is mostly tongue in cheek of course, but it does really bring up a point in that if there were stringent controls on regulation it could help minimize the issue. And if nothing else there's some beautiful irony in regulation being in need of regulation.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> if there were stringent controls on regulation it could help minimize the issue It would just shift attention to the organs of government controlling said regulation. The insight of democracy is it seeks to balance, not suppress, human nature. Capitalism and democracy healthily co-exist because the former produces the private property rights that keep state power in check. Keeping that checking function itself balanced is the crisis–and opportunity–of our modern era.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoAutomatic, mandatory scheduled review for regulations and mandatory sunset provisions for laws would be a damn good start. It would solve a lot of social issue too.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoAbsolutely. Another idea here would also be to require more than just a majority to pass a law, or 'refresh' it. It never made any sense to me that laws, treaties, and other decisions that seriously affect 100% of people end up getting passed by 51/49 majorities. If laws required e.g. a 75% vote, then we would need to work with one another to create ideas that are globally beneficial, ideally helping to mitigate some of the increasing partisanship today. Given that we're split just about down the line it means both parties will invariably have their time in control which removes the necessity of working together. So people are just increasingly radicalizing on one side or the other and then hoping for 'their side' to force whatever they want done, through. It doesn't feel like this is really in the spirit of democracy. Of course this is all mental masturbation since none of this will ever happen. But for the next nation starting from scratch, we will have an even greater base of knowledge to grow from. I think there's no doubt that the United States went from backwoods outpost to most powerful nation, in the blink of an eye, largely because we were able to learn from and avoid the mistakes of other nations that had become so entrenched in their ways that change became unreasonably difficult -- similar to the state we are in today.
- philipov 8y agoI think it's more appropriate to call it Corporatism now.
- ChristianBundy 8y agoYes. Just like socialism is still socialism when there's corruption. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman We need to accept that capitalism seems to be prone to problems relating to regulatory capture and find a solution that resolves these issues. The idea of a perfect and pure "capitalism" is a myth.
- anon49124 8y agoTrue. There's never has, and never will be, any "pure," utopian socialism nor libertarian anarchism, just messy reality with varying levels of gotchas, power concentrations, totalitarianism and corruption. The best people can do is diffuse power and install individuals whom are fair, reasonable and put society / greater good before personal gain... without many of these sorts of people, the crooks win and tear civil society down.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoWhat is with this ever present desire to blame concentration on regulatory capture? When Adam Smith wrote about competition he was writing about pre-industrial business, small shops with apprentices and journeyman, mostly horizontal and small organizations. With the industrial revolution that was all turned on it's head as economics of scale began swamping other factors. So we went from lots and lots of small competitors to (just) lots of medium competitors. And as technology has advanced economies of scale just get better and better so now we're down to a few large competitors. Concentration and the diminishment of competition is a totally expected result of giant technology gains.
- Avshalom 8y agoCapitalism, as distinct from just a market (let alone a free market) economy, is based on the idea that ownership creates value thus entitling the owners of capital to some fraction of it's production and to a lesser extent the idea that anyone-can/everyone-should be an owner (as opposed to a feudal system with hard line serf-lord/owner-renter separation) Regulations, regulatory capture, corruption, market failures; that's all broadly orthogonal.
- notabee 8y agoYes, because any system that allows corporate entities to amass significant wealth will see those entities using that power to create and capture regulation for their own benefit. Unless a counter mechanism to mass media and bribing politicians can be created, the general public and their governmental power will inevitably be neutered by wealthy interests. Regulatory capture and monopolies are features of capitalism, not bugs.
- purple-again 8y agoInteresting article. I wonder if anything major happened in the world around the early 90's that could help explain why the big winners around the world were suddenly able to use their economies of scale to grow even larger over the next three decades...
- platz 8y agoIs it still Capitalism when the government prevents the "fair market" from operating by issuing all sorts of subsidies, and allows all sorts of exemptions to let specific employers avoid having to pay certain taxes, giving them a competitive advantage over companies that don't get those exemptions? How Government Creates Inequality - David Cay Johnston https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VApBedmawnM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VApBedmawnM
- norseman 8y agoYes, it is.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoThat's the strange thing about governments - no matter what you do, you find there's always a government somewhere.
- johnchristopher 8y agoIs it still Capitalism when private companies lobby governements to implement subsidies ?
- platz 8y agothat exactly johnston's point, in case you misunderstood political intent
- llcoolv 8y agoSaying that regulatory captured capitalism has failed is like putting Michael Phelps in chains, throwing him into the sea and claiming that swimming has failed.
- tanderson92 8y agoMarxists would counter that capitalism will lead to a oligarchic elite, or at the very least powerful industries which will seek to influence and capture the political and regulatory system using the excess value taken from labor. So, it's like timing Phelps in the rapids leading to a waterfall and blaming the waterfall only for the rapid plunge.
- llcoolv 8y agoWell. Is that a problem of capitalism? Or the inadequacy of political systems?
- notabee 8y agoPolitical systems depend on power exercised by people to enforce law. When the real power transfers to the wealthy, which in peacetime happens as surely as large masses draw objects into orbit through gravity, they will use that power to draw in even more power and wealth. The only protection is politicians, and other democratic counterbalances like the justice system and the media, acting in good faith. History has shown repeatedly that that cannot be depended on. All it takes is for one generation's politicians to defect for personal gain and the avalanche of corruption starts. Wealth is power, capitalism amasses wealth, and wealth will blindly hoard itself to death. If one wealthy entity abstains, other wealthy entities will grab that power instead, because that power will insulate them from any consequences of doing so. Believing that politicians will ever extricate themselves from the influence of wealth and power by their own volition is ridiculously utopic.
- llcoolv 8y agoI have a question. Why are the justice system and media expected to act in good faith, but industry leaders are expected to be crooks? Nowadays with all the statistics available it holds true for almost every country that politicians, lawyers and journalists are in fact the least trusted people. I think it is for a good reason and it is called inherent hypocrisy. Also, how could two entities be counter-weights to each other if both aim for the same thing - wealth. The only solution I see is to strip all the societal roles, who claim to be driven by good faith, of all property and relationships. But this is even more ridiculous than what we have right now.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoTwo words: Regulatory capture. I can't turn my hobby/side gig into a small business without navigating a bunch of bureaucracy to obtain 9001 permits, some of which are inevitable "may issue". Assuming I made it through that I'd be subject to all sorts of government oversight to the point where I either have to sink all the resources I would spend growing my business on compliance or just not think about it and hope that by the time anyone notices my business is big enough to afford the cost of compliance. For programmers, lawyers and other occupations that don't deal with physical things the issue isn't as big but for blue collar businesses this is a big deal. You literally cannot hope to comply with everything when you're in the boostrap phase and that dissuades a lot of people from striking out on their own. The fundamental problem here is that laws and regulations written to deter some mega-corp from systemically being sleazy to make a buck apply equally to small businesses. turns out it's only the mega-corps that have the economics of scale to make compliance possible while still making a profit.
- fenwick67 8y agoOn the other hand, small business owners shouldnt be allowed to be sleazy either. Maybe to stimulate small businesses, the government could advise business owners how to navigate these regs, something like a social worker for a business?
- zzzcpan 8y agoStimulate is the wrong word here. To avoid harming small businesses regulations usually need to exclude them completely or at least don't put the same regulatory burden on them. But with all that lobbying and regulatory capture harming small businesses is the whole point of regulations.
- pg_bot 8y agoThe classic example would be food companies requiring the use of a commercial kitchen for selling food to the general public. There are a lot of fledgling businesses that have been shut down immediately because they cannot build capital while they are still in their cottage stage. While it is perfectly fine to invite my neighbors over and cook for them, it immediately crosses the line when I want to sell to them. I think it would be smarter to have progressive laws based on the number of servings instead of immediate high barriers to entry. So you still need to use a commercial kitchen, but only once you serve more than say 5,000 customers per annum. I think most people would believe that this is reasonable. There are countless industries that I think should have similar cottage exceptions.
- djschnei 8y agoBetter title: Corporatism was never competitive
- citilife 8y agoOne thing that people seem to skip in Capitalism is the idea that you can't have a tone of regulations. It appears the U.S. version of capitalism is continuously granting the "winners" in sectors with such strong regulations that it's limiting newcomers -- making it less competitive. The current fashionable thing seems to be claiming that we need to become more socialistic. Which IMO is just an attempt to fix over regulation with more regulation... so down the rabbit hole we go.
- zimablue 8y agoIt seems like it's not more regulation vs less regulation but rgulation in the interests of society vs regulation in the interests of the powerful. America has very lax rules on political donations from corporations, allowing almost unlimited lobbying. Plus a two-party system and the ration of population=>votes being very uneven.
- beaconstudios 8y agoregulations seem insanely hard to design well. It's very easy to claim you're regulating for the good of society, but have said regulation have a completely different effect. They're far from a panacea.
- zimablue 8y agoThe way I think about it: you have lots of problems in society which are prisoners dilemma in nature. The only way for the prisoners to escape their fate is to have some external authority fix the incentives and that's basically the law. Three ways to use the law: Regulation Sueing people for damages Complex contracts There are situations where some of these work better than others and we just need to pick. It's really hard to imagine sueing for damages working precisely for something like preventing air pollution, the chain of causation is too long. You have no choice other than regulation. There's this libertatian politics common on HN but I've never seen a convincing argument of how you solve air pollution using 2. or 3. Imo you will always need regulation.
- DrNuke 8y agoAt its best, regulatory capture is a mean to achieve basic quality assurance; at its worst, it is a fence to protect the richest. Our mileage may vary, we see the world through our own experience and rightly so.
- 40acres 8y agoHow competitive is capitalsim anyway? What's the best measure for it? When I look out in the economy I see massive industries that are being protected by their governments for various reasons: some of it political, some of it effective lobbying. In many sectors private companies are building off of a platform that their government has provided for them. For instance, the NIH is a major contributor to pharmaceutical research, yet once a new drug comes to market, the profits all go to the private company and the tax payer is essentially charged twice for access to the drug (cost of research and cost to buy the drug). I had one idea of what a free market was growing up, but as I've learned more about the global economy it seems like the idea of a free market was just a clever ruse.
- nickpsecurity 8y ago"How competitive is capitalsim anyway? What's the best measure for it?" I look at stuff like this among a group of suppliers: 1. What suppliers offer in terms of product, capabilities, etc should be going up. 2. If comparing two versions of something in No 1 overtime, then... 2.1. Quality/reliability/security should go up over time. 2.2. Price should go down. 3. Customer service should improve over time given it's an easy differentiator. 4. Convenience of any aspect of the business should go up over time. Low-hassle in general. You'll find in monopolies or cartelized oligopolies that these are all bad or move super slowly in a way that keeps everyone high margin. In highly competitive industries, things move fast with many players having low margin.
- spectrum1234 8y agoProfit margins. In general the lower, the more competitive. Historical average in US is 8.5%, 9-10% more recently. This is pretty competitive! Although a bit less recently because profit margins went up ~1.5%. This is also, generally, why different industries have different profit margins. Here, its even more obvious.
- mabbo 8y agoTechnology is playing a role. So it size. Google/Amazon/Facebook/Netflix/Microsoft can drop a few million bucks on a team of developers trying to squeeze some lemon for an additional drop of juice. I've been on teams before where a 1% increase in success of our software would pay for the team twice over. There were dozens of teams beside us all doing the same thing. A small business competing in the same market cannot do that, and so they find themselves fighting a far more efficient giant.
- rainhacker 8y agoWhy is this post flagged ?
- gricardo99 8y agoI'm guessing "off-topic"[1] 1 - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ardy42 8y agoSome people's core ideological beliefs are structured around the idea that free market capitalism is the best economic system, and they perhaps find it uncomfortable when those beliefs are challenged.
- bediger4000 8y agoHow much of a role does secret government intervention play? That is, we know the US government interferes in markets in secret. There have been lots of revelations in the past few years about how the CIA boosted jazz and modern art during the 50s to appear new and modern relative to communist countries of the day. The NSA advised the creators of DES about how to make it better. There have almost certainly been other secret and larger interventions. Has the CIA/NSA/whatever intervened to an extent that the resulting markets are inefficient? We'll probably never know, but my guess would be that at least secret interventions have favored certain companies to the detriment of others in the same market.