3 ms·
In my previous job, which was security-related, we had to deal with people forgetting their 2FA credentials (and many, many people forgot their credentials, eve
by StavrosK 8y ago
In my previous job, which was security-related, we had to deal with people forgetting their 2FA credentials (and many, many people forgot their credentials, even staff members). The way we did it was thus:
If you had enabled 2FA, it could be disabled/reset by calling support and adequately proving you were the owner of the account. This had to be this way, because, as I said, everyone forgot their 2FA credentials ("my phone fell in the sea and the backup codes were on it").
We also had another checkbox that said "Never, under any circumstances, reset my account. I have stored my backup codes somewhere secure that is not my phone. I understand that, if I lose access, I lose the account."
If the user checked that, then the password/2FA reset system for the admins got disabled for their account. If they lost their 2FA, nobody short of DBAs could reset their account (and DBAs knew not to).
Additionally, we had a screen where you could print a long, random, one-use key that would reset your account. It would come with a nice QR code so you could physically print it on a piece of paper and store it somewhere, and scan it if you ever forgot your 2FA/password, and it would let you access your account.
I should probably write an article about this...
- giancarlostoro 8y agoYeah I hate when sites force one approach or the other, having the option to permanently lock yourself out seems the best, if I don't want to be permanently locked out, let me fallback to a SMS text.
- ClassyJacket 8y agoSMS is an absolutely unacceptable system to require for authentication. I just went overseas and got locked out of half the apps on my phone. Some of them permanently. Tinder now bans your account for life if you ever change phone numbers. I suppose if it's just one option then it's okay.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI think if you arent willing to fully lock yourself out if you lose your backup code, it should be a fallback that you can get a text, otherwise rely on a 2-factor app. Key would be that nobody in support should have any access to change your 2 factor number or disable 2 factor. Now if you lock down your account to just your backup code, no SMS, no take backsies.
- sho 8y ago> Tinder now bans your account for life if you ever change phone numbers Huh? I've got at least 5 different SIM cards for various countries and I've never noticed any issue with Tinder. I didn't even know it used your phone number for anything. For SMS auth it's usually no big deal to put back in your old SIM if it needs to send a 2FA code; even the most brutal roaming charges won't come to more than a dollar or so for a single SMS.
- jsjohnst 8y ago> even the most brutal roaming charges won't come to more than a dollar or so for a single SMS Receiving SMS is generally free (or goes against your monthly bucket) while roaming. I’m actually not aware of any cell carriers (and I have SIM cards from over a dozen providers each in different countries) that charge for receiving anymore, but leaving a little wiggle room in my statement above just in case there’s an odd ball out there.
- kbutler 8y agoCruise ships: https://www.cruisecritic.com/articles.cfm?ID=1752 https://www.cruisecritic.com/articles.cfm?ID=1752 It's possible to send and receive text messages at sea, as long as you have a signal through your ship's roaming network (just make sure you turn off data roaming in your settings). Texting costs a lot less than a voice call -- usually in line with standard, international "pay as you go" rates: Most major carriers charge $0.50 to send a message ($0.25 for a picture or video message); AT&T also charges $1.30 for an outgoing picture or video message. For messages received, Verizon charges $0.05/text ($0.25 for a picture or video message), and Sprint charges $0.05, while T-Mobile and AT&T deduct incoming messages from your monthly allotment.
- tinus_hn 8y agoSMS is insecure and not a secure form of 2fa, never mind a secure password reset option.