3 ms·
I would suggest that the problem is too much wriggle room / dissonance during the design process (in nice safe meeting rooms admittedly) We can all persuade ou
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
I would suggest that the problem is too much wriggle room / dissonance during the design process (in nice safe meeting rooms admittedly) We can all persuade ourselves that as all items are ticked, the job is done.
But testing gives the lie to all this. The patriot system was battle tested in the 1990s and its deficiencies became apparent - and lessons seem to have been learnt.
So perhaps more adversarial testing is the right approach - set the marines to take out the air forces weapons, the navy to destroy the army.
If people know their beloved weapons systems are going to get roughed up, then the tick box stops being the determinant of achievement - it becomes "what would one of those navy/marine/air force/army bar stewards do?" That's a much higher bar.
tl;dr blow shit up and see if it still works
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI always assumed the US military does such tests routinely. Don't they?
- lifeisstillgood 8y agothe fact that this one test is news suggests, no. I seem to remember a story about "how good is the SAS" because they were asked, after years of development, to try and destroy an armoured train that carried nuclear material from power plant to disposal (it ran through populated areas so was proof against head on collisions at a gazillion miles per hour and so on) The guy took a calor gas canister, filled the train half full of gas and lit it. The armoured million dollar train of course ruptured with the internal explosion. kudos to the well trained SAS demolitions expert, but i suspect a lot of the army could have done that, at various earlier stages. not sure where that is going, except, yeah blow things up, early on.
- abledon 8y agoNow -that- sounds like a fun job to have that comes with lots of dinner stories to tell. Course I guess they’d assassinate the guy if he was telling these stories Willy nilly (to protect national secrecy)
- pjc50 8y agoYes, but they don't always want to hear a negative result, e.g. in Iraq wargaming: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2002/aug/21/usa.julianborger https://www.theguardian.com/world/2002/aug/21/usa.julianborg...