7 ms·
"They are consistently bogglingly bad at human interaction -- communications, PR, management, UX, customer service." I don't think that's actually true. In pa
by nostrademons 8y ago
"They are consistently bogglingly bad at human interaction -- communications, PR, management, UX, customer service."
I don't think that's actually true. In particular, I think that Google for most of its history was masterful at PR and communications - they managed to maintain a very positive public image all the way through 2011, despite being both far more powerful, more naughty, and more ruthless than the general public saw them as. I think management and UX are also quite strong at Google - they're known for sparse design and UX fails, but there's often a lot of subtlety to how Google products are designed that makes them very effective for their purposes. They did always suck at customer service, though.
Rather, I think Google's hubris is...hubris. They feel the need to have their fingers in everything. It's not enough to be the world's best Search company or even organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful, they also need to be the best social network, and best cloud provider, and best AI company, and best mobile-phone OS, and best web browser, and best daily deals site (remember their aborted Groupon purchase, soon followed by a competitor?), and do government contracts for the military, and get into China, and build self-driving cars and robotics, and be a major payment provider and operate half a dozen different chat services.
Most of the PR, communication, management, and UX fails are forced errors. They happen because there's an inherent contradiction in Google's business model. You can't simultaneously market yourself to engineers with "Don't be evil" while devising ways to help the military kill people more accurately or censoring Chinese search results; hell, at some point the military is likely going to have an issue with China potentially hacking into Google's cloud infrastructure through their partnerships. A surprising number of the UX fails also come about because some executive is protecting their turf and won't let the obvious integration & UI simplification happen even though both engineers and customers want it.
- ddebernardy 8y agoGetting bad commentary on geeky/nerdy HN is, almost by definition, bad communications/PR for a tech company. Getting into too many fields and ending up all over the place is bad management. Executives protecting their turfs may indeed be a recipe to getting bad UX, but that doesn't excuse the fact that it's bad UX or that bad UX is all over Google. If anything the latter points towards more bad management. And as you wrote, customer service has always been bad.
- dunpeal 8y ago> Getting bad commentary on geeky/nerdy HN is, almost by definition, bad communications/PR for a tech company. Except there's always going to be some critics, especially when you're talking about a corporation of Google's size. There's going to be people concerned about privacy, corporate overreach, the nature of some of its activities (such as defense contracts). You will also get various biased opinions, such as people who were hurt in some way by Google: rejected candidates or businesses that folded due to some Google service grabbing their market share. Hell, even if Google religiously avoided all the above, you will still get some astroturfing campaigns by its competitors! Negative commentary on a niche website like HN doesn't actually mean much in the grand scheme of PR. Check what the average person thinks about Google. Most likely you will find it quite positive. If you're looking for a company with serious image problems, compare to Facebook.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TuringNYC 8y ago>> Getting into too many fields and ending up all over the place is bad management. I'm glad Google (and Apple and Amazon) got into the phone business, the camera business, the phone service business (Google Voice), the car business (Waymo) and the entertainment business (Youtube, Music, etc.) The status quo was so awful (remember cable TV contracts with 200 channels you didnt want to watch?) and has finally improved with the tech giants putting pressure in cushy lazy incumbents. Same for self-driving cars. Where were the efforts before Google and other tech giants go into the game? I seem to recall only incremental innovation for decades. What I really wish is that they didnt botch some of these things (Google Voice is a great example of an amazing product with massive underinvestment (abandonment?) from Google.)
- voltagex_ 8y agoI think you're still seeing these companies as startups. They're in incremental innovation mode now. I'm biased, because I was hoping Amazon would come in and wipe the floor with Australian retail, but it's been kinda lukewarm. We also missed out on Google Voice, will miss out on whatever TV play they're making with YouTube.
- dunpeal 8y agoExactly. I don't know how Google is "bad at PR" when the company maintained a sparkling image since its inception - arguably, to this day. For common person, who doesn't know or care about lethal security work or sophisticated privacy concerns (which aren't even easy to explain to your average non-techie), Google is this high-flying company full of brilliant people who are eager to provide him with a peerless search engine, a great webmail, and many other great services "for free". All that while their primary business is advertising - not generally a well-liked industry. Their PR management is so great that most people would be shocked to realize they're even in advertising at all. The company also has a great reputation among engineers, and is among the most desirable employers not just in its field, but in the US in general, at a time of a booming job market with plenty of other great choices. I also don't know about those "UX failures". The company has several web-based services that have effectively beaten all other services, including desktop-based services in their field. Do people forget this feat was considered impossible back when Google got started? This was no easy feat - Google realized none of the browsers that existed back then was up to the task, so it launched its own browser (!) with a revolutionary new Javascript engine that was an order of magnitude faster than anything else at the time. This was an incredibly ambitious technology project, and they made it a huge success. So while Google certainly has its failures, and we can expect more of those as it keeps its unrelenting march to become one of the most powerful corporations that has ever existed, describing them as bumbling fools who always botch "human interaction" is simply false and misleading.
- slededit 8y agoThey haven't really been challenged. For much of the past 20 years tech was seen as the one part of the American economy that was working. Nobody wanted to tip over the apple cart with "excessive regulation". The true test of any company is how the behave in bad times. And lets be honest even the measly bad press they now receive is a fraction of what other industries put up with. They are handling it poorly in comparison. For comparison the banking sector managed to take down the entire economy and came out of it virtually unscathed by Washington. That is successful PR and lobbying.
- dunpeal 8y ago
- autokad 8y ago> "In particular, I think that Google for most of its history was masterful at PR and communications - they managed to maintain a very positive public image all the way through 2011" I feel like this is in part because the people that write bad things about other people owned google stock or had many close friends in google.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoGoogle are accidental PR geniuses. The whole 'do no evil' thing was instinctive PR, not really thought out in the den of some PR genius. They made their brand synonymous with the word 'search' - my god man, that's worth billions, minimum. They've done it in an oddly naive 'authentic' way, by I think truly believing their own schtick, and drinking their own coolaid. And I'm not nearly as cynical as the above posters, Google is way more ethnical that most companies. My god man, if Google wanted to they could change electoral outcomes, simply form a massive hedge fund and beat everyone at investing, do evil things the likes of which we've never hard of. I'm constantly impressed by how actually objective they've been about a lot of stuff given 99% of other CEO's would have abused the data position a long, long time ago. Not to say they are perfect, but ... compared to most, they have been pretty good. Though that's changing. They've done it without any hardcore ad spends, or any real classical marketing attempts to make us believe things one way or another, so kudos on them. But yes, they are kind of bad at most classical parts of marketing, communications ... heck even some kinds of product management. But the 'Engineers first' mentality got them where they are, I'm going to doubt that part of their DNA will change.
- ars 8y agoDo no evil was a reaction to Microsoft. I don't know how old you are, but back in the 1990's/2000's Microsoft actively tried to destroy/takeover the internet (in favor of desktop and/or vendor lockin), and Google's "Do no evil" was a reaction to that: A promise to grow the internet. And they kept that promise! Look at the internet today. Microsoft is no longer "evil", and the internet is fine, so "do no evil" is no longer necessary. People assumed do not evil had something to do with privacy, or this or that, or lots of other things people read into it. It didn't. It was just one thing: Open standards and promoting the open internet.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoI'm old enough to be an Engineer living 1k away from Google when it was born. I'm not sure if I believe DNE was exactly about Microsoft, rather a more general mantra. In 98' the founders were running around giving talks about how 'advertising was ruining the internet' which wasn't really an MS things. So I think MS was just one factor, but yes, most don't remember a time when they were so dominant.
- sealthedeal 8y agoI dont think most people are qualified enough to give an opinion about how Google operates...
- joyeuse6701 8y agoThe don't be evil mantra was problematic before the questions of military contracts or Chinese censorship, the answer to 'what is evil' is subjective. But I am surprised by the naivety of employees when they are upset that their company fails to live up to their literal interpretation of a company motto.
- e40 8y agoCase in point for UX: new gmail, hover over an email address, select add contact. Works for me about half the time. Edit contact fails for me 100% of the time. Been like this for months.
- pjmlp 8y agoReally hate the new UI, but they removed the option to go back to the old one. Thankfully, unless they remove IMAP access it isn't something that I have to deal with most of the time.
- karmakaze 8y ago> also need to be the best social network, and best cloud provider, and best AI company, and best mobile-phone OS, and best web browser This is an overstatement. Yes, they want to stick their fingers in all the pies but they don't try very hard and cancel products on whims too. Search and its revenue is all they cared about. I would actually commend Google on that focus where most others would lose themselves in the mix. Search, Gmail, Docs were their major contributions. Chrome browser is based on Apple's WebKit.