3 ms·
A brief romantic encounter at UC-Davis triggered an absurd Title IX process
- creep 8y agoI'm glad this is finally being talked about more openly. Most of the stuff I've seen regarding issues of false accusations comes from MRAs and the like. And while I don't see an issue with MRAs as a rule, the general public seems to take issue which means that most of the discussion coming from men's rights forums isn't taken seriously. I've been nervous about this issue since the #metoo movement and "believe the victim" slogans first started making rounds. As a female who has been assaulted and violated sexually at various points in my life, my instinct is to support believing the victim because had I been believed, I would have gone through far less pain. But that's the problem. It seems like a good idea, especially to people like me who have experienced sexual violence, but it is not at all a good idea. You cannot sacrifice innocent lives to make sure that every victim has justice. That's not justice! We face a really difficult obstacle right now. Many victims do not have proof that they were assaulted, especially if they were not penetrated or also physically assaulted, which means that many victims will never get justice if we do not automatically believe them. That's uncomfortable and painful, but that's an issue we have to sort out while also understanding that our axiom "innocent until proven guilty" is an axiom that also prevents abuse.
- commandlinefan 8y agoIt reminds me of the security guard paradox - companies that hire security guards rarely see break-in attempts, so they might be led to believe that the security guard isn't doing anything. But if they get rid of the security guard, they'll suddenly see break-ins - the security guard was discouraging would-be attackers. In the same way, it's probable that with the checks and balances in place to limit the damage that false accusations might do, one might look at the rarity of false accusations and say, "hey, this is practically never happening, we can loosen the restrictions here a bit" only to see it suddenly used as a weapon because it's now suddenly effective.
- throwaway5250 8y agoThank you for posting this. I've never been assaulted, but I've been on the receiving end of some really shitty behavior. I won't deny spending a lot of time wishing vengeance. But I also think that if the cost for it were harm to innocent bystanders, that cost would be too much. It seems to simply be a burden that we have to carry.
- anon7429 8y agoWomen can do whatever they want now with no accountability and no recourse. Opt out of the bullshit by not playing a game stacked against you (interacting with random people), otherwise it's playing Russian roulette; which is pure stupidity.
- nikkiofearth 8y agousername checks out
- gammateam 8y agohm, although our opinion is framed by the way the article is written, compared to the information the faculty unilaterally received, I would say that the accused was a victim here I think saying "don't blame the victim" would refer to all parties involved and becomes a matter of perspective in a circumstance where there is always someone to blame, so perhaps that should be rephrased as "don't blame the accuser"?
- anon7429 8y agoNever. Trust. A. Woman. Period. It ain't worth it.
- dang 8y agoWe've banned this account. Would you please not create accounts to break the site guidelines with?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nikkiofearth 8y agoAbsurd is definitely the key word here. This is a hype piece? Let's find out! Hint: Isn't it strange how the author didn't want to reach out to the victim least she harm him more? I will address each point in turn chronologically. TLDR; Educate yourself people! FUCK! First off: the mother. Everything seems to be going fine until that fateful phone call with her mother.(See how I can villainize with so little effort?) Real talk tho, that woman pushed it during the phone call. I can see why, I would also be protective of my little girl who just got out of a bad thing. Second: A chance to speak. When Becky first accused him of assault during their Monday meeting James could have not only apologize, but also offered to talk to her again about the matter when he wasn't feeling "terrible". There was a lot of ambiguity around what Becky was saying and what James was thinking she was saying. >>"Becky then asked James whether he knew something was wrong. James replied that he indeed suspected something was amiss, thinking she was referring to the status of their relationship. But she was evidently asking whether he knew something was wrong with touching her that way—and thus she took his response as a kind of confession." Maybe here would have been a nice time to have the other side of the story.... Next: Other chances. Instead of clearing the air, making sure Becky was ok, talking to the drama teacher(this chance would have given him a nice paper trail too), etc; James "did his best to avoid Becky for the rest of the semester, and went out of his away to avoid making eye contact, or being too close to her in class." Sidebar: That's what someone who wanted to be my friend would do.>> James told her he understood, and asked whether they could still be friends. Next: The point. Here is another place Becky's version might have lent some clarity. After avoid all contact with her, they cross paths at (the most awkward of all places) the gym. Not wanting to make it _more awkward_ >>... he "pointed at her in a friendly way." "That's a universal gesture right?" he said. "Like, hey there? I just kind of pointed at her and gave her a smile and then rushed out of the building." Next: EDUCATE YOURSELF PEOPLE. fuck! James receives the notice from of the Title IX investigation, sat through math class, then went home and lay down. A google of what his rights were, what he signed off on being a student there, how to proceed in general really...nope. In the uni's [policy](https://policy.ucop.edu/doc/4000385/SVSH https://policy.ucop.edu/doc/4000385/SVSH) they are mandated to educate students about these matters, so there would have even been prior opportunity to ready himself. Next: His parents. These parents also didn't react well here. Both jumped fast to believing their son was a pervert. Maybe they didn't know how to use google? Next: The lawyer. Sounds sketch right.off.the.bat. telling>> him, "If everything goes south on us, don't kill yourself." This is a professional? Next: EDUCATE YOURSELF PEOPLE. He is right >> you can't just say, 'I don't know, there should be some sort of investigation process,'" says James. "You'd get crucified for that." But does he go to the class? Learn how to bring up the subject politley? Nope. Note: This might also have led to another chance to clear things up. I don't understand why the lawyer was brought into the picture at all. James was not paying for the investigation, no criminal investigation was made, the only issue was that it took some time for the uni to drop the issue. Finally: Reason.com. This is not a journal of repute. https://www.sitejabber.com/reviews/reason.com https://www.sitejabber.com/reviews/reason.com https://www.reddit.com/r/skeptic/comments/47mtdk/how_reasonable_is_reasoncom/ https://www.reddit.com/r/skeptic/comments/47mtdk/how_reasona... https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Reason_Foundation https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Reason_Foundation