4 ms·
"Who else might get their hands on these devices in the shipping chain?" From the original Businessweek article: "Supermicro has assembly facilities in Califo
by tyingq 8y ago
"Who else might get their hands on these devices in the shipping chain?"
From the original Businessweek article:
"Supermicro has assembly facilities in California, the Netherlands, and Taiwan, but its motherboards—its core product—are nearly all manufactured by contractors in China."
- bonestamp2 8y agoI have to assume we'll start to see a rise in American high tech manufacturing for security purposes alone. Some of these companies may want to manufacturer these critical components themselves, maybe even hand deliver them from their US factory to their customers in the US too. I know that some refineries do direct delivery for some of their large customers, especially industrial lubricants and other by-products. If the order is big enough, or someone wants to pay the premium, then direct delivery could be very feasible for tech too.
- rjurney 8y agoWhat high technology manufacturing America does is in the security space, otherwise Japan is a trusted source.
- Klathmon 8y agoIs there any way to solve this problem without needing a "trusted manufacturer"? I know it won't probably won't apply to general purpose motherboards or devices, but is there a way to design or build some components or devices in a way that you can verify that they can perform their purpose and nothing more? If we start with that concept, and slowly build up "verifiably secure" components, they can be the islands of security that we can build off of without having to worry if the manufacturing plant left their door open one day and some random person was able to sneak in.
- nosuchthing 8y agoWhat happens when your attacker knows how your safeguards work and can route around your door though the windows? For a motivated and well funded attacker who has an ability to manufacture a replacement chip with an additional coprocessor that can siphon or modify data from the main processors, network cards, and baseband modems, short of decapping every chip and component that comes through your assembly line your resources would be better spent on establishing trust mechanisms with your suppliers and the transportation couriers touching your devices before the end user acquires it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tailored_Access_Operations#Known_targets_and_collaborations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tailored_Access_Operations#Kno... http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/the-nsa-uses-powerful-toolbox-in-effort-to-spy-on-global-networks-a-940969-3.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/the-nsa-uses-power...
- Klathmon 8y agoMy thought was it would be something that would get more secure the more knew about it, similar to math proofs or cryptography code. A way to verify a chip is working as expected in a way that it can't be gamed without breaking multiple fundamental proofs, so that you won't need to worry as much about who makes it, just that it "passes the tests". (and you'd probably need a system to validate the validators, but splitting up the people involved means it is significantly harder to hack multiple products to all have them falsely verify each other) Obviously I have no idea what I'm talking about and am just kind of musing at the idea, but trying to secure the whole supply chain from digging materials out of the ground all the way until it is in the hands of the consumer seems like an exercise in futility. You'll never be able to secure it in all cases, and like you said a truly motivated attacker is going to be able to break the chain (even if it means threatening a handful of people with death so you can get 5 minutes alone with a board).
- FooHentai 8y ago>we'll start to see a rise in American high tech manufacturing for security purposes alone. Already exists in the form of 'country of origin' procurement for high security applications.
- cyphar 8y agoIt's odd to me to assume that people should trust US-based supply chains. We know that the NSA has done supply chain attacks in the past[1], while in this case we only have allegations of China doing the same (don't get me wrong, I wouldn't be surprised if China did this, I'm just saying we have more evidence for the NSA doing it). Personally, as someone outside the US, I would gladly trust alleged Chinese malware over known NSA malware. Or even better, literally any other country outside the 5-eyes. [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/may/12/glenn-greenwald-nsa-tampers-us-internet-routers-snowden https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/may/12/glenn-greenwal...
- rsync 8y ago"Supermicro has assembly facilities in California, the Netherlands, and Taiwan, but its motherboards—its core product—are nearly all manufactured by contractors in China." That's interesting. As someone who has bought hundreds of thousands of dollars of gear from Supermicro (and has been a huge fan of their products and designs) I always thought their chassis were their core product. Recently SM started to go down the "you can't buy our JBOD chassis without buying them full of our qualified drives" ... I knew that was the end of the golden age (of SM). Luckily this coincided with the introduction of the 60bay HGST JBOD chassis. We haven't looked back.
- lozaning 8y agoEvery storage vendor eventually goes full NetApp. The money just looks too good.
- phil21 8y ago> Luckily this coincided with the introduction of the 60bay HGST JBOD chassis. We haven't looked back. Yes, these units are stellar and anyone buying Supermicro JBOD units should be looking into these as much better replacements. If you have volume they can be even more competitive than Supermicro if you push.
- rsync 8y agoOne very, very small gripe is that the HGST JBODs have no power switch. You power them on and off by inserting or yanking the power cables. Not my favorite SOP ...
- dylan604 8y agoIs that a real thing? Holy cow, I'm shocked (bad pun intended). What about adding an inline switch in the cord? Unless they expect everyone to be using a managed power system where each plug can be turned on/off, this just seems very odd decision to make. <off to look up this beast>
- 8y ago