5 ms·
I sometimes think that they answer to the Fermi paradox is that the universe is an exceptionally dangerous place. Even when intelligence evolves, it has to dodg
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
I sometimes think that they answer to the Fermi paradox is that the universe is an exceptionally dangerous place. Even when intelligence evolves, it has to dodge a whole bunch of bullets from the universe randomly sterilizing chunks with GRBs.
- clubm8 8y ago>I sometimes think that they answer to the Fermi paradox is that the universe is an exceptionally dangerous place. Even when intelligence evolves, it has to dodge a whole bunch of bullets from the universe randomly sterilizing chunks with GRBs. Or maybe since all this started with the big bang, there's some other civilization at a similar level of development at the opposite end of the universe - so far away we'll never cross paths? Or maybe there's only 1 intelligent form of life per universe, but many universes?
- ChuckMcM 8y agoIf you have read Fermi's paradox you know that it deals with only the visible stars in our own galaxy. The question he posed is why hasn't one of those planets orbiting one of those stars already created a galactic civilization that colonized the Milky Way. It could be that we're the first/only group to achieve sentience in the galaxy but the probability of that being true is astonishingly small. (Hence the paradox) The conjecture is essentially a "negative space illuminator" which is to say it suggests there is some piece of information that exists but is not currently known that would resolve this apparent paradox. If we were to discover that events happened every 'n' million years or so that sterilized stars in a 'm' thousand light year radius, a function of these two components would tell us for what values of n and m that would cancel out the survival and thus emergence of intelligent species.
- stickfigure 8y agoHow about: The physical laws of the universe just don't allow a practical way for us to interact. "Space is big." Science fiction authors can imagine all sorts of ways we could communicate or travel across interstellar distances, but really we have no idea how to build them. Maybe there just isn't some new discovery to be had.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoTraveling across interstellar distances is not sci fi, at least not the act itself. What is sci-fi is an engine capable of accelerating for a sufficiently long period of time. Something people often mistake is that the speed of light is a hard cap on travel rates. It's more complex. More educated individuals tend to think that as objects approach the speed of light, their mass approaches infinity - that is correct from the perspective of an observer. But from the perspective of something continually approaching the speed of light, there is no effect on your mass. This is where time dilation and space contraction come into the picture. Anyhow, setting aside all of that stuff the important thing is that if we can manage to generate engines capable of creating fairly modest acceleration (e.g. 1g) then interstellar travel is completely possible within a single human lifetime. There is a calculator here [1]. The relativistic effects are exponential but to give some examples: - 100 light years of travel = 9 years of 1g acceleration - 1000 light years of travel = 13 years of 1g acceleration - 1 million light years of travel = 26 years of 1g acceleration - 15 billion light years of travel = 45 years of 1g acceleration To be clear this gets into the fun time games of relativity though. Though you may be able to travel 15 billion light years in one human lifetime, from the perspective of an at rest observer (such as everybody back on Earth) - 45 billion years of time will indeed pass during your 45 year journey. So, for instance, the sun will have long since turned into a red giant by the time you arrive. This leads to really interesting 'paradoxes'. You could leave Earth on your relativistic starship towards some system billions of light years away. And when you get there you find that the system is completely colonized and hyper modern. Earthlings that left a million years after you got there first and colonized the system millions of years ago. They traveled at 2g acceleration... Reality is much stranger than any sort of fiction. But anyhow of course the issue is just discovering a technology to enable years of 1g acceleration. And while that may be far away, I think few would argue it's something that will ultimately prove to be impossible. [1] - http://convertalot.com/relativistic_star_ship_calculator.html http://convertalot.com/relativistic_star_ship_calculator.htm...
- leetcrew 8y agoeven if such travel became possible, what could motivate anyone to actually do it at scale? if they're anything like humans, there would probably be a few crazy beings who would do it just to do something extreme, but aside from escaping a dying world, i can't see any reason why such a journey would be attempted at scale. what's the point of having a galaxy spanning civilization when the origin system would be destroyed every time you made a roundtrip?
- nwallin 8y agoThe other resolution to Fermi's paradox is much simpler and much less interesting. Maybe interstellar travel is as difficult as all our scientists tell us it is. No civilization has colonized the Galaxy because it's simply too difficult. Maybe FTL travel really is impossible. Maybe SETI hasn't detected anything because generating a signal loud enough for us to detect is a stupendous amount of energy, and it's simply too much energy for a single planet civilization to justify using on a radio transmission that's going to travel at most a quarter of the way across their star system. Maybe all the science fiction we love so much really is just fiction.
- ubercore 8y agoEven without FTL travel, on galactic timelines, we could presume to see colonization spread very rapidly through the galaxy. For example, this answer on quora shows with some pretty conservative timelines, the galaxy should still be riddled with life: https://www.quora.com/Could-the-answer-to-the-Fermi-paradox-be-that-travelling-faster-than-light-is-just-not-possible-If-you-have-to-spend-500-000-years-traveling-to-Earth-your-ships-would-have-to-be-extremely-comfortable-Why-would-you https://www.quora.com/Could-the-answer-to-the-Fermi-paradox-...
- mcbits 8y agoThose timelines don't seem very conservative. 1% sounds like a nice, small number, but 1% of the speed of light is insanely fast. It's about 200 times faster than our fastest craft to date. We might envision launching a probe 200 times faster in the future, but a colonization ship would also weigh millions of times more and have to slow down somehow. It's not clear that we'd be able to do that in 10,000 years (or ever) with "shoot stuff out the butt" propulsion, so we'd probably need propulsion based on different physics which may or may not actually exist. We'd definitely need new physics for constant 1g acceleration into relativistic speeds. Maybe we could hitchhike on progressively faster interstellar asteroids or something, but that would void the assumption of having the ability to reach all parts of the galaxy.
- pixl97 8y agoEh, the slow travel still has lots of issues. You have to travel with a massive amount of mass. Space is really dangerous. There are high energy particles that want to mess up your 'ship'. Even worse things like neutral hydrogen are hard to block with energy style shields. Then you have the issues of long times without high gravity. Then you have to carry enough 'stuff' and energy to recycle absolutely everything you need, ever.
- AgentME 8y ago>It could be that we're the first/only group to achieve sentience in the galaxy but the probability of that being true is astonishingly small. If life is extremely rare, then that doesn't seem so unlikely. If life were so rare than on average, after 15 billion years, only one out of every trillion galaxies has life evolve, then every instance of intelligent life should see itself as being alone. I think people are too quick to write off the possibility that life really is this rare. I think people reason "if life were so rare, then I wouldn't be here to exist to think about it", but I don't think that's a correct way of thinking about it. If life is really that rare, then the rare instances of life could all think that same thought process too, and they'd clearly be wrong. Maybe if life is super rare, we should expect to find ourselves in a much older universe, but maybe this current age of the universe is actually more suitable for life than other times. (Some crazy hypothesizing: If you accept the many-worlds interpretation, maybe periods early in the history of the universe, before the universe has branched so many times, in some sense have more "measure", and so observers are more likely to find themselves here. This is definitely a more "out there" idea; I'm not hingeing anything off of this idea, but I think it's worth mentioning while thinking about the anthropic principle and fermi paradox. I'm also hesitant to give it too much weight since if branching happens uncountably many times every moment, then if this effect does apply, then I'd expect it to overwhelm almost everything else and we should expect to find ourselves at the absolutely earliest possible moment. Arguments about when we should find ourselves in history seem to always go weird -- see the Doomsday Argument.)
- scott_s 8y agoIn case you missed the "Dissolving the Fermi Paradox" action a few months ago: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=dissolving%20the%20fermi%20paradox&sort=byPopularity&prefix=false&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=dissolving%20the%20fermi%20par...
- oAlbe 8y agoThis makes me wonder about the details of such a sterilizing event. How would it actually work? Say the Earth was in range of a supernova explosion, or in the path of a GRB. How would we go out? Would the planet be thrown off its orbit and wander away from the warmth of the Sun, letting us die a slow, freezing death? Would the planet simply be vaporised? Would the atmosphere be incinerated, and anything below it suffocated for lack of oxigen, or maybe burnt by unfiltered solar radiations? Would it leave the planet mostly there, and just destroy anything organic on it? Would it be an instantaneous event? One moment we are there, and one nanosecond after that us and every trace that we ever even existed will be vanished. Or will it take longer? Will we feel it, feel pain, or recognize that it's over, that's it?
- dnautics 8y agoProbably a grb would only nuke a bit more than half the planet,though. There would be diffusive, reactive conversion of the atmosphere to some nasty stuff with lots of acid rain, but that is likely to be survivable over the long term.