3 ms·
Another way to think of it, other than the other fine posts: Imagine you are selecting your random number by using a ten-sided die and writing down the number o
by jerf 8y ago
Another way to think of it, other than the other fine posts: Imagine you are selecting your random number by using a ten-sided die and writing down the number of each (fair) roll. Suppose you assume you are going to write down a rational number. What does that imply? It means that your fair die is going to roll some prefix, and then roll some infinitely repeating segment over and over again. As you roll the dice an infinite number of times, what is the probability that your die will ever deviate from the necessary strict repetition of the repeating segment? It is literally 100%, because no matter how many times it happens to conform to the repeating sequence, there remain an infinite number of rolls remaining in which to deviate.
If it absolutely never deviated, over the course of infinite rolls, that would itself be proof that the die is itself not a fair die. e.g., if your putatively "fair ten-sided die" rolls up precisely 1/3, by virtue of rolling an infinite series of 3s, then that would be proof that it is not in fact fair and random.
I think this helps the 100% intuition. It is simply impossible for a truly random selection process to produce a rational number.
- JadeNB 8y ago> As you roll the dice an infinite number of times, what is the probability that your die will ever deviate from the necessary strict repetition of the repeating segment? It is literally 100%, because no matter how many times it happens to conform to the repeating sequence, there remain an infinite number of rolls remaining in which to deviate. While I think that accumulating as much intuition as possible is a good idea, I'm afraid that this intuition may be misleading. The problem is that there's no roll at which we can give up and say "oh well, we deviated from the pattern and aren't rolling a rational number", because we have no idea in advance when we've entered the repeating portion of the decimal expansion. That is, if we roll 0.000123456789, and then roll a 6 rather than a 1, we can't conclude that we're rolling an irrational number; all we can conclude is that, if we roll a rational number, then the repeating portion of its decimal expansion either isn't 123456789, or else hasn't begun yet.
- jerf 8y agoFor any given rational number, my argument holds. I meant to type "suppose we're going to roll a particular rational number", but I see that I neglected to edit that in. For any given roll up to a certain point, there are a finite number of rational numbers that you could be rolling. For any given one of those numbers, my argument holds. There is never a point at which any rational number you could be rolling has a probability greater than zero.