3 ms·
> basic human right You mean "entitlement". In the US, "rights" are inherent and natural things; those outlined in the constitution are "negative rights" in th
by zdragnar 8y ago
> basic human right
You mean "entitlement". In the US, "rights" are inherent and natural things; those outlined in the constitution are "negative rights" in that they are prohibitions on the government infringing upon them.
As such, "medical care" doesn't make sense as a right, because it's a service provided to you, not inherent to you in the sense that speech or association between individuals.
Of course, "entitlement" as a word comes with a negative connotation around here, but that's also because most or all entitlements are means-tested and not available to everyone.
As for you the cost, you're spot on. Insurance for myself and my wife is roughly $1000 / month (paid for by my company of 8 people). An active lifestyle won't compensate for things like pregnancy, Alzheimer's, osteoporosis, glaucoma, arthritis, or any other of the innumerable ways that our bodies have yet to catch up with our lifespans.
- yokaze 8y ago"Rights" is the correct term. A right is an entitlement. To my knowledge, the differentiation in law is Negative and Positive rights: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights
- mrslave 8y agoPrivileges and rights are the terms I was taught in place of positive rights and negative rights, respectively, in your link. I think they are better terms. Privileges impose an obligation on others. Rights do not. Positive right is very similar to the equivalent alternative term (privilege) but negative rights unnecessarily confuses the conversation. Is there an impact on others and is it really negative? It appears to simply be used in the opposite of positive right but the adjective negative is misleading.
- wz1000 8y agoI am not convinced that there is any meaningful distinction between "negative" and "positive" rights. Take property rights, the classic example of a "negative" right. But what are property rights but an entitlement that the government will protect your property? What use is the right to fair trial without an entitlement that the government will provide you a lawyer and select an impartial jury? What use is a "negative" right to liberty or free speech without an entitlement that when someone tries to infringe these rights, the government will protect you?
- coretx 8y agoThe intellectual meaning of rights and rights-philosophy is long gone everywhere, today the law is nothing but the will of the powers that be. Keeping that in mind, i can tell you from memory that property rights and it's philosophy in the US are based on the British definitions and those are based upon Lockean principles, based on a believe in natural rights. In a nutshell the fruit of your labour and being the first to appropriate creates your rightfull property. Legally having property therefore does not mean the government will protect it per se. People who are against Lockean definitions tend to mock saying "Planting a flag ( first appropriation ) allows me to rape and pillage a country", something the british did with lockean arguments to justify the behaviour. We're lucky to note however that in most schools of rights philosophy; there is a monopoly on violence owned by the state, not it's citizens.
- vixen99 8y agoits philosophy
- cayblood 8y agoThe problem with the Lockean conception of rights is that merely improving some natural resources doesn't necessarily entitle a person to claim ownership. It doesn't factor in any externalities resulting from the appropriation, nor does it factor in the inherently communal nature of human life and the fact that no human can practically be reared to maturity without a community, and that therefore our appropriation of limited resources (property) affects our surrounding community in potentially negative ways.
- lurquer 8y agoIt's a little more complicated than that. To take an extreme example, in some cases you can use force (even deadly in some states under certain circumstances) to exclude trespassers from 'your' property. Thus, the right to property is not only a right to have the gov't protect it for you, but also a restriction on the government from prosecuting you for certain acts taken by you on your property.
- koboll 8y ago>As such, "medical care" doesn't make sense as a right, because it's a service provided to you, not inherent to you in the sense that speech or association between individuals. Guess we'd better scrap that whole "right to an attorney" portion of due process, then.
- barry-cotter 8y agoIANAL but isn’t that a right to have a lawyer if you can afford to hire one? I know you’re not going to be provided with a lawyer at the state’s cost in civil cases though that’s not true in criminal cases. If you can’t afford one you’ll get a public defender. IIRC Peter Thiel said that if you have less than $100 million your access to the courts is more theoretical than actual. Hulk Hogan certainly couldn’t have afforded to bring Gawker down by himself and it’s not like he’s poor. Fix: Allow people to sell, or sell shares in, their right to sue.
- codetrotter 8y agoI didn’t even know Gawker shut down, but apparently they did since 2016. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bollea_v._Gawker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bollea_v._Gawker http://gawker.com/how-guilty-should-i-feel-1785565192 http://gawker.com/how-guilty-should-i-feel-1785565192
- dmurray 8y agoThis already is allowed in many places, including "most US jurisdictions" according to Wikipedia[0]. There's even a YC company that does it, which was discussed here when they were looking to fund lawsuits against Equifax[1]. The practice is called champerty or litigation funding. The fact that this is not more popular suggests that litigation is not efficient for the rich, either. In the end it only enriches the lawyers. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_financing https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_financing [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15249825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15249825
- microcolonel 8y ago> Guess we'd better scrap that whole "right to an attorney" portion of due process, then. "You have the right to have an attorney. If you cannot afford one, one will be appointed to you by the court." is the language intended to be used in the Miranda warning; and it is not so much that you have a right to an attorney, but that your right to a speedy and public trial (...and to have the Assistance of Counsel for [your] defence) combines with the state's mandate to prosecute your case to produce a mandate to provide you an attorney. The "right to an attorney" is a colloquialism for referring to the state's obligation to fulfill the requirements of a constitutional trial if they want to try at all, which in practice either means the state hires public defenders, or the state can not try you (though this wasn't done in practice until it was interpreted this way in court). There are other legal colloquialisms such as "jury nullification", which is an emergent behaviour rather than an explicit one.
- KaiserPro 8y agoIts article 12 of the UN's International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights as adopted in 1976 by the USA and 160 other countries.
- sthgrau 8y agoFwiw, the USA signed but did not ratify it, so it not adopted by the USA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Covenant_on_Economic,_Social_and_Cultural_Rights#Reservations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Covenant_on_Econ...