2 ms·
Indeed, this seems like the wrong matching model if you want either (a) expert review; or (b) representative user review. A random other website-developer isn'
by gojomo 16y ago
Indeed, this seems like the wrong matching model if you want either (a) expert review; or (b) representative user review. A random other website-developer isn't especially likely to be either. There is great value to the ad-hoc, user-driven matching of people with topics that occurs on sites with a public new-queue and topic-leaderboard.
And so this reminds me of an idea for a more focused version of HN I'd had a while back. Let's call it 'Bluntr' for now. All stories are requests for review of work: code, designs, websites, products, whatever. All comments are supposed to be brutally direct feedback, with as much concrete backup-data/recommendations as possible.
Note that this does not mean 'nasty': no mockery or vague insulting filler words would be permitted. But it also means every thread can jump straight to the point, without traditional 'attaboy!' or 'I like the X but...' niceties slowing things down. Essentially: at Bluntr, empty compliments or insults would both be flagged/downvoted to oblivion, while steely-eyed evaluation would be promoted.
The community might not gel without those normal verbal ticks and grooming-activities, but then again these ground rules might help the really focused, strong contributors cut to the chase a lot faster. You are not allowed to be either nice or nasty, just honest -- and so you are free to be more productive. That's the initial theory to be tested, at least.