7 ms·
"I have to make sure I go home to my family at night," Well, in that case- maybe don't become a police officer? I mean, I don't know that I've ever heard a fi
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
"I have to make sure I go home to my family at night,"
Well, in that case- maybe don't become a police officer?
I mean, I don't know that I've ever heard a fireman, or a doctor, a rescuer, a
lifeguard, etc, say that sort of thing - "my first priority is to go home
safely tonight". That doesn't mean that they're expect to sacrifice their
lives in the line of duty, it means they're expected to risk their lives, to
save someone else's (the doctor, if you were wondering, because they can
easily catch something nasty).
The police officer who made the comment shot a szhizophrenic woman who was
holding a knife (that's all we're told about that case). So presumably he shot
her because he was afraid she'd stab him. Presumably, also, that was part of his training.
That is very dangerous. Giving someone a gun and telling them that when
their live's in danger their priority is to come out of it alive, is dangerous
for everyone around the person with the gun. Because the easiest way to make
sure you "go back to your family" when you have a gun and the crazy lady is
holding a knife is to shoot her dead. I mean, duh.
I should also probably point out that I think this is a peculiarly US thing.
I doubt that anywhere else in the developed world police officers are
adviced to shoot first and ask questions later, or in any case,
as a first line of defense.
- akerl_ 8y agoThey definitely tell lifeguards and firefighters and first responders that their "first priority is to go home safely tonight". If you have a small group of people who can help, and a much larger group that need help, it's critically important that your helpers don't get themselves killed by being reckless with their own lives. The overuse of force by police in the US is terrible. It's a combination of bad judgement, bad training, and no repercussions. But that's fully separate from the fact that "keep yourself alive" is a core tenet of all the jobs you listed.
- rrauenza 8y agoThey also express it that "now we've got N+1 victims we have to rescue, and one less helper."
- GW150914 8y agoThere’s a difference between telling people to not put themselves in risky situations thst will just lead to adding a casualty (firefighter running into a collapsing building) and shooting people to “be on the safe side.” The equivalent for a cop would be to wait for backup, not murdering someone else because they’re scared.
- craftyguy 8y agoThey generally do not give lifeguards, firefighters, and first responders firearms and instruct them to kill the survivors if they feel like their life is in danger.
- Spivak 8y agoIt's not very often those people are being attacked on the job though, seems like the right analogue would be training on when to let someone in danger die. Having went through lifeguard training the very clear message was that if you feel unsafe in a situation or can't subdue someone who's dragging you down you preserve your own life first.
- paulddraper 8y agoThey don't tell them to directly kill anyone. Because very few people attack firefighters. Indirectly, however they do recommend that. If the burning building is very dangerously unstable, firefighter SOP is not to enter to try to save anyone who might still be alive (nor permit others to do the same).
- isoskeles 8y agoI don't understand why people are typing on this thread as if the officers shot this man to death with bullets. It seems disingenuous.
- rahimnathwani 8y ago"Tragically, Magdiel never heard the police commands - because he was deaf. During the stand-off, neighbours shouted to the officers to tell them this, but they shot him anyway."
- scarface74 8y agoThere is a huge difference between “keeping yourself alive” by not going into a burning building that there is a huge risk that you won’t come out alive and you won’t help anyone and shooting an unarmed person just in case they might be carrying a weapon. As a police officer, they signed up for an increased risk of death (even though statistically it’s not that dangerous). I as an African American, didn’t sign up to be shot just because I “look suspicious” for living in a predominantly White neighborhood.
- elipsey 8y agoI am extremely sympathetic to this view. I think it's hard for some people to appreciate how others are policed, because they have not experienced it first hand. I have lived in all sorts of neighborhoods, and in some I was repeatedly searched, restrained, and detained. I had broken no law, and I have never been charged with a crime. Not everyone can simply avoid interacting with the police by virtue of their behavior, and interacting with the police is dangerous even when one is trying to be compliant.
- fucking_tragedy 8y ago> Not everyone can simply avoid interacting with the police by virtue of their behavior, and interacting with the police is dangerous even when one is trying to be compliant. Yep. If you haven't been in this situation, there really isn't anything comparable to having each word spoken and action made taken as a immediate threat by an officer with a gun who is visibly high from the adrenaline rush they got from the situation.
- isoskeles 8y agoDid you get shot?
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoLook, what I'm saying is I would never expect a fireman to say "I didn't go near that burning house because it would have put my life in danger", or for a doctor to say "I won't treat this Ebola patient because, dangit, Ebola". The people in that kind of job put their ass on the line to save other peoples' bacon and accept that their job carries a risk. They won't actively try to harm another person (a person, btw, they're supposed to protect) to avoid getting killed. Imagine a lifeguard who bonks a panicked swimmer on the head and lets him sink, because "when they start panicking they can pull you under, so it's my life or his". That would be completely mad, wouldn't it? You'd expect the lifeguard to be trained to deal with that sort of thing wihtout having to kill someone they're trying to save in the first place. And like I say, obviously, nobody expects, or asks those people to lay down their lives in the line of duty. But they're there to handle dangerous situations that not everyone can handle. Right? That's what the police are there for. If someone tries to rob the bank, they're supposed to stop the robbery. It's a dangerous line of business. Of course they shouldn't get killed while at it, but if the best they can do to keep alive is to execute everyone around them, they shouldn't be doing that job. They're supposed to be cops, not Judge Dredd.
- isoskeles 8y ago> (a person, btw, they're supposed to protect) Do you suppose maybe the officers' intent was to protect the person who called them? I'm not happy this happened, and I think some blame can be put on the culture of police officers using violence as a solution to many problems, but I also think a lot of blame can be put on the culture of people-not-knowing-their-neighbors. I would want to know more about my neighbors before calling the cops on them, even if they did some crazy thing like walk around the hallways naked or yell or scream.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> Do you suppose maybe the officers' intent was to protect the person who called them? The officer's stated intent was to go home to his family that night. That's what's bothering me. He didn't try to explain his actions in terms of protecting the public from a potentially dangerous individual, he put it in terms of protecting himself. So what's going to happen if you give a man a gun, tell them "protect yourself first" and send them in a situation where someone might put their life in danger? I think it's obvious- they'll shoot the person putting them in danger. To protect themselves.
- washadjeffmad 8y agoI suppose I've never thought about a lifeguard intentionally drowning a panicking swimmer (or preemptively drowning someone who appeared not to be abiding pool rules) because they wanted to ensure their own or other's safety. Likewise, firefighters are tooled for survival in the environments they're expecting to work. Police share more of their tooling in common with robbers and kidnappers than with lifeguards or firefighters, who we don't regularly see them killing others. If we made regular police white glove, non-lethal social servants and only minimally armed them (or not at all), would this decrease violent escalation? We'd need to treat mental health crises as medical situations and have an armed response division trained in deescalation, but I think the current belief in us vs them and commonplace sanctioning of deadly force are wounds on our society that need to be healed.
- betenoire 8y ago"This kind of people (criminals), you cannot treat them as if they were normal human beings, ok? We can't let policemen keep dying at the hands of those guys," Bolsonaro said on TV Globo's main nightly news program. ""If he kills 10, 15 or 20 with 10 or 30 bullets each, he needs to get a medal and not be prosecuted." Add Brazil to the list. I'm sure it's not a US only thing at all.
- wild_preference 8y agoYou don’t realize you’re talking about a completely different victim here? Do you think he’s talking about schizos?
- bachbach 8y agoThe US has its issues but nothing to complain about in comparison to Mexico or Brazil. 50,000 murders a year - that's a low intensity war.
- clarkmoody 8y agoYou're concerned about the symptom of a deeper problem: lack of consequences for trigger-happy police. The courts and police are on the same team. I'm still waiting for a convincing Third Amendment challenge to the militarization of the police.
- rrauenza 8y agoI've been reading (and watching) content on both sides of this to gain a better perspective. Firemen definitely do also have a mentality of no unecessary risks -- which, yes, is a little different. But there is a mentality of 'I want to go home tonight.' Cops risk assesment is a different situation than rescue -- it's a matter of intent. In a rescue situation, there's uncertaintiy in the physical environment. In law enforcement, the risk is that the subject actively wants to hurt you. Also, society in general has become more risk averse. One thing I have a better appreciation for now is how fast a situation can turn bad for a cop. There's an ex-cop who has a youtube channel under the name Donut Operator who breaks down cop videos. It has opened my eyes to why cops react certain ways in certain situations. It has helped me understand better when a shooting is justified -- or unjustified. Still, I think as a society we've swung too far into moving the risk onto the citizens -- and the most vulnerable take the brunt of it.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoWell if that society supports the Second Amendment it has made a choice. Acceptable collateral damage.
- arcbyte 8y agoThat's certainly true in a limited sense. We are accepting collateral damage from the second amendment. No doubt about it. People are dying from the availability of guns. The great bet of the second amendment, though, is that those deaths are far fewer than the deaths that would occur if our government were not regulated away from tyrant and towards liberty by the threat of an armed populace. I firmly support that bet.
- krapp 8y agoYou've been downvoted, but you're not wrong... I've heard that precise argument made by gun control opponents more than once, usually after the latest school shooting.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> Firemen definitely do also have a mentality of no unecessary risks -- which, yes, is a little different. Yes- unnecessary risks. Some risk is inevitable when you're doing that kind of work- putting out fires, rescuing swimmers in distress and so on. And those people put their lives at risk as a matter of course. A while ago I got my ass pulled out of a very, very hairy situation by a lifeguard. He basically put himself in the same mess I was in to pull me and a friend out. I remember looking at his face and it was obvious he didn't know if he would make it out alive. If that guy was a police officer trained to put himself first, he'd have kicked us back in and saved his ass. Instead, he waded in some really bad waters and pulled us both out. Obviously, I'd never ask the guy to risk his life for me and my friend- but he totally did. That, for me, puts all that "I have to go back to my family" stuff in a very negative perspective. Yeah, as a police officer you need to make sure you go back to your family- you need to make sure everyone goes back to their family.
- da_chicken 8y ago> I mean, I don't know that I've ever heard a fireman, or a doctor, a rescuer, a lifeguard, etc, say that sort of thing - "my first priority is to go home safely tonight". I mean, I've definitely heard firemen say that or express a similar sentiment. Much of their training involves not taking risks even to rescue someone because cowboy fireman tend to turn one casualty into two. I've heard similar things from lifeguards, but it's usually stated that the idea that their goal is for everyone go home safely. Lifeguards typically carry the buoy because they train to save people by giving them that. They train not to swim up and grab someone in distress, but to give them a buoy. That prevents the victim from attacking the lifeguard or clinging to them and drowning both of them (which happens when people panic during a rescue). Don't get me wrong; I 100% agree that a police need to de-escalate more often instead of immediately resorting to physical or violent responses. I agree that militarization of police only serves to emphasize police vs citizen mentality that leads to escalation. I think they should use better judgement with high speed chases as well as confronting individuals. But to argue that "keep yourself safe" is something that only police teach is complete nonsense. > I should also probably point out that I think this is a peculiarly US thing. It's also relatively irrelevant. The US has a lot of peculiarities due to it's culture and history that make it difficult to compare it to the average western European country which is almost universally what this comment means. That's why it's always followed up with some comment about "the developed world" or "the first world." "Why can't you be more like Sweden/England/Germany/France?" Because we're not any of those countries. Yes, the US has problems with violence. It's not a secret. Our violent crime rates are very high even though our non-violent crime rates are typically much lower than other developed countries. No, we're not happy about it. This is not something we can magically fix by changing a few laws. Crime is a culture problem and an economic problem, and those are both very hard to fix. Think of it like this. Have you ever seen the streets in China or India? How chaotic and out of control all the drivers seem with no respect for more regimented and safer driving? You don't fix that by copying Germany's driving laws and signage and applying them to the roads. That won't actually change anything. To change that, you have to change the driving culture. You've got to get people to believe that they need to change. That's extremely difficult to do because you've got to get everybody or nearly everybody to do it. It takes a very long time to change culture like this, and the larger the culture, the longer it takes to change. And changing something like driving laws or whether or not you use a recycling program for waste is much easier to change than fixing endemic crime or endemic violence.
- sjg007 8y agoIt is also a bogus argument. In the UK police deal with knives all the time and the cops don't have guns. Only an elite swat like unit has weapons but not the day to day bobby. I'm pretty sure UK cops want to come home every day as well.
- MrLeftHand 8y agoYeah, but the UK doesn't have gun crimes, mass shootings in schools, in music festivals or in a park. For a common civilian it is really hard to get a hold of a high caliber gun. In the US you just walk in to the closest gun store and get one. Or as the American youth does, just grab your parents gun and go on a shooting spree.
- scoggs 8y agoTime and time again, even without the "threat" (as perceived by police officers that mentally incapable people are unable to follow commands strictly and promptly) of dealing with a "difficult / defiant" subject / suspect, the police officer's actions never seem to mirror their words. They use commands to confuse, disrupt, provoke, belittle, and ultimately trap the subjects in a situation where they have no "good option". Their inability to parse the irate and rushed officer's commands almost always seems to wind up in the use of excessive force in these cases where a subject is injured extensively or, worse, murdered in cold blood. Bad training and a culture of "Us versus Them" is only part of the issue. I think the majority of the issue stems from police quotas. Even the most weary and well-meaning officers have to meet quotas. If they aren't bringing in 4 felonies or finding 1 suspect with a gun on them in a given month (NYPD statistic, will supply source below) they are first pressured from above by superiors with verbal warnings. After a verbal warning the punishment turns into marks on the officer's permanent record which can prevent an officer from upward mobility or landing a position in their desired unit. That means, to me, that in a situation where an officer who has no reason to go overboard with a subject isn't given 110% respect, the subject doesn't "submit to the officer's power", and the officer sees, hears, feels or perceives anything but certain cooperation and submission that the officer now has "incentive" to make the subject one of their, minimum, 4-monthly felonies. There is a light bulb that goes off in an officer's head. If they haven't met their quota for the month as they approach a subject they have the added weight of needing to "make the grade" for that period. There is a code for a subject that isn't in need of anything more than a written citation (ticket or warning) and there is a code for a subject that needs to be hauled into the police station to be jailed. If the officer is below their quota and the subject gives that officer any reason to view the situation as anything above a written citation than it is actually in that officer's best interest to escalate, provoke, stoke, prod, and push a subject to the point of the situation becoming one that requires an officer to lock that subject up. These officers are human, yes. But the blue line, the quotas, the inability for "good cops" to report "bad cops" without their career trajectory or possibly even their career being ruined, and a bunch of other non-crime related characteristics are fueling the growing rift between ALL CITIZENS and law enforcement officers. The Mayor needs the police to be tough on crime so they can report to the citizens, State, and Federal government that the crime situation is improving in their district. The Police Chief needs to ensure that his officers are meeting quotas, making enough arrests to meet whatever standards have been set, and make it so the Mayor can give those press conferences and cite those numbers that show improvement in order for the Chief to justify the Federal and State budget endowed to that precinct / police department. Each officer is expected to bring in a certain number of felonies per month or find one subject with a gun on them (or more, obviously) in order to meet their quota for the month in order for their Chief to make the Mayor happy. When a police officer is a rookie there are certain assignments that are reserved to them. One I've heard of that's common in New York City is when people in a building report the smell of a dead body. There are lots of elderly people in rent controlled apartments and homes that pass away each day of the year. From the moment a call is made and a body is discovered an officer needs to stay with the body until the medical examiner / coroner shows up to take the body away in official capacity. Like I had said, this job and others like it (less desirable, more rule based than anything type jobs) are reserved for two types of officers: rookies and officers with any amount of experience who do not meet quotas. When officers do not meet their quotas they are given the lowest jobs on the totem pole as a display of punishment. If they continually miss their quota numbers it will disrupt not only their upward trajectory in their career but it will also effect their ability to schedule and take their earned time off. Officers who fail to meet quotas will purposely be given the least desired stretches of time off, usually never coinciding with the days they've requested. All of this incentivizes officers to target subjects who appear to be criminals which often means they are targeting individuals who haven't committed any crimes. If a citizen calls the police for something and it's later found out that the person who called, even if they were not committing any crime or doing anything illegal, if they have a criminal history it is in the police officer's interest (due to quotas) to escalate the situation to the point where they can justify hauling that subject in and thus adding another number to their monthly expected arrests / felonies / quotas. If people can't see the discrepancy here, if people can't understand how the dots connect, if people try to equate this to things like, "they shouldn't have been doing anything wrong if they didn't want to be arrested, hurt, MURDERED!", than I really don't know what to say. People blindly defending police or, worse, blindly blaming people of color or anyone who meets an unkind fate at the hands of over-eager officers is part of the problem, in my honest opinion. I'm a law abiding, non-violent, non-criminal (never been arrested), and for all intents-and-purposes model citizen. Every police encounter I have (even as a white citizen of the US) always goes one way for certain: I hold absolutely still unless instructed otherwise and I completely submit to the officer. I feel completely helpless. I feel completely in the control of the officer. I feel like if that officer is having a bad day or I incidentally irk that officer that I will be the benefactor of whatever negative perceptions that creates -- regardless of anything I did prior. It's all up the officer in that moment and I feel and somewhat know that even if the entire ordeal is recorded (with video and audio) that at the end of the day it's still my word versus theirs and the entire court room is on the same payroll as that officer. There's nothing good about this situation. The entire thing makes me sick. I have friends of every race, nation, and creed and I can't even begin to imagine the way they are made to feel in similar situations if I feel so helpless and at the whim of the given officer. I don't wish that feeling on ANYONE! Even my OWN WORST ENEMY! It's not human, it's not normal, and it breeds the type of feelings people talk about when innocent people are attacked by a foreign military. All it does is create grudges, the quest for revenge, and enemies for the police. AND THEY WONDER WHY SO MANY PEOPLE HAVE PROBLEMS WITH THEM AND THE WAY THEY DO THINGS! Thanks for tolerating my post but lately things have reached a boiling point in my life with people I know and love being mistreated. I caught this interview yesterday, by chance, while not going out of my way to look for it and it was extremely enlightening. I urge each and every one of you to watch this video IN IT'S ENTIRETY! I also urge you to research more about the NYPD 12 and what their mission and message are, even if you don't agree with anything I or they say or stand for. This effects each and every person on American soil, regardless of any personal characteristics you may possess. Thank you for your time. ---------- Sgt Edwin Raymond On Police Quotas, NYPD 12 & Says He Was Denied Promotion (Youtube Interview with HOT97 Radio Station, New York, New York on October 4th, 2018) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBzR2pkWgVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBzR2pkWgVU
- jimnotgym 8y agoTake a look at a UK police officer tackling a disturbed person with a knife. Ordinarily they won't have a gun, so that is no use. They have a baton, a stab vest, maybe a tazer and cs spray. Most importantly they have a radio on their ear and can call for help and they have training. UK police officers are not routinely killed by knife wielding mad people. So no, you don't need to shoot sick people just to make sure you get home tonight.
- MrLeftHand 8y agoYeah, but it is different wielding a knife then a gun. You have to be up close and personal with that. Whilst with a gun you can be far away. Apples and Oranges. And don't look at one individual case, look at the cause why this keeps happening. The police force is trained that there is a high possibility that there is a gun. So how are they going to go in there? With guns drawn of course. That is the difference. The knowledge of you might getting shot is enough to be trigger happy about everything. Especially when your training says the same thing. But then it's not enough changing the training of the police force, whilst civilians still wield guns. Disarmament needs to happen on multiple levels. And another thing, yes there are cases where it is fairly simple to tell if you are in front of a disabled or mentally ill person then a nutcase high on crystal meth. And these are just cops, without any training in the medical field to tell the difference and they go in already on edge. No wonder bad things happen.
- elipsey 8y agoThe guy in this article wasn't wielding anything. He was naked and empty handed in his own shower. >> there are cases where it is fairly simple to tell if you are in front of a disabled or mentally ill person then a nutcase high on crystal meth What are you trying to say here? It's OK to kill unarmed drug users, but not unarmed crazy people? I don't think it is OK in either case and I'm putting my money where my mouth is. I live in the tenderloin and walk everywhere, so I get approached by aggressive people who are acting weird and scary everyday. So far I have never even considered shooting them.
- 8y ago