2 ms·
> Yes. Neanderthals as a population don't exist anymore. But then neither is the Homo Sapiens of that era, surely? > The house cat and tiger shares 95% of the
by Nursie 8y ago
> Yes. Neanderthals as a population don't exist anymore.
But then neither is the Homo Sapiens of that era, surely?
> The house cat and tiger shares 95% of the same genes. If tigers disappeared, you wouldn't consider it an extinction because we have house cats around?
If they interbred now and there was gene transfer within that 5%, I think that would be an entirely different situation to the one you describe.
The picture that is often painted of the Neanderthal following a parallel evolutionary course to 'us', Homo Sapiens. But 'us' is actually a hybrid of the two.
> Also, the common ancestors of humans and the common ancestors of cats became extinct a long time ago. Are you saying those "creatures" aren't extinct because humans and cats are around?
Of course not, and you seem to be entirely misunderstanding my question.
If humans and cats somehow interbred and the ongoing population of cat-human hybrids was what carried on, identifiable fully as neither, the picture is much more grey.
- muthdra 8y agoJesus fucking Christ if you could fuck the Homo Sapiens of that era and a fertile baby would come out, then no. The homo sapiens is not extinct. It's not rocket science.
- msla 8y ago> Jesus fucking Christ if you could fuck the Homo Sapiens of that era and a fertile baby would come out, then no. The whole point of the article is that modern Homo sapiens have Neandertal DNA. This means humans were interfertile with Neandertals, and produced fertile offspring. Neandertals were a separate species which is extinct now. > The homo sapiens is not extinct. True. > It's not rocket science. True: It's more complex than that.
- username3 8y agoIt’s the other way around. Neanderthals have homo sapien DNA.
- Nursie 8y agoBut presumably we can say the same about the neanderthal of that era, given we have genetic material from both. So it seems a little odd to consider one extinct and the other some sort of continuity of species, when both populations contributed to our makeup.