3 ms·
This makes a lot more sense to me. Whenever I see a description of a long period of history as being mainly static, such as humans evolving as a separate group
by simonh 8y ago
This makes a lot more sense to me. Whenever I see a description of a long period of history as being mainly static, such as humans evolving as a separate group within Africa for a hundred thousand years or more, it sets off alarm bells. It just sounds like historians and archaeologists only have a few reference points to work from so they extrapolate between them in a straight line or a nice smooth curve. Real human history is messy, complicated and often violent.
I'm not getting at the science or it's practitioners, they can't just make up complex changes without evidence, but let's be honest that any such seemingly static periods of history due to limited evidence are probably just placeholder theories for whatever was actually happening.
- Pica_soO 8y agoIm sure they extrapolated for ritual or religious reasons.
- posterboy 8y agoThe common notion is that there wasn't much technological development going on. Stone tools, hunting gathering for a long time, then civilization over the last 10.00 years. Your point still applies to a degree, but it's amazing what they can already tell from the remains that didn't fall to the forces of nature.
- Radim 8y agoThis reminds me of the so-called "dark ages". Bronze age collapse, Middle ages… Early historians used to call them dark because of just such "limited evidence". Little surviving records, compared to the periods before/after. But these "periods of silence" may have given us something less tangible but even more lasting than literature and architecture. The fabric of societies was rewoven, new modes of thinking and organization emerged from the chaos. People may not have been into books and stone, but they were certainly not idle! The inhales and exhales at the scale of humanity are sometimes hard to appreciate, or even tell apart, from our individual level.