5 ms·
I'm not sure about this (I don't know that particular journalist or any of his reportings). That there is some kind of PR machine at work from the likes of Boei
by hef19898 8y ago
I'm not sure about this (I don't know that particular journalist or any of his reportings). That there is some kind of PR machine at work from the likes of Boeing and Lockheed, sure bet, they alsways do that. But then SpaceX has Elon Musk, a PR machine all of his own.
What did change so, and that I think is directly related to Musk as well, is how SpaceX is perceived now as compared to a few years ago. It all started with Teslas Model 3 issues and the subsequent Twitter issues, after that Musk, and by extension his companies, are seen in a different light by many. Whether this is justified or not is anyones guess.
Regarding SpaceX, competitors are now exploiting an opportunity, I just hope that Musk doesn't take the bait. On the other hand, maybe a somewhat more realistic approach doesnt't hurt. When did some "research" into SpaceX lately I saw a change in tone in articles, especially covering the financial side, from article in 2013 / 2014 to now. I have the impression that SpaceX, and Musk as well as Tesla, are also followinng the hype curve.
Added background: I'm not so optimistic regarding bith Tesla and SpceX anymore as have been, especially Tesla.
- Tuna-Fish 8y ago> Added background: I'm not so optimistic regarding bith Tesla and SpceX anymore as have been, especially Tesla. Not commenting on Tesla, but why are you not optimistic wrt SpaceX? To put simply, SpaceX has won the space launch industry more thoroughly than anyone could have predicted just a few years ago. SpaceX is now routinely recovering every core they fly, and based on publicly revealed data they are cheap to refurbish. This means launch costs they pay are down to a small fraction of what everyone else pays. They have reduced the cost of getting to the end of their launch queue to $60M for basic service, and despite the low sticker price they are still probably making more profit per launch (not profit margin, more flat profit) on those than any of their competitors are. According to Königsmann's recent talk at IAC, they now have a 100 future launches on their launch manifest, priced at about $12B. That's more than the entire rest of the commercial launch industry put together, by a huge margin. Because they now get their first stages back, it means that their stable of launchers grows larger and their launch cadence can improve with every new finished rocket, so they can rapidly turn those deals into actual profit. In just a few years, SpaceX has turned from the scrappy upstart to the 800-pound gorilla who dwarf all their competition. On top of that they have the BFR which sounds fantastic and fantastical, and their satellite internet business which seems designed to make sure they don't run out of launches for their launchers, and both those projects are a lot more risky. But the point is, unlike Tesla with Model 3, those projects can fail and they will still be the most effective and profitable space launch company in human history. They can afford to have a long and explosion-filled development cycle for the BFR. In a lot of ways, they have already won, and that's just the victory lap. Of course, until they get BFR worked out, they are not going to go to Mars.
- hef19898 8y agoIt is curious that whenever I voice doubts regarding SPaceX I get quite some downvotes. But I digress. The main reasons I am not that optimistic anymore regarding SpaceX are financial, mostly based on some doubts I developed regardintheir real launch prices ( I know that there is no "standard" launch) and the fact that encumbents are waking up. So, as far as financials are concerned 100 launches representing $12B mean an average of $120M per launch, a far cry from the $62M they are advertising. These price are not that far of from, say, Ariane. Sure, it's an average, which is exactly my point. Underbidding other commercial providers is easoer when you get highly priced government work to susidize these commercial launches (ULA is a nice case in point regarding the revenue and profits government work is providing. this also explains a lot about ULA, but that is a different topic). SO the first issue I have is the hype regarding SpaceX costs which is purely based on advertised numbers. The discrepancy was also there up to 2015 (wsj published internal docs and real number up to 2015 in Junuary 2017). So, to me it seems that SpaceX is doing what everybody else is doing in that sector: taking government contracts to cross finance commercial business. Be it development contracts (SpaceX and Boeing for manned space flights), purely military programms (F-35, Eurofighter,...) or direct state subsidies (Airbus, Boeing tends to get the government money through military programms). I'm not judging here, it is simply a common industry practrice. I totaly agree that SpaceX has a much lower development cost structure as purely private company without any political and bureaucratic beef, I just doubt that this advantage is as great as I believed it to be. The other threat I see is now that incumbents woke up competition for comparative launchers is getting tougher. While Ariane-5, as one example, was intended for a shuttle-like program Ariane-6 will be much closer to a Falcon-9 and will allow lower costs per kg-payload. Last estimates put in almost in a ballpark region of Falcon-9s based in advertised prices not taken the above emntioned averages into account. As a result it is reasonable to assume that SpaceX cost advantage will not stay for ever. The other oart, somehow related, is reliability. Both, ULA and Ariane, have a better launch record than SpaceX. That reused Falcon-9s are now advertized as "launch-proven" instead of reused (nice counter-point to a expendable launcher when you look at a unit level) kind of confirms this and is again pure marketing. Not sure how much marketing factors in when someone wants to launch a $100M plus payload so. And the final factor is that incumbents have really deep pockets, SpaceX needs venture capital. All of this doesn't mean that SpaceX did not achieve incredible things, they showed how fast and cheap development can be without political BS. They developed a reusable rocket (finacial aspects non-withstanding). They breathed life again into the American space programs. So when I say less optimistic that implies a very high (hyped?) starting point. EDIT: Ariane-6 is scheduled to replace the Ariane-5, with an unclear development up ahead it it seems obvious that demand is shifting to a provider with an already developed launcher. As you see I did not look to deep into ULA yet, so everything is coming down to Arianespace - SpaceX comparison.