2 ms·
I question whether the cost of doing this in new novel naval architecture isn't excessive. You can have a green ship without installing Magnus effect rotor sail
by walrus01 8y ago
I question whether the cost of doing this in new novel naval architecture isn't excessive. You can have a green ship without installing Magnus effect rotor sails:
A) install a massive ground mount photovoltaic system
Or massive wind farm on land.
B) use the kWh from it to crack water into pressurized tanks of hydrogen
C) transport the hydrogen to the ship, store it onboard, and run it through fuel cells to drive electric azipods.
This require the engineering resources for on board hydrogen tank system, fueling system and fuel cells. Less mechanically complex than massive rotor sails, and something that all of the subcomponents exist for "off the shelf".
This lets you use otherwise useless, non arable land for the energy generation. Even if the electricity to hydrogen process is extremely inefficient. At a certain point if you plot the ongoing price drops for massive grid scale PV, when PV panels hit $0.20/watt, it will be economical.
- gumby 8y agoHydrogen plumbing is not really a solved problem so I challenge the "less mechanically complex". Those hydrogen atoms are really small! The margin on shipping is low enough that I suspect they looked at everything they could get off the shelf before settling on this one, which I agree is complex. It will be interesting to see the long time life of these sails.
- vosper 8y ago> I question whether the cost of doing this in new novel naval architecture isn't excessive. You can have a green ship without installing Magnus effect rotor sails: > A) install a massive ground mount photovoltaic system > Or massive wind farm on land. > B) use the kWh from it to crack water into pressurized tanks of hydrogen Or, though it's in a different sense of "green ship": provide the power generated by the solar array / wind farm very cheaply or at-cost to offset the emissions generated by the ship. It doesn't make the ship emissions go away, but it could make something that's grid-connected become carbon neutral.