3 ms·
I don't think that profit is the primary problem here. As always, the key to hiring someone is setting the right specification for their work product. In the
by jrockway 8y ago
I don't think that profit is the primary problem here. As always, the key to hiring someone is setting the right specification for their work product. In the US, the prison system's expectation is "torture these miserable criminals who were convicted by the 100% accurate and infallible criminal justice system". The for-profit prisons do that for $24/day instead of $130/day. Yay!
The problem is that the specification is WAY wrong. Treating the criminal justice system as infallible is a huge mistake, many people in prison are wrongfully convicted or were bullied into a guilty plea. Treating it as a place to punish people for their crimes has no long-term value. They get out, don't know how to interact with the real world, and end up back in prison (hey, more profit!).
Ultimately society is shortchanged because these people have value even though they can't necessarily be trusted in their current state in free society. (Some of this is society's fault, of course, which we take no responsibility for, because taking responsibility is expensive and if we spent our tax dollars on that, we couldn't have as many sports stadiums or wars.) I look at prison as a place where people who can't be trusted in free society to be more closely monitored. A case I always think about is Hans Reiser. Clearly he cannot be trusted to be alone with people that he wants to murder, because he'll murder them. Fair enough. But I don't see why he can't write filesystem code anymore. You can have a laptop with the Linux kernel on it and submit patches without being able to freely murder people. Why doesn't the prison system provide that? We as a society lose out on that possible value, and the prisoner loses out on the ability to be human. (The conflict here is always that that's unfair to people who haven't murdered anyone. And that's true, which is why the concept of basic income comes up again and again. If everyone is equal in their ability to have their basic human needs met, the world can be a much better place. That costs $$$ though and we must not spend money on boring things like meeting society's basic needs. Me, me, me! That's the most important thing.)
Anyway, the TLDR is that right now the criminal justice system is severely fucked, and private prisons are a way of getting absolutely terrible results for a lower price. If we want to get good results, we will have to change things dramatically, and that will cost money. Nobody wants to pay the money, or necessarily even knows how to fix the problem with money, so here we are.
- eropple 8y agoThe "right specification" for the work product is deemed what they say it is because they're paying to write the specification. You don't think private prisons' higher rates of inmate infraction (leading to longer time in prison, leading to more money) and the lobbying efforts against rehabilitative services for prisoners isn't directly rooted in The Search For More Money?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]