4 ms·
Wow, that's actually a great deal. The top marginal tax rate in the state of California this year is roughly 65% (and that's excluding employer contributions).
by arcticbull 8y ago
Wow, that's actually a great deal. The top marginal tax rate in the state of California this year is roughly 65% (and that's excluding employer contributions).
13.3% of all income (State) +
39.6% of all income (Federal) +
5.3% of all income (Federal double tax on State Tax - thanks, Donny) +
6.2% of all income (Social Security - Individual)
=====
64.4%
Then of course your employer pays another 6.2% of gross earnings on your behalf for social security too. And of course, in tech, your employer has to pay for your healthcare too, an average of $19,616, which also actually comes out of your paycheck. [1] Feel free to work out what percentage of your gross earnings that amounts to and tack that on top also. Good thing we've got the freedom to save the remaining ~33% while people go without basic health cover and social services.
In years I earn a lot, I'd actually be better off in Canada.
[1] https://www.kff.org/health-costs/report/2018-employer-health-benefits-survey/ https://www.kff.org/health-costs/report/2018-employer-health...
- nickthemagicman 8y agoAnd it's the third biggest economy in the world. My conclusion is that having a huge healthy educated talent pool is more important to companies than taxes.
- arcticbull 8y agoI agree completely.
- ac29 8y agoThe top marginal tax bracket in CA is for single people making $1M+, and higher if married. That's a lot, even for software engineers. A more realistic total combined tax for most people is well under 50%.
- walshemj 8y agoFor the UK with the NHS that figure would be 32% for most single people and less for those with kids.
- tomatocracy 8y agoYou've excluded employers national insurance contributions here, which is 13.8% of total pay. That makes the true "main" marginal rate c.44% (20% tax + 12% employee national insurance + 13.8% employers NI / 113.8%). Most higher earners in e.g. tech or professions will be in the 40% band at least, where the true marginal rate is c.49% (40%+2%+13.8% / 113.8%). The "top" marginal rate is c.53% (45% tax+2% employee NI+13.8% employer NI / 113.8%) although the highest marginal rate comes between £100k and c.£123k as the personal allowance (bottom 0% band) gets withdrawn making the effective rate (40%+50%x40%+2%+13.8% / 113.8%) = c.65%. (And at the very low end of the scale, as benefits get withdrawn the marginal combined rate of tax and benefit withdrawal is also extremely high). We don't allow joint filing for married couples which is a significant benefit, especially for single earner couples with high earnings, in the USA. Then we have mandatory minimum private pension contributions (given these all go into a defined contribution scheme, it's just pay by another name), the apprenticeship levy, etc etc. Overall, I'd say the UK and "high-tax" parts of the USA (California, New York etc) are similarly taxed at least as far as income is concerned.
- walshemj 8y agoAdding the employers contribution to calculate marginal rates for employees is not how its calculated. Do you think any employer in the uk would magically give you the 13.8 if employers ni went away. And most STEM jobs including tech don't get into the higher band at 46,350 I think you ignored the tax free band.
- Joky 8y agoNot including employers contribution when comparing countries is just non-sense to me: the only number that matters is the total cost per added employee for a business, and on the other side for the employee the after-tax money that remains after everything is deducted. And then you can put the services you get for the money (i.e. yes taxes are higher in France for instance, but the state provides also much more).
- tomatocracy 8y ago
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoCalifornia is an outlier! After taxes, insurance and maxing out my 401k (i.e. all the stuff that comes out of my paycheck) I take home 56% on the East coast (in a high tax state no less). I also pay less sales tax and transportation costs than I would in CA and I can afford a house with less than six figures (gross) household income.
- vonvonschilling 8y agoYou make paying 45% for France's system sound like a deal for a lifetime.
- Joky 8y ago45% is only the (higher bracket) "federal taxes" (France isn't a federal country) that don't include all the welfare contributions which are taken from your salary (22% IIRC) and also the higher employer contributions. Edit, FYI: - 14% from 9 964 € to 27 519 € - 30% from 27 519 € to 73 779 € - 41% from 73 779 € to 156 244 € - 45% beyond 156 244 € And the table here for the social contribution that are taken out of your pay before the taxes above are applied: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cotisations_sociales_en_France#Travailleurs_salariés https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cotisations_sociales_en_France...
- arcticbull 8y agoI left those out of my headline numbers too though.
- Joky 8y agoYeah I just clarified because of the part that said "for France's system", this part of the tax is not what's paying for the welfare part of the "system". According to https://argent.boursier.com/impots/analyses/ou-va-largent-de-vos-impots-743.html https://argent.boursier.com/impots/analyses/ou-va-largent-de... - 23.5% for tax credit for other people (i.e. think about solar panels, etc.) - 15.7% for primary/secondary education (i.e. from kindergarten to 12th) - 13.6% for counties and other local / regional structures. - 11.5% for interest on the debt. - 9.35% for the Defense budget. - 6.35% for Universities (education and research) => This is paying for ~ free education!! Probably the best deal in the French system compared to the USA. - 5% for Europe - 4.3% Police - 1.9% Judiciary
- briandear 8y agoYou aren’t paying the top marginal rate unless you make over $600k as a couple or $500k as a single. Also the top marginal rate is 37%, not 39.5 (Thanks Donny.) And SALT? Rather than “thanking” Donnie for the reduced deductibility, perhaps complain that they are so high as to exceed the allowable cap in the first place?
- rayiner 8y agoYou're double counting the "Federal double tax." Also, the marginal Social Security tax is $0, since it phases out long before you hit those marginal rates. That being said, the reason France can offer robust services while California cannot, even though tech worker taxes are similar between the two countries, is because France taxes everyone that way. In France, the 41% tax bracket (just a little lower than the top bracket of 45%) kicks in at 71,000 Euros (about $80,000). The U.S. federal rate in that bracket is 25%. Then there is the 20% VAT paid by even the lowest income people.
- anticensor 8y ago> France can offer robust services while California cannot, France offers much more social security than whole US.
- rayiner 8y agoMost of the US has much lower taxes than California.
- arcticbull 8y agoYep, you're absolutely right, I did double-count the double-tax. Your comment had me re-run the numbers, and this is what I came up with. You are correct that Social Security goes down to $0. Medicare contributions have no cap, and are 1.45% by both the employer and employee and the 0.9% Obamacare surcharges on the employee only portion (until 2035) kicks in over $250,000 also. Therefore, social insurance contributes a marginal 3.79% So, the numbers to the best of my knowledge should have been: 13.3% of all income (State) + 39.6% of all income (Federal, including the Donny double-tax) + 2.34% of all income (Medicare, Obamacare - Employee Contributions) + 1.45% of all income (Medicare - Employer Contributions) ===== 56.69% Then you still have to deal with the fixed portions, the $19,616 [1] in healthcare premiums, the $7,347 you'd have paid in social security tax and the $7,347 your employer would have paid in social security tax. [2] [1] https://www.kff.org/health-costs/report/2018-employer-health-benefits-survey/ https://www.kff.org/health-costs/report/2018-employer-health... [2] https://www.bizfilings.com/toolkit/research-topics/managing-your-taxes/payroll-taxes/employers-responsibility-for-fica-payroll-taxes https://www.bizfilings.com/toolkit/research-topics/managing-...