5 ms·
Between the emergence of resistant bacterial strains and growing understanding of internal microbiomes, the future will not look kindly on our use of antibiotic
by andrewflnr 8y ago
Between the emergence of resistant bacterial strains and growing understanding of internal microbiomes, the future will not look kindly on our use of antibiotics. And of course, you don't need to go into the future to find people who look dimly on the state of the art in nutrition.
- refurb 8y agoWon’t look too kindly? The alternative to antibiotics in a lot of these cases is death. Not sure anyone would look at that “unkindly”.
- Ensorceled 8y agoI believe the parent was thinking of our using antibiotics for things like increasing growth rates in livestock, hand soap marketing, and viral infections; but maybe your incredibly uncharitable interpretation is correct ...
- andrewflnr 8y agoSure, those specific cases are justified. A lot of others aren't. I guess in the context of blood-letting it wasn't clear I meant they would look unkindly on our policy as a whole, rather than on using them at all.
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoWhile overprescription of antibiotics to human patients has been a problem, I think that the antibiotics usage that the future will really look back on unkindly is the massive use of antibiotics in the livestock industry. Wastewater from that is a major contribution to bacterial resistance.
- wwweston 8y agoYou don't even have to go into the future to find unkind looks here. Operators making the decision to use ABX the way they're used in livestock are morally guilty of negligent homicide whether or not it meets a legal standard. It's unconscionable at this point to treat them as just another industrial input.
- Filligree 8y agoA family friend, who's a farmer, made the decision not to use antibiotics in feed. He then went bankrupt. He claims that was why. Whether or not it is, in his specific case, this is a coordination problem. Using antibiotics this way has to be outlawed, because any farmer who unilaterally chooses not to use it is leaving money on the table. In an efficient market, that leads to bankruptcy.
- philwelch 8y ago> the future will not look kindly on our use of antibiotics It's entirely likely that we use too many antibiotics, but antibiotics have also saved all of us from unbelievable levels of pain and suffering. I had an ear infection once, and the pain was unbearable. I went to the doctor, who quipped, "if we leave it alone, eventually it'll just burst the eardrum and drain out." And then she prescribed me some antibiotics. And that's not even the worst situation that calls for antibiotics. It's not like my life was in danger.