3 ms·
> "how can we know something?", "what does it mean for something to exist?", "why is there something rather than nothing?", "what is good and evil?" These all
by Koshkin 8y ago
> "how can we know something?", "what does it mean for something to exist?", "why is there something rather than nothing?", "what is good and evil?"
These all are perfectly valid questions, and they deserve answers which are based on rigorous science. Philosophical discourse is just the first step in trying to find these answers or to establish the scientific framework (a model) that would allow to discover them in a completely rational way.
- CM30 8y agoI strongly doubt we'll find scientific answers to moral questions anytime soon. The answer to 'what's right' likely doesn't exist in nature outside of human civilisation and social standards, and going from 'this is true' to 'this is right' is not an easy jump to make. (It's also one that would theoretically obsolete the field of politics if it was ever answered scientifically).
- Koshkin 8y agoThe answers to moral questions ("what is right") are found at the intersection of sociology, psychology, and biology - which are all very well established sciences.
- wsy 8y agoThey can't because they are empirical sciences. They only can find out facts about the world. Philosophy has already shown that moral is not derivable from facts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem.
- Koshkin 8y agoTo be clear, I wasn't talking about creating "optimal" moral imperatives (which is impossible and even meaningless), only about finding out why they are the way they are in a particular social group, how they have evolved, etc.
- CM30 8y agoThat's all very well and good, but it's not really what moral philosophy/ethics is trying to solve. It's about what is right and how society should work, and whether the right thing is say, what brings the most happiness/utility or what's someone's duty as a good person or what not. No, those are not meaningless goals, since they kind of determine how society works/should work, and are often the basis of fair political and legal systems. Here's how it worked in the past doesn't justify it working the same way now, and cultures throughout history have done all sorts of questionable things on the assumption they were in the right. It's the job of moral philosophers to figure out how to move forward from this, figure out what's right for society and go beyond tribalism and instinct.
- Koshkin 8y agoIt is indeed meaningless and impossible, because, on the one hand, the spectrum of choices is too large and fuzzy, and, on the other hand, "happiness" cannot be universal, because the interest are naturally in contradiction with one another, so the reason one is happy can make another sad. Which is why we have dura lex for morals. And which is why, for example, a "just" war can be "immoral" or even "criminal" at the same time. The popular saying "No good deed goes unpunished" is an expression of the deep distrust towards any attempts to derive morals from some abstract "first principles."
- wsy 8y agoYour statement sounds quite philosophical. Is it open for discussion, or do you consider it a dogmatic truth? I'd recommend to check out John Rawls and Amartya Sen on how you can reason about a fair society without assuming universal concepts of happiness, and with taking into account everyone's selfishness.
- Koshkin 8y agoProblem is, “fair”, “good”, and “right” are three different things, and what adds to the confusion is that each has a different meaning depending on a context (the size of the social group - down to the individual; relation to other social groups; the point on the timeline - i.e. whether we are speaking about now or the future, etc.) Statistical mechanics avoids complexity of taking into account properties of the individual constituents by shifting attention to the averages, and so, in a sense, must ethics, if it is to be rational. But, again, the properties in question are not well-defined, unfortunately, and so no amount of effort to rationalize them could yield a positive result. Otherwise we’d have moral codes in place of arbitrary laws long ago.