4 ms·
>the media tends to declare someone a genius if his work cannot be understood by laymen That's not particularly true. I don't think there is a single mathemati
by whatshisface 8y ago
>the media tends to declare someone a genius if his work cannot be understood by laymen
That's not particularly true. I don't think there is a single mathematician whose papers are understandable to laypeople (by laypeople, I mean the average person, who remembers some but not all of highschool math). What's really going on here is that Einstein made a tremendous contribution to a tower that was already quite tall, while Darwin's contribution was to the ground floor where everybody could get on. The maths analogy to Darwin would be one of the inventors of Algebra - evolution is taught to children right along with the foundations of math and physics.
- 11235813213455 8y agoNot always understandable by Einstein itself, he got helped by his mathematician friends, like Levi Civita
- nyc111 8y agoTrue. And also he got mathematical help from Marcel Grossmann. Poincare too was doing work on the theory of relativity. Also one of the selling points of relativity in the early days was the difficulty of its math. I think it was Eddington who said that "only three people understood General Relativity."
- nyc111 8y ago>Einstein made a tremendous contribution to a tower that was already quite tall, while Darwin's contribution was to the ground floor where everybody could get on. I see your point, but if Darwin created a new field but Einstein contributed to an existing field, Darwin ought to be considered a greater genius. (Personally, I think it is better not to define anyone as a genius so that we can continue to evaluate their work critically.) I'm saying that we value things we don't understand more than things we do understand.
- zaphirplane 8y agoAfter evaluating their work if deemed so declare them a genius. Some would say that’s already happened
- Reelin 8y ago> That's not particularly true. I don't think there is a single mathematician whose papers are understandable to laypeople I suspect that the media would indeed portray most mathematicians as geniuses, though. In fact most laypeople I know would agree that they were, and I know some fairly well educated laypeople in my opinion. By mathematician, I mean a publishing academic with a PhD in math (or some rough equivalent to that).