3 ms·
I've been hearing for years that automation will take all our jobs and leave us with crazy high permanent unemployment rates, thus necessitating some paltry UBI
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I've been hearing for years that automation will take all our jobs and leave us with crazy high permanent unemployment rates, thus necessitating some paltry UBI so useless humans can keep eating and won't revolt. Yet, a current news story informs me that unemployment is at a 49 year low.*
No doubt, tech has changed the world and will continue to do so. But I increasingly take it with a grain of salt when I hear predictions about robots being superior to humans in every way and making humans obsolete for various things.
* https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/05/economy/september-jobs-report/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/05/economy/september-jobs-report...
- Razengan 8y ago> useless humans How do you expect all 8 billion people to remain ““useful”” without artificially holding back technological advancement?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIIRC, the average education level of women in the US when Lincoln was president was 2nd to 4th grade. Mrs. Lincoln had a 12th grade education. She was unusually educated and headstrong for a woman of her era. A hundred years ago, a high percentage of Americans lived and worked on farms. It was pretty common to not complete high school. This is why the military created the GED. Now, most Americans live on cities and it is stigmatizing to drop out of high school. Education levels have generally risen over the years. It seems to me that additional education beyond high school could well become a normal expectation. There have always been "useless" humans such as infants, the very old and those who are disabled. There will always be such, though we are living longer and tech (among other things) is changing things for people with disabilities. But I don't see any reason to expect, say, 80 percent permanent unemployment as the new norm. I think it is much more realistic and healthy to expect people to stay in school longer. Students are not generally counted among "the unemployed" and are generally not considered "useless," even if they don't have a paid job. Granted, there will be challenges in providing that at scale and paying for it, but, unlike UBI, it at least ties money to socially desirable outcomes and increases capacity for productivity.