5 ms·
In Ireland, these kinds of tax breaks are one of the foundations of our economy. They aren't viewed as a way to give a hand out to the big companies, but as a w
by rmc 16y ago
In Ireland, these kinds of tax breaks are one of the foundations of our economy. They aren't viewed as a way to give a hand out to the big companies, but as a way to create jobs. This article mentions that 2,000 people are employed in Google Dublin. Given Microsoft, Amazon, Intel, IBM and Sun also operate, there's easily 10,000+ people employed thanks to our low tax rate. There are only 1,000,000 people employed in Ireland (small country), so the loss of these 10,000+ jobs (~1%+ of all employees) would be massive.
Ireland has very little industry, very little traditional ways to grow the economy. We all know if it wasn't for the tax breaks these companies wouldn't be here, and that there'd be loads of people out of work.
- fiveo 16y agoI hope you guys can find other means/ways to create jobs. I live in Vancouver where hi-tech companies receive generous amount of SR&ED (Science Research and Education) grant. Let's just say that it was a good thing for short-term but not-so for long-term.
- elai 16y agoCould you go into more detail?
- fiveo 16y agoIn BC, if you are a hi-tech company, you are eligible to receive SR&ED (given by the government, but you need to fill some paperworks). In the short-term, it's great because it gives your company some money to survive. In the long-term, when your actual balance sheet is red but because of SR&ED it becomes green, most companies are lying to themselves. There are many companies in BC that rely on SR&ED and as a result, they're not dead nor living. They can't pay top money for top talent. Their product/software take the hit. There are many CEOs that only want to ship the product ASAP or else they're going down ASAP as well. In general, it's a vicious cycle.
- borism 16y agoAnd that's the reason Ireland has something like 1000% external debt to GDP [1] - politicians and local businessmen alike got so drunk with their success of luring in corps that they assumed it will continue forever. The reality is however, that taxes will have to be raised and the corporations will leave for yet another island paradise, and that will result in social catastrophe either way. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_external_debt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_external_d...
- yummyfajitas 16y agoUm, Ireland had a big property bubble, which is the cause of their current troubles. High corporate tax rates didn't prevent a property bubble in the US or Spain, why would they have prevented one in Ireland?
- borism 16y agoUm, Ireland's structural problems are not limited to property bubble? Perhaps it's the symptom, not the cause?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOk, you tell me. Why do you believe low corporate taxes are the cause of Ireland's problems? Before making your argument, keep in mind that 12.5% of something > 33% of nothing.
- borism 16y agoI have a very hard time understanding how you translate my line of thought: low tax rate->more multinationals->higher debt for local business and government->higher tax rate->less multinationals->social catastrophe into your line of thought: low tax rate->more multinationals->property bubble->"current problems" what are "current problems" you identify in Ireland anyway? all I was saying is that low tax rate is not sustainable with level of public and private debts in Ireland. Do you agree or disagree? of course property bubble is connected to presence of many multinationals in a way, but I wouldn't nor did I identify it with this primarily. Property bubble was global as you might know. So why does Ireland have such large problems when compared to other countries?