11 ms·
Madrid announces new rules of the road in bid to banish traffic from center
- grezql 8y agoThey have done this in other european cities too. But maybe not in the same territory scale. I have lived downtown for 2 years myself and oppose this ridiculous "environment"-protection move. Its very anti-social to ban traffic from urban areas. Technology and evolution should create opportunities and positive changes for people, not take away their rights!
- skh 8y agoIt seems to me encouraging pedestrians makes things more social. Everyone driving in their own car seems a lot less social to me. Can you elaborate on why this is anti social?
- grezql 8y agofriends and families are discouraged when they realize they cannot drive home to me and park here. Instead they must spend 1 hour on train. This in turn increases isolation of people.
- tecleandor 8y agoDuring most of the day, driving to the center of Madrid is way, way slower than taking the train. The city is quite antisocial right now, full of people incapable of moving around the city due to a huge stream of cars occupying most of the space in the streets, but barely moving.
- KirinDave 8y agoWas the car faster? Is taking the train actually difficult? I live in the US, in a state famous for requiring a car. I genuinely miss when I could take the train to work, and my family visits me less now that they have to drive into the city rather than park at a train terminal and ride transit in.
- the_clarence 8y agoThis is because you have a shitty public transport because your city focuses on cars.
- CalRobert 8y agoNobody can land a helicopter on my flat but I still have friends. Cars are about as practical in city centres.
- the_clarence 8y agoIn Europe most people do not drive in the cities. How is that anti social? On the contrary cars are hated: they contribute to noise pollution, real pollution, accidents, etc. They take space and breaks paths for pedestrians, scooters, bikes, etc.
- Silhouette 8y agoIn Europe most people do not drive in the cities. That's quite a generalisation. People in major cities like London and Paris would obviously like to clean up the pollution and reduce the noise and disruption, but the simple fact is that the existing public transport systems are not even close to having enough capacity to replace private motor transport entirely, and there zero chance of them having it any time soon. And those are the ideal cases, where there is enough demand to make a reasonably efficient and close-to-24/7 public transport network viable. Those in smaller cities have much worse options in terms of efficiency, availability and reliability, as do those travelling between or outside the bigger cities. You can't just ban cars to fix this, or price them off the roads with congestion charging or the equivalent. It would take a huge programme of investment in developing new mass transit alternatives and redesigning large parts of the overall transport infrastructure within cities to make forcible elimination of cars in favour of public transport a viable option, and any such plan would probably have to be implemented over a 50-100 year timescale, with those footing much of the bill never living to see the benefits. That's a tough sell for any political administration. I personally think that making private transport less intrusive and damaging has far more potential to improve the situation in the short to medium term. Infrastructure for electric vehicles is one obvious move in the right direction, but more generally, our road systems are still designed around the idea that one person making a journey with limited cargo needs a car-sized vehicle, which is horribly wasteful in road space, parking space, fuel consumption, etc. We have some very basic infrastructure in cities these days for bikes and we make some allowances for motorbikes, but these modes of transport have serious downsides for a lot of people. Crucially, the changes needed to improve those downsides would also allow, for example, smaller electric vehicles that are still fully enclosed and having space for carrying small loads in addition to their human occupant. Combine that with increasing automation over the next couple of decades for better safety and general efficiency, and most of us might at least still be alive to see the benefits.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoIt's very anti-social to permit the thing that more than any other makes a city noisy, dirty, polluted, smelly, health impacting, interferes with everyone's quality of life, and takes an absurdly selfish amount of space (1 person in a 5 or more seat car - the usual). Get rid of all of them, enable adequate public transport, add a whole load of trees, calming and removal of signage and markings. Then give priority to the pedestrian, bike, and perhaps limited motorbike before car. Cities could be a nice place to live once again rather than somewhere to avoid.
- cm2187 8y agoI am not sure what you mean by "once again". Are you suggesting that pre-car cities had no nuisance related to horse traffic?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSeems there was a brief spell in the 30s, and early post-war prior to the UK eliminating so much bus, rail, and all trams there was a spell where everyone got OK quality of life in a city, before everyone owns a car. Before all the flyovers, dual carriageways, urban motorways and junction prioritisation of cars. That said, I feel no cars at all is the ideal we should aim for, and build our roads for - with the necessary investment in public transport.
- majewsky 8y agoAs much as I'm advocating for public transit (heavy user myself, don't have a driver's license), "no cars" is a very unrealistic ideal. If I had to propose a rule, it would be something like "no privately-owned cars". Even in an ideal scenario, you still need car lanes everywhere for: - ambulances and fire engines - trucks that deliver goods to inner-city shops - moving vans - vans of craftsmen - etc. Also, there should still be some form of carsharing for when families go grocery-shopping, or when I buy a sofa and need to haul it home.
- NeedMoreTea 8y ago
- Puer 8y agoDriving is not a right. It's a privilege.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- iwwr 8y agoMore like, mobility is a right. Areas without functional public transport still have to rely on cars.
- frabbit 8y agoImagine if I proposed taxing people approximately $5000 extra a year and then insisting that in addition they took on an extra job of being a chauffeur every morning and evening? And in addition I sequestered land and the sides of roads in order to store the vehicles which you needed to maintain, license, insure? And in addition I would propose that approximately forty thousand people a year would be killed directly in vehicle collisions and that your children would be put in danger by you and your neighbors. It is possible that you are talking about one of the very rare (and ever decreasing) rural areas which simply does not have enough population density to make public transport viable. But, we will worry about that after the dense suburbs, exurbs and downtowns have a modern transport system.
- eeZah7Ux 8y ago> mobility is a right Spot on - and societies obsessed with cars effectively deny that right to people who cannot drive or cannot afford a car.
- KirinDave 8y agoUnless you're implying this was done against the will of the majority of the citizenry who live there, I'm curious why you think an axiom "technology should create opportunities" should override the rights, freedoms and preferences of people there.
- kareemsabri 8y agoEver heard of tyranny of the majority?
- frabbit 8y agoIsn't that when the car drivers get vast amounts of money spent on infrastructure so that they can inconvenience me?
- kareemsabri 8y agoSeems like a good example.
- KirinDave 8y agoAh yes. I've heard this argument. It's pretty puerile. Land, utilities and the environment aren't like human-made resources. They're finite. So there's some inevitable decision-making there. This may limit your absolute freedom, but no one promised you that anyways. It seems to me like having a majority of residents and workers supporting an initiative for local civic planning has a lot more legitimate authority than, say, a national vote on the same subject. At some point, you have to accept being an outlier.
- weeksie 8y agoCan we do Manhattan next? Haha, just kidding. The dysfunction of our city politics makes obvious life-improving policies completely untenable. Hell, we can't even change the way we collect our garbage or maintain our (totally necessary, vital) mass transit.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoI bet there's plenty of public money and quick decisions for SPORTS TEAMS though!
- cultus 8y agoI hear that. In King County (Seattle), we desperately need more public transit and funding for the homeless problem. The county decided that giving a $135 million handout to the Mariners to build a bigger beer garden (among other things) was a higher priority. Not only is this a flagrant waste of money, but it is highly unpopular.
- turtlebits 8y agoI wouldn't say it's a handout, they are signing a new 25 year lease, and the funds are supposed to address wear and tear. Seems reasonable to me as a landlord (in lieu of the owner of the stadium performing repairs).
- stochastic_monk 8y agoWhy wouldn’t the owner of the team or stadium (the ones making money with it) pay?
- bobthepanda 8y agoThey are. The county owns the stadium.
- deleted 8y ago
- anonymousDan 8y agoIt's very noticeable how pleasant Madrid is to wander around even currently in comparison to other big European cities. Cars seem well confined to certain streets and everywhere else is very quiet (in terms of traffic) in comparison.
- davidgould 8y agoI spent several days walking around Madrid about a decade ago. Compared even to the SF area cars were much less obtrusive. Most street level views were not completely blocked with cars. I as amazed when I got back how even potentially beautiful cityscapes here are cluttered up with cars - as if "used car lot" was our aesthetic ideal. So I'm really glad to seem them take this even further.
- kareemsabri 8y agoLot of anti-car folks on here. I'm inclined to agree we should discourage driving into city centers, but it's a tough ask when we've been driving forever and everyone owns cars. Telling my elderly father, who lives in the suburbs and drives everywhere, to take a train into the city to visit me is a non-starter, as another commenter pointed out. Habits are hard to break. However, I work in downtown San Francisco and live in Oakland, and I would NEVER drive my car over the bridge into the city, because of congestion. Banning cars outright seems to be a heavy-handed move and overly restrictive of individual choice, and you should just "price in the externalities" as the economists say. High tolls or expensive city driving permits for non-residents seems a better move to ease the transition as well as fund public transit options. They have to build up really, really good public transit infrastructure if they're going to make it more attractive than driving. To me the plethora of rules reads overwrought and complex, and "occasional visitors" seems ridiculous.
- ip26 8y agoWhat happens when your elderly father in the suburbs loses his license?
- kareemsabri 8y agoNot sure why he would do that, I see people much older than him still driving. But he'll stay home, I imagine. Or get rides from his family members, or younger wife.
- Retric 8y agoVision degradation with age is a common issue. Really though, public transit is vastly better from a heath, independence, financial, and safety standpoint for the elderly than driving.
- frabbit 8y agoNot to mention dementia, arthritis, diabetes, decreased articulation. Old people in rural areas and suburbs without mass transit are in a very vulnerable position.
- roknovosel 8y agoLjubljana has already made a similar effort: https://www.citylab.com/design/2016/02/how-ljubljana-turned-itself-into-europes-green-capital/458934/ https://www.citylab.com/design/2016/02/how-ljubljana-turned-...
- lucidguppy 8y agoSo we want cities that can let in delivery vans - but not people with cars. Sounds reasonable.
- ck425 8y agoYeah, it does. People can use public transport. Or legs.
- TomMarius 8y agoDefinitely not everyone and/or every time. Also time is a factor. And what about comfort? I'm not in favor of the current system, but your idea is wrong. It creates a centralized monopolized transportation system that serves well only a very small minority of people and might easily became a nightmare. There are other ways we could follow that would make much more people happy, support the economy and wouldn't make sick people stuck at home and everyone late. One such system could be a real time optimized network of self driving and self owning (limited AI) electric vehicles with various sizes and operation modes (on demand like taxi/bus-like/...) - and non-self driving vehicles wouldn't be allowed inside.
- 549362-30499 8y agoDriving in a city with even a basic public transit system is almost always slower than taking the train anyway, so time isn't really a factor. As for comfort, I don't think all the negative externalities of having a car-centric urban area are worth that trade off - what about the comfort of bikers and pedestrians that cars disrupt? In the US at least, we already massively subsidize road infrastructure and gasoline, I think it's fair to let people who actually live in cities enjoy them, rather than bend over backwards to accommodate suburbanites who only come in for work. Also, cars aren't a magic ticket to mobility. Elderly people often can't drive and end up stuck in their homes. They have to be purchased or leased, and maintained, etc.
- TomMarius 8y ago> Driving in a city with even a basic public transit system This is not true for almost every major EU city I've been in. Yeah, many routes yes, the common ones - of course. Once you need something more specific, it can take hours to get to the other side of the city. > what about the comfort of bikers and pedestrians that cars disrupt This is bad planning, not a side effect of having 4 wheel road vehicles. It'd be exactly the same with only public transit if you wouldn't change how you design roads. > Also, cars aren't a magic ticket to mobility. Elderly people often can't drive and end up stuck in their homes. They have to be purchased or leased, and maintained, etc. Not saying they are a magical solution to everything, I'm saying they help a lot - because they do. I was ill three times this year and having a car was literally a life saver, I wouldn't even be able to buy groceries without it. My grandmother wouldn't be able to get to her cottage without a car because public transport simply doesn't go there. My parents wouldn't be able to raise 2 kids with wildly different interests at the same time because they wouldn't get them to school and then themselves to work on time without cars - actually they wouldn't be able to work at all because of how much time they'd spent in a bus (we calculated it one time). BTW with comfort I meant this: During summer I drive car exclusively (taxi or mine) because I physically can't go inside a bus - it's so hot, humid and smelling that I start throwing up and losing consciousness almost before I go inside. Yes, I'm a particularly sensitive person but I'm not the only one. > They have to be purchased or leased, and maintained, etc. That would be solved with the system I proposed above. When I'm saying cars, I mean four wheel vehicles for ~4 persons, not that I'd like to maintain the entire current system as it is. I'd like to see more much optimization and
- HeadInTheClouds 8y agoI wish London would follow this example, I fear however that the press would whip up an outrage. Public transport in Central London is excellent. I have not felt the need to have a car after 20+ years of living here. The situation is obviously very different in rural areas. It would also be great to upgrade all Taxi's and buses to fully electric as well.
- alex_duf 8y agoTo license a new taxi in London it has to be electric. We're seeing quite a few nowadays. There's still a huge backlog of diesel cabs but at least it's slightly improving. New double deckers are hybrid, and all new single deckers are fully electric. Again, big backlog (8000) but give it 20 years. (I wish it could be done faster though)
- Symbiote 8y agoWith political will, the taxis could be solved in under 10 years — it's mad that they allow 15 year old taxis to operate. The buses should be solved much earlier, the average age is about 4-5 years. (Older buses seem to end up in Northern England...) https://tfl.gov.uk/corporate/publications-and-reports/bus-fleet-data-and-audits https://tfl.gov.uk/corporate/publications-and-reports/bus-fl...
- lightgreen 8y agoWhat’s wrong with 15 yo taxis as long as they are compatible with emission regulations? If they work fine, we should encourage long term cars usage and repairs instead of throwing them away after 5 years.
- ip26 8y agoThe emissions regulations of fifteen years ago are much more relaxed than today's, and of course old cabs are measured to the old standard- grandfathered if you will.
- sarahdavid130 8y agoReally great post.. Thanks foe Sharing
- clukic 8y agoAfter leaving NYC I've lived in more than a dozen European cities over the last five years. The one commonality that I've seen is that where ever an area is pedestrianized it just explodes with life. Terraces, shops, children, dogs. No one wants to be anywhere near a 100km/hr road. It can sometimes be ok to walk next to a 50km/hr road but it's not nice and it's best to avoid it. 30 km/hr you can stroll or sit on a terrace and it's fine. But when it's 20km/hr or just closed everything changes. When there's no chance your kid is going to get killed by a car, he can just go out and play. Your dog can sit off leash under your table while you eat. You can be absorbed in a conversation and not worry a misstep will result in serious injury or death. We somehow just accept that the possibility of death or jury is just outside our door. Like live electric wires running down streets. When you take them away, everyone just relaxes a lot more.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoThere have been pedestrianization attempts that failed. Just like failed malls. European cities mostly have a better layout for that sort of thing.
- cco 8y agoDo you have any examples? I'm always curious for counter points.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoI don't know examples offhand, sorry. I mean, there's some if you google "failed pedestrian malls".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tatami 8y agoThere were few mentioned in the comments to the article about Pontevedra. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18014283 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18014283
- village-idiot 8y agoThe dangers of car oriented cities has been so egregiously ignored, at least on a policy level, that strong and aggressive push backs are not surprising. Honestly, I think this is kinda what drivers get for fighting tooth and nail against bikelanes and public transit for decades.