3 ms·
Yes, well, I'm extremely suspicious of the "better tasting" claim in the article- and the use of the over-the-top terminology is not doing much to reassure me (
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
Yes, well, I'm extremely suspicious of the "better tasting" claim in the
article- and the use of the over-the-top terminology is not doing much to
reassure me ("super" tomatoes! Rrriiight).
To begin with, there is no need to edit wild varieties to produce tasty
tomatoes. The varities we have already are actually pretty damn good already.
It's the production and distribution methods that suck out all the taste and
purpose out of their miserable, sour existence.
For example, when I'm back home in Greece for the summer, I eat tomatoes that
taste of tomato and smell of tomato. They are usually grown by people,
normally grocers, in their gardens, in small numbers (though not necessarily
using organic means, if you were wondering). The grocers who grow them then
sell them in their stores, so you can find maybe a kilo of home-grown fruit in
a grocery store every other week or so, and often only in the summer (because
the grocers seldom have greenhouses). Note that this is only true in the
countryside- in the cities, like Athens, the quality is much more bland.
Like in Athens, the tomatoes I eat in the UK, where I live and work, are
boring, tasteless and miserable and they leave behind a lingering sensation of
disappointment and nostalgia of a faraway sunny land. As I understand it,
these commercial varieties are actually grown in Southern Europe (including
Greece) in vast greenhouses, from where they are picked when they're still
green and then allowed to "mature" (basically, slowly they rot) during
transportation in fridge trucks. These tomatoes have been abused to the point
of PTSD and it shows when you put them in your mouth: they are empty and
devoid of all taste, fragrance and meaning and can drive a sane eater to
depression.
So forget about mass-producing and mass-distributing decent-tasting tomatoes.
You can mass-produce tomatoes that satisfy the farmers, with characteristics
that make them profitable to sell; and you can mass-produce tomatoes that the
majority of consumers will accept, mournfully, but only because they seldom
have the chance to buy and eat good ones, and have probably even forgotten
what tomatoes actualy taste like.
But you can't mass-produce good tomatoes.
- crististm 8y agoUnfortunately, you can say this until you are blue in the face and those who should listen will turn a deaf ear. You can drown them in good tomatoes and they will not see them to save their lives.
- petters 8y ago> But you can't mass-produce good tomatoes. I thought the whole point of this article was that you can, with gene editing.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoMy point is that gene-editing may breed "super", "awesome", "badass" tomatoes, but it can't breed tomatoes you really want to eat. So I doubt the article's premise very much. Basically, my intuition is that you can't take a shortcut around the long time that it takes to develop good, tasty foodstuffs. For example, you can't hurry the production of good wine, you can't make olives mature overnight, or grow healthy animals in a day and you can't produce good varieties of vegetables in a few months of experiments. It takes literally generations of trial-and-error to get things right. And any effort to cheat time and speed-up processes ends up producing inferior products. This has always been the case, regardless of the technology- and the more recent advances, like CRISPR, only promise to speed things up, which is exactly what has steadily, constantly, failed until now with all the earlier technology that also promised to speed things up, only less so. This is my intuition, anyway. I've eaten plenty of fast-food, mass-produced and cheap. I'm probably 50% pizza, 30% souvlaki and 10% burgers. But I know the difference between all that crap and the 20% that is my grandmothers' cooking (which was divine) and the local produce I eat every summer, when I go to the countryside. There is just no comparison between the crap that we eat out of convenience and the stuff that people eat when they have the time to grow it and cook it at leisure. That must have something to do with the fact that figuring out what really tastes good is bloody hard, because taste (and fragrance) are such difficult senses to quantify. So even if science promises to make tomatoes feel tastier- well, the only measure of that is our own taste buds. And those cannot be relied upon, except over a very long timeframe, like generations- over generations, people choose the best varieties of grape that make the best wine; over generations, they pick the best varieties of fruit that have the most taste; the best vegetables, and so on. We won't succeed in reproducing that in a couple of years, no matter how much we science the shit out of it.
- sp332 8y agoYour comment kinda highlights the point of the exercise. Attempts to breed shelf-stable varieties have accidentally bred out a lot of the flavor. But an analysis of the genes involved shows that these qualities are not inextricably linked. With the right tools, you can make tomatoes physically tough enough to ship well without sacrificing that tomato taste.
- crististm 8y agoHow do you know this?
- sametmax 8y agoYou can't make void taste good. The problem of the tomatoes is not their genetic material but the fact their environnement is empty of the things that make them good. You can create the most badass tomatoes you want, they can't create things out of thin air.
- craigsmansion 8y agoI guess it really takes someone originating from a genuine food culture to drive the emotion home ("tasteless and miserable and they leave behind a lingering sensation of disappointment and nostalgia of a faraway sunny land", wonderful), especially on a technically oriented board. Genetic tech is exciting, but tasty tomatoes are a solved problem: just pay extra for time and dedication and demand quality. And just as with software there are likely no magic bullets to solve the 2 out of 3 of cheap-fast-good problem without significant side effects.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoHeh. Sorry to disappoint you, but like all kids growing up in Southern Europe, in recent years, the proportion of my diet that was Mediterrannean was unfortunately, small. The rest was pasta, chips, steaks, burgers, pizzas, and altogether too much salt and sugar. This is typical- Greece has now the highest rate of child obesity in the EU, and our once healthy, and tasty, diets, have been largely replaced by a predominance of red meat, pasta, rice and potatoes. Thankfully, in between eating all that crap, I was also lucky to have two grandmothers that cooked traditionaly dishes with great skill, and to escape to the countryside every summer, where the local produce was incomparably better than whatever I could by in the big city. So at the very least, I know what we have lost :/
- sametmax 8y agoI have the same view, espacially moving from France to the US. But it also affect the nutriotional content : the same quantity of food won't satisfy my needs in the US. Combining those 2 issues, you understant a lot of the health problem we face. I can't blame kids for choosing the ice cream pot when the damn apple taste like garbage, hurt your teeth and doesn't provide you with thz feeling of eating something you need.