4 ms·
From 2016, https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/03/report-apple-designing-its-own-servers-to-avoid-snooping/ https://arstechnica.com/information-
by walterbell 8y ago
From 2016, https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/03/report-apple-designing-its-own-servers-to-avoid-snooping/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/03/repor...
> Apple has begun designing its own servers partly because of suspicions that hardware is being intercepted before it gets delivered to Apple, according to a report yesterday from The Information. "Apple has long suspected that servers it ordered from the traditional supply chain were intercepted during shipping, with additional chips and firmware added to them by unknown third parties in order to make them vulnerable to infiltration, according to a person familiar with the matter," the report said. "At one point, Apple even assigned people to take photographs of motherboards and annotate the function of each chip, explaining why it was supposed to be there. Building its own servers with motherboards it designed would be the most surefire way for Apple to prevent unauthorized snooping via extra chips."
- MR4D 8y agoIf you have all the resources of a state actor to accomplish this, it’s owuld not be a chip on the motherboard, it would be a set of circuits in the motherboard. Why make something easy to photograph when you can embed it an area that can only be seen in an x-ray? That’s how I’d do it at least.
- thinkmassive 8y agoThe original Bloomberg article said some of the chips were so thin they were sandwiched between PCB layers.
- xevb3k 8y agoOr just replace an existing chip, which is the most logical way to do it...
- ggggtez 8y agoHow do you know they don't do that too? This is just one news story, from one manufacturer.
- xevb3k 8y agoI’m mean they could do that too... but why do this weirdly awkward thing described by Bloomberg at all? It’s not like doing both is extra sure, it’s just weirdly difficult and more easily detectable to do it in the way described.
- lmm 8y agoThat seemed to match the lightbluetouchpaper description - the "hack chip" goes where the optional legacy (non-quad) SPI chip would go.
- xevb3k 8y agoGiven the size estimation, it wouldn’t cover the whole footprint. But... why put it on an unpopulated footprint. Why not just replace the original Quad SPI IC with a backdoored device?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lmm 8y agoWhat do you then do when they upgrade/change the Quad SPI IC? A separate chip means a stable interface they can conform to.
- mrb 8y agoAltering the flash chip would be too obvious. It's a textbook 101 supply chain attack... Looking at the flash image (dumping it) or chip (x-raying it) would be the first thing anyone would do if they suspected something fishy. A tiny SPI man-in-the-middle chip sandwiched between the PCB fiberglass layers is a lot more discrete and more generic (same MitM chip fiddling with transmitted bytes can attack many different flash platforms, regardless of the sizes/pinouts/footprints of the flash chips).
- andrewstuart2 8y agoOr even, why make it visible on an x-ray when you could make it only visible on a microscope after cutting open an IC?
- 4684499 8y ago> suspected > to prevent Considering the article is credible, it doesn't mean Apple has found anything, it only means they were being cautious,
- dpkonofa 8y agoThis doesn't really mean anything, though. For all we know the "person familiar with the matter" is the same source Bloomberg used in their report. There's still not acknowledgement from Apple in 2016 that anything like this was actually happening.
- captainmuon 8y ago> At one point, Apple even assigned people to take photographs of motherboards and annotate the function of each chip, explaining why it was supposed to be there. I have done this before, and we actually found an unspeced part! Thankfully, it was not from a malicious state actor, but just one supplier being creative and not telling anybody. Especially if you don't have an iron grip on your supply chain, you have to be vigilant. As a manufacturer, there are more problems to watch out for than espionage.
- alxlaz 8y agoThis is more common than one would think. I've done something like this several times before, too -- not taking photographs, but reviewing the actual board against the layout and specs. I found unspecced parts twice; the first time it was pretty innocent, just a couple of 0-ohm resistors that weren't marked on the schematics (understandable from ODMs who want to reuse the same design but annoying to debug when it goes wrong). The second time it was a pair of clamping diodes that should have been there from the very beginning (I don't know how it slipped by the initial schematic review; I wasn't working there when it happened). They weren't on any schematics, and when we requested an up-to-date BoM, they were tucked away under another set of diodes, despite being a different part. I also found parts that had been changed without notice (one of which had the potential to be tons of fun because it was a crystal oscillator with a far worse tolerance than the original). When the supply chain itself, the management effort and the handling of the supply chain gets so large that it's done almost completely overseas, by a whole team of different people, under constant time pressure and in various degrees of partnerships with other companies (not just those who sell the supplies), these things can slip between the cracks surprisingly easy.
- richsherwood 8y agoReading this makes me understand the decision about them licking down on repairs a little more. If a Mac won’t boot because of tampering (repairing) then it essentially solves this problem. I’m a little conflicted if it’s the case as I think we have the right to repair our own devices but distrust of any state actors (locally and internationally) is also pretty high.