3 ms·
The thing is - self-driving cars fundamentally change the structure of the automobile market in a way that negates many of the advantages of existing automakers
by nostrademons 8y ago
The thing is - self-driving cars fundamentally change the structure of the automobile market in a way that negates many of the advantages of existing automakers. Instead of private ownership of cars, they encourage ride-sharing services, because the car can pick up a different passenger on the return trip and no longer has to park. Instead of internal combustion engines, they encourage EVs, both because of the power-draw of the self-driving hardware and because refueling becomes the responsibility of the service, which can program them to return to base and not pick up any new passengers once they're getting low on charge. Instead of servicing being a huge pain that encourages buyers to put a premium on reliable cars, maintenance is handled by a centralized maintenance department full of professionals. Instead of family cars, they encourage small motorcycle-like "pods" sized for a single occupant (with a smaller number of family cars or trucks available for family trips).
Already, that negates the advantages of consumer brand, reliability, dealer networks, internal combustion engines, ergonomics, and bodywork. There's not all that much left to the auto industry, once all that changes.
- hef19898 8y agoEven if you are right with everything you predicted (some of it, all of it is doubtfull), that does not negate the core competencies of traditional car makers. You still need someone to buold cars -> existing car makers EVs are actually easier to built than EVs -> inceeasing the advantage they have on production Maintenance -> to be done locally, there is no way to centralize it on a full continent, car makers and their existing network are king Fleet management -> see above, plus existing fleet mgt serives, only real competition are large rental car companies Ride sharing -> acquisitions, mytaxi in the case of Mercendes, drivenow and car2go in the case of Mercedes and BMW, VW with an in-house solution Self-driving -> acquisition of the provider (GM and Cruise) or sourcing the tech, alternative is a partnership (Jaguar) Traditional car makers slept into these developments, a few years ago I would have bet a lot on disruptors in that industry. Now that changed, the only "tech" (as in software) companies that can compete are the likes of Google and maybe Uber as long as VC money doesn't run out. The same is true for certain smaller manufacturers of automobiles, but this market cleaning is gling on for while now so they are used to it. And let's fave it, the automotive sector is well entrenched in politics (Europe, Japan and the US, Chine, too) and money generally is not a rwal problem. So, yeah, now I would say Google / Wymo might become a major Tier one supplier. But hardly more.
- glenrivard 8y agoWhen you large fleets of cars you will do maintenance more like how cars are built. With basically an assembly line. But you would also push some of the work out to cheaper labor and centrally. So replace the entire wheel instead of the tire. Then ship off the wheel with the old tire to be replaced somewhere else and centrally. But it is about the economics. Today car dealers lose money on every car sold and make their money from maintenance. “Yes, the typical new car sold loses a dealership about $200.” https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/articles/show_me_the_money_how_do_car_dealerships_make_their_profit https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/articles/show_me_the_money_how... Which is why maintenance is so expensive. I would expect Waymo to invest heavily on improving this significantly. Waymo will not be a tier 1 provider, IMO. They have shared rolling out their commercial ride sharing in Arizona later this year and testing today. The thing is they started way earlier then others. This is from nine years ago. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4V2bcbJZuPQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4V2bcbJZuPQ Google was the top place to work for six straight years and so they were getting the cream of the crop. They then get to triage those engineers and send the cream of the crop of the cream of the crop to Waymo. Then there is the massive infrastructure that Google has to leverage. SDC is an software engineering exercise. Who is better at software engineering? Look at the automated testing that Waymo has. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/08/inside-waymos-secret-testing-and-simulation-facilities/537648/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/08/insid... How would you ever do SDC without this?
- glenrivard 8y agoGreat post and completely agree. Today cars are sold through dealers. Those dealers lose money on every car sold. “Yes, the typical new car sold loses a dealership about $200.” https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/articles/show_me_the_money_how_do_car_dealerships_make_their_profit https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/articles/show_me_the_money_how... They make their money from maintenance and why maintenance is so expensive and so common. Waymo or any other company running very large fleets of cars would fix this. They would take the service data each year and invest to improve. Plus you have perfect data on how the car was used with SDC. Car designs will also change. Today you have to design around the person being able to see when driving. No longer needed.
- maxerickson 8y agoHow is the power draw even a factor for the fuel? A sedan is using 10 or 20 kW just driving around, 2 kW to power a computer isn't going to require fundamentally rethinking anything, just a correctly sized alternator (or whatnot these days). That electricity is cheaper is the big factor, especially for a service doing shorter runs. Whether it's used for traction or steering doesn't really matter.