4 ms·
> Let’s assume an implant was added to the motherboard at manufacture time. This needed modification of both the board design, and the robotic component install
by mindslight 8y ago
> Let’s assume an implant was added to the motherboard at manufacture time. This needed modification of both the board design, and the robotic component installation process. It intercepts the SPI lines between the flash and the BMC controller
Circuit wise, you don't really need to "intercept" (place in series with) the SPI lines. Two parallel drivers [0] will generally fight it out quietly, and you can guarantee yours will win by designing your implant to have the beefier driver (and perhaps only changing 1's to 0's, as P-channel FETs are generally weaker).
If there already was a footprint for an extra chip (debugging, part flexibility, etc), then it would not require modification of the board design. And an extra component can easily be hand soldered afterwards outside of the standard robotic component placing.
[0] The standard topology of SPI, but in proper operation only one is active due to CS lines.
- theomarkettos 8y agoPost author here. That was what I was thinking of - simply overdriving the lines to drag them high or low in opposition to the 'official' driver. That's pretty much all you can do with 6 pins. I was trying not to overcomplicate the explanation, since the material is already complicated enough! Fair point about hand soldering, however it would be more obvious to the manufacturing employees for an entire production batch to be diverted to have parts added manually than to simply sneak in another reel to the hundred on the pick and place machine.
- mindslight 8y agoI just thought that was phrased as if it were a necessary requirement for the attack, rather than a description of a likely approach. I could also see a scenario where only the occasional unit was bugged, and then an agent at the distributor made sure the right customers received the bugged units. Thank you for writing your article! I'm currently a bit out of the security headspace and reading the Bloomberg article had me scratching my head like what are the actual details here.