5 ms·
If they are under a gag order, they would simply not comment on it. Lying about it is never required and puts them at risk for shareholder lawsuits.
by lern_too_spel 8y ago
If they are under a gag order, they would simply not comment on it. Lying about it is never required and puts them at risk for shareholder lawsuits.
- lozaning 8y agoI wonder if there isn't some level of national security super mega secret scenario situation where the government requires companies to do something and the government indemnifies them against all risks associated with the required action.
- trhway 8y agohasn't it been the case with NSA and carriers all along? http://articles.latimes.com/2012/oct/09/business/la-fi-court-wiretapping-20121010 http://articles.latimes.com/2012/oct/09/business/la-fi-court... "Congress granted retroactive immunity to people or companies aiding U.S. intelligence agents." In this case i'd not be surprised if Google/FB/AMZN/Apple/MS/Supermicro were even part of the CIA/NSA counter-sting - feeding of the false info back to Chinese intelligence through the detected 'mistery' chips.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoThe carriers never lied about it. They were provided immunity from criminal lawsuits, not civil lawsuits.
- rrix2 8y agoHow does the USG indemnify these companies for the massive breach of trust if that's indeed the case? You can't pay for trust.
- ryanmarsh 8y agoI would be highly surprised if this wasn’t the case.
- stephenr 8y agoApple specifically states that they are not under any form of gag/confidentiality order/conditions: > Finally, in response to questions we have received from other news organisations since Businessweek published its story, we are not under any kind of gag order or other confidentiality obligations.
- amoshi 8y agoAnd if they were, you think they would admit it?
- avip 8y agoThey would not have blatantly lied about it in an official statement. That could not have passed legal.
- zanmat0 8y agoAren't they required to do so in the context of a NSL?
- djrogers 8y agoNo, they are not required to provide materially false information in direct violation of SarbOx, the SEC, and several other federal agencies and statutes - not to mention the various EU laws surrounding such activity. If they were under an NSL they would simply not comment on this at all. That would be pretty normal for Apple, so people would probably take it in stride.
- ocschwar 8y agoNo. THere's plenty of case law establishing that you cannot be compelled to outright lie.
- Arbitrary4657 8y agoMost of Apple's "creative image" is one gigantic lie. Why would they suddenly have scruples now?
- walshemj 8y agoIn all cases? possibly not if it is covered by national security.
- rossdavidh 8y agoAre you sure about that? I recall reading, in reference to canary clauses (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary) that the government can and has required lying. If there's an ongoing national security concern, I would expect that they would.
- gowld 8y agoThe article you linked is primarily a disproof of your claim. It cites some hearsay speculation that Warrant Canaries are illegal, and cites several court cases that say Warrant Canaries are protected and compelled lies are illegal: "West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette and Wooley v. Maynard rule the Free Speech Clause prohibits compelling someone to speak against one's wishes; this can easily be extended to prevent someone from being compelled to lie."
- cjarrett 8y ago--no. That's not how this works.