4 ms·
Part of me wonders if it's possible that there's just something about the nature of the internet that induces instability in otherwise-ordinary people. I think
by kibwen 8y ago
Part of me wonders if it's possible that there's just something about the nature of the internet that induces instability in otherwise-ordinary people. I think about photosensitive epilepsy and how it was a more-or-less benign feature of the human brain until technological progress caused flashing lights to be absolutely everywhere. I worry that I can't discount the possibility that some heretofore latent feature of human thinking is incompatible (in a physiological sense, not just a psychological sense) with being perpetually plugged into the internet. I know enough people that have gone from "totally outwardly normal" to "detached-from-reality, Hillary Clinton is a lizard person" (this isn't an exaggeration, yes, people I know in real life appear to sincerely think this) and I'm struggling to think of what else could contribute to such seeming mass psychosis. It's more than just propaganda, it's people deliberately abandoning critical thinking.
- tuesdayrain 8y agoI think the internet creates instability at least partially because 1. Anonymity/distance lets people say things they would never dare say in person and 2. Most people naturally perceive others' internet comments as if they were said in person. It takes a conscious effort to desensitize yourself to the raw bluntness found in heated online discussions, and many people never get to that point. So controversial topics frequently lead to nasty positive feedback loops that would have never occured in a face to face conversation.
- cafard 8y agoHere's a link referring to the days somewhat before Twitter: http://prospect.org/article/lbj-and-dallass-mink-coat-mob http://prospect.org/article/lbj-and-dallass-mink-coat-mob
- burlesona 8y agoI'd just call it "road rage." There's some research into this and my high-level understanding is that when people feel "safe inside their armor" - whether that's the metal of the car or the semi-anonymity of the internet, their animal instincts come out. It's fueled from both directions. In a tweet you don't really have context or body language or any of the other signals to tell you how someone means their message to be taken, so it's a lot easier to unintentionally offend. And then because you don't have to face the consequences of digitally "throwing a punch" a lot of people just fire off a nasty tweet without really caring. I guess I see it as not surprising. Civilization is fragile, and the institutions that hold it up take generations to build. All of it is basically a thin veneer over our animal selves that helps us individually and collectively function as a higher level creature than we really are. The internet fundamentally changes most things about communication and therefore human interaction and therefore the institutions of civilization itself. And really, looking back at the original internet ethos, that was kind of the point. So it shouldn't be surprising that something we use to "disrupt" civilization is in fact disruptive to civilization.
- savanaly 8y agoHuh, that's interesting because introspection tells me it's the opposite for me. When I'm in my safe zone is when I can comfortably be rational and calm almost all the time. If I ever said something rash or that I didn't mean it would probably be when someone engages me and makes me feel uncomfortable in real life, never over the internet.
- burlesona 8y agoYeah I mean people are all different. I know what you mean about feeling calmer behind the keyboard, something about seeing what I'm about to say often makes me tone it down or rephrase it. Not everyone goes nuts behind the wheel of a car either. But the thing is when the potential mob is the entire national or world population it doesn't take a very large percentage of the mob going "road rage" to turn the thing violent, you know what I mean? It's like the whole "yelling fire in a crowded theater" problem.
- chibg10 8y agoIt's complicated I think. Behind the keyboard, there generally aren't the same social pressures (due to anonymity and often others aren't directing their thoughts at you as an individual, but rather as a group) and time constraints to organize thoughts that come with oral communication. This, in many cases, allows for better and more rational discussions. On the other hand, when people do directly address on the internet behind the veil of anonymity, the lack of social pressures also removes disincentives to act like hooligans. It's different form of communication and has its advantages and disadvantages.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoIt is what you are saying, and exacerbated by the huge gap in power and control between elites/politicians and the average person. You have CEOs and politicians making decisions that ruin people's lives. With Twitter, people are suddenly put at the same level where they can speak back to power, directly and angrily.
- chongli 8y agoI worry that I can't discount the possibility that some heretofore latent feature of human thinking is incompatible (in a physiological sense, not just a psychological sense) with being perpetually plugged into the internet. The answer you're looking for is Dunbar's Number [1] and it's been an issue since the agricultural revolution. Humans simply struggle to cooperate with, care about, and even understand people outside of a small group. Human societies have developed governments and legal codes in response. It's not a perfect system, though, and the Internet has begun to reveal the cracks in the mortar. Prior to the Internet, groups of people tended to segregate themselves geographically. This allowed independent cultures, governments, and legal systems to develop. The Internet has broken down those barriers and revealed the contradiction to all of us. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar's_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar's_number
- rubicon33 8y agoHuman beings are susceptible to "group think". If a large group of people are saying something, we're more likely to believe it, which means we are more likely to parrot it, which means the group of people that subscribe to that thought grows. It's a recursive cycle. The internet has created the biggest connection of people the world has ever seen. It's no surprise that among the many who use it, there are a bunch that lack critical thinking, and tend to just subscribe to whatever group roughly matches their ideology. It's not long before theories like Hillary Clinton being a lizard can start to gain traction.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI think the internet just makes craziness possible on a much larger scale. It's much easier for manipulators to spread false information to a large number of people. Previously it wasn't that easy to enrage millions of people.
- davidw 8y ago"The social dynamics of the net are a direct consequence of the fact that nobody has yet developed a Remote Strangulation Protocol." - Larry Wall
- pjc50 8y ago> gone from "totally outwardly normal" to "detached-from-reality, Hillary Clinton is a lizard person" Millions of dollars of advertising money have gone into making them think that - and into reducing their desire to do critical thinking. https://www.politico.com/story/2015/01/super-pac-scams-114581 https://www.politico.com/story/2015/01/super-pac-scams-11458... https://talkingpointsmemo.com/cafe/why-conservatives-suddenly-care-about-political-mail-order-scams https://talkingpointsmemo.com/cafe/why-conservatives-suddenl... https://www.vox.com/2015/10/23/9603028/conservative-marketing-scam https://www.vox.com/2015/10/23/9603028/conservative-marketin... https://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-long-con https://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-long-con (2012!) https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2018/04/scam-pacs-misleading-donors/ https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2018/04/scam-pacs-misleadin... .. and that doesn't even require involving questions of foreign intelligence agencies and "psyops".
- cirgue 8y agoTwitter is the collective thoughts of humanity when we're on our boring train commute, at home in our underwear at 2:00 am alone in our apartments, trying to waste time at work, in line at the supermarket, and in myriad other situations that put us at our most misanthropic, isolated, bitter, and sad. Twitter generally is a toxic cesspit, and the only reason to go on there is because whatever is going on in your life is worse than that.
- lisper 8y agoI think anonymity is a major contributing factor. Here's a data point: I worked at JPL between 1988 and 2000. Somewhere during that time period -- I don't recall exactly when -- the IT people set up an internal Usenet newsgroup that could be posted to anonymously. The idea was that it would be a forum for people to candidly discuss issues that needed to be addressed by management. Almost immediately it degenerated into a Lord-of-the-Flies style melee of the sort that is all too familiar today, but which was new and shocking back in the days before the WWW was really a thing. And this was not just random people off the street. These were all JPL employees, of which there were about 7000 back in the day. It went on for several months until IT decided to disallow anonymous posting, and all the acrimony immediately ceased.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoI believe it's supernormal stimuli.[1] In short, we tend to think of quality of something and the quantity of it as distinct. In essense, communication has a good quality so we should increase it's quantity. However, over time the quantity of the good transforms it's quality. Ice cream for desert once a week or once a month is a wonderful treat. Ice cream for every meal is a depressing slog. New modes of communication tap into the primal desire of people to engage in social action, the repeated tapping of that desire however has pulled most of the good stuff and now we're getting into the ugliness that lies beneath. [1] http://www.stuartmcmillen.com/comic/supernormal-stimuli/ http://www.stuartmcmillen.com/comic/supernormal-stimuli/