4 ms·
For the law as written, sounds like a very fair sentence for the guilty.
by bdcravens 8y ago
For the law as written, sounds like a very fair sentence for the guilty.
- uncoder0 8y agoYeah... I don't agree that prison time is appropriate but, I do suppose the sentence was not too excessive. I suppose for most people a couple weeks in the clink is better than the 1,000,000+ fines we were seeing for copyright infringement in the 90's. Although since this is criminal I guess he could still have civil liability.
- bashallah 8y agoSpend a day in jail and then think about 3 weeks and whether it’s “fair”.
- ArchTypical 8y agoIt's not that bad. 3 weeks means you're going to county jail (in California). 3 weeks in county is great. They feed you a bunch (5 times a day), you aren't there long enough that you are compelled to get a jail-time-job, and the weather is fair. There's a TV, books, paper, pens, cards, etc.
- malcolmgreaves 8y agoJail: where you'll loose your current job and be destined for minimum wage for the rest of your life!
- loceng 8y agoThis does bring to the light potential issues, like whether a person has any or many coping mechanisms that are part of their routine - such as perhaps certain types of entertainment, certain routine of walking places, certain comfort from their regular environment(s) or physical/material goods. For someone in a severe state and need of coping mechanisms/strategies (whether they realize it or not, whether they have any support or people helping them), it could be extremely harsh for them — so therefore, it’s relative to everyone as to what impact, or how easy it would be. For myself, if I had enough food that didn’t hurt or bother me to eat, clean water, pen and paper, place to sleep properly, then 3 weeks would be good time for deep reflection and meditation. For someone else it could be torment. And it’s not hard to assume that someone who blatantly uploads a copyright video publicly to Facebook may not have the best critical thinking skills, and therefore not the best self-care or self-awareness, awareness overall.
- olliej 8y agoTo put this in perspective: Brock turner got 3 months for rape - so is 3 weeks a proportional sentence?
- kennywinker 8y agoUsing prison for non-violent offenses is ridiculous, in my opinion. For anyone who thinks “better that than a huge fine” - explain to me the difference between that and debtors prison.
- loceng 8y agoTo begin, I'm not arguing nor have I come to any conclusion related to whether a fine or prison time is appropriate, however a fine/financial cost is very relative to a person's financial situation, and it is also more subtle, and perhaps also in some areas someone could simply declare bankruptcy or a fine will have no impact if their life is already "in the shitter." Prison on the other hand is a concrete/tangible separation from a person's regular life/routine, and so it's guaranteed to not be subtle - however as I replied elsewhere in this thread - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18150041 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18150041 - how prison affects someone can vary greatly and be much more detrimental than what a financial cost could potentially have, and I think it would be immoral to not properly account for this - if prison time is going to be allocated; another variable to account for is around the world "prison time" has great variability as to the conditions someone is put into, likewise with the social/safety constructs of taking care of people, or not.