3 ms·
I haven't read Mine Kampf and I don't like Nazis or Socialism for that matter. But are you certain that every single chapter of that book is 100% genocidal rubb
by roenxi 8y ago
I haven't read Mine Kampf and I don't like Nazis or Socialism for that matter. But are you certain that every single chapter of that book is 100% genocidal rubbish? Because I'm guessing that out of the ~15 or so chapters there is probably one that is palatable.
The German's didn't go in to WWII because they were just terrible people. They had a very long list of quite justifiable grievances after WWI. If they hadn't been proud supporters of eugenics they'd be just another entry in a long list of bloodthirsty European states.
EDIT So here is a selected paragraph (from 3 random candidates) from said text. It isn't exactly anti-factual.
"Thus, from a certain vanity, which is always a cousin of stupidity, the great mass of politicians will keep far removed from all really weighty plans for the future, in order not to lose the momentary sympathy of the great mob. The success and significance of such a politician lie then exclusively in the present, and do not exist for posterity. But small minds are little troubled by this; they are content."
- jbattle 8y agoThere are WAY too many compelling thinkers in the world to read to justify any of my time sifting through Hitler's writings hoping to find some nuggets that are not "100% genocidal rubbish". I'm imagine he advocated for exercise and a good diet at some point. Why we need to try to find something useful the man said is utterly beyond me.
- roenxi 8y agoThe claim is that a journal published a rewritten chapter of Mein Kampf and that journal is therefore bad. I don't think that is a reasonable argument. It depends on what the chapter was talking about. If it made a big point about Jewish conspiracies and keeping the American people ethnically pure then that is a problem. If it was 1,000 words complaining about vision-less politicians then what is the issue?
- jbattle 8y agoIf we are talking in the context of submitting it as a paper to a journal, then a problem is plagiarism. If we are talking about "does hitler have some non-genocidal ideas?" then like I said, not sure I care. "How was hitler so persuasive?" Interesting. "How did hitler outmanuever his opposition domestic and foreign" . Interesting. But yes you have a fair point that just because Hilter said X doesn't automatically invalidate X. The old "the nazis drank milk so dont drink milk" fallacy
- yorwba 8y agoThe chapter used was http://www.mondopolitico.com/library/meinkampf/v1c12.htm http://www.mondopolitico.com/library/meinkampf/v1c12.htm according to the authors. If you replace all mentions of Germans, Marxists, Jews and any other related details by appropriate counterparts, you can probably fit the template to any "us vs. them" narrative you want. Of course the aversion to Mein Kampf is mostly due to Hitler's choice of "us" and "them" (EDIT: and the means used to fight "them", but they are not the focus of that chapter, as far as I can tell), so by rewriting the chapter they have also removed the reasons why it's taboo. But most people who hear about this story are unlikely to consider whether the essence of Nazism is preserved in the rewritten version and will simply associate it with "feminazis".