3 ms·
Maybe someone with better legal chops can explain this to me; how is the Internet Archive's internet arcade MAME stuff not considered piracy? I'm not saying I
by tombert 8y ago
Maybe someone with better legal chops can explain this to me; how is the Internet Archive's internet arcade MAME stuff not considered piracy? I'm not saying I don't support it (I think data preservation is important, even if it involves "piracy"), but it seems like a huge legal headache to a lay-man.
- ISV_Damocles 8y agoFrom the Internet Archive FAQ: [0] > The Internet Archive (Archive.org) is a nonprofit library that preserves digital cultural artifacts, and provides online access to over a million users a day with the goal of universal access to all knowledge. Since it's a library, it has special copyright exceptions that make their emulation efforts legal, as Section 108 was updated to allow libraries to circulate digital copies of material online and off-premises. [1] So it would have been a huge legal headache if they hadn't been given the explicit exception to do this. Edit: oh, caveat that IANAL, but this was what was explained to me on another forum thread a couple of years ago when they first started their emulation efforts. [0]: https://archive.org/about/faqs.php https://archive.org/about/faqs.php [1]: https://crln.acrl.org/index.php/crlnews/article/view/8932/9652 https://crln.acrl.org/index.php/crlnews/article/view/8932/96...
- comex 8y agoJudging by [1], I'm pretty sure updating section 108 is still a proposal. In this case, my impression is that the Internet Archive is basically ignoring copyright law and hoping nobody complains, relying on the lack of commercial value in such obsolete software, and to a small extent the moral high ground our society assigns to libraries. [1] https://www.districtdispatch.org/2017/09/copyright-office-releases-draft-bill-change-section-108/ https://www.districtdispatch.org/2017/09/copyright-office-re...
- pkaye 8y agoCalifornia declared it a library so it has rights to do this data preservation.