4 ms·
Why is there so much rising extremism, period?
by chrisco255 8y ago
Why is there so much rising extremism, period?
- tomcam 8y agoIs it extremist to support Kavanaugh?
- Double_a_92 8y agoWomen must always be believed! Everything else is an extremist sexist view, enforced my old white cis males in powerful positions! /s
- dang 8y agoPlease don't do this here.
- Double_a_92 8y agoThat's appearently the opinion of most high-tech companies. Why can't I criticize that here in a sarcastic manner? I thought this was about discussions... Or are you just talking about the sarcasm part? Can we not use basic rhetoric styles here?
- chrisco255 8y agoNo, it's a mainstream view for the conservative half of the United States.
- RickS 8y agoRespectfully, and with the hope that we can keep it civil here, I put forth that these two things are not mutually exclusive.
- RickS 8y agoMaybe. I would argue after watching the hearing that anyone who so blatantly ignores the obvious intent of questions asked of them, rather than attempting to pursue and convey the truth in earnest, regardless of their guilt, is unqualified to enforce justice at the highest level in America. I struggle to imagine a credible reason to look past this conduct, and would be interested in hearing a take on it. To be clear, I don't have a take on whether he's guilty, and I don't think it particularly matters. I'm operating based solely on his bad-faith responses to interview questions. It could be argued that the questions asked of him were themselves in bad faith, but that doesn't seem like it should change anything, since it's critical for a judge to be resilient to bad faith questioning, rather than sinking to that level and rolling in the mud. If a person has a different take that involves him being levelheaded, truthful, nonpartisan in the face of immense partisanship, and dedicated to the pursuit of justice, then no, it is not extremist to support him. If a person can recognize him as being at all deficient in any of those categories and yet supports his nomination out of partisan dedication, despite intellectual qualities that should disqualify him, I would classify that as extreme.
- chrisco255 8y agoWe have to presume Kavanaugh's innocence because no witness has come forward to corroborate any claims. In the meantime, the Democrats skewered a man for every inside joke he made in his High school yearbook with his buddies. They were picking apart his actions as a child. They weren't asking questions related to the allegations. They were trying to assassinate his character. That's fucked up I don't care who you are. Who would like to sit on trial for things you said 40 years ago? And have a mass media misinterpret everything out of context? It's fucking primitive. Who wouldn't lose their composure? Only a cool, level headed liar like Bill Clinton could pull that off.
- RickS 8y agoMy comment was specific and deliberate in presuming his innocence, which, to reiterate, I do. I was also deliberate in my pointing-out that many of the questions asked of him could be perceived as being in bad faith. Whether that's so is quite subjective. Your "inside joke" is other people's "description of a sex act". For the same reason we can't truly know Kav's innocence or guilt, we can't know whether the jokes are harmful or not. I want to point out a distinction that I made, that I'm not sure you're making: I don't discredit Kavanaugh because he "lost his cool". I too would most certainly be crying in that situation, without a doubt. But when Leahy pressed him, repeatedly over a span of excruciatingly long minutes, to explicitly request and comply with an investigation, and Kavanaugh dodged and bent over backwards to avoid doing such a thing, I found it difficult to understand how a person interested in the truth could behave in that way. A SCOTUS judge should be wiling to be investigated, and expected to survive such a thing.
- chrisco255 8y agoNot if all standards of due process and normal jurisprudence were thrown out the fucking window. These allegations were held in the pocket as a political football instead of being handed over to a bipartisan committee and investigated by the FBI from the get go. Feinstein's unethical manipulation of this allegation in the handling of Dr. Ford and outright lies about her alleged fear of flying in order to prevent her being forensically interviewed, like a normal case, are inexcusable. The Democrats had two months to hatch a plan while Kavanaugh's life got turned upside down in less than a week. That's a legal ambush, complete with an angry mob. It's not just at all.
- exmicrosoldier 8y agoIn the context of most supreme court nominees, combined with the amount of contoversy surrounding his appointment yes. Every tier one tech company I ever worked for would not hire someone that caused that much ill will, from a culture perspective. The brand of the supreme court is seen as a wise, impartial, authorative, servant of the people. An imperious, rabidly partisan, agressive, evasive, offended, entitled boy damages that brand. A nonpartisan, considered, empathetic, distinguished man does not.
- chrisco255 8y agoWho caused the ill will? The man accused of something he didn't do? Or the Democrats who manufactured a mock trial with all the optics of one and with none of the evidence and due process of one.
- exmicrosoldier 8y agoKavanaugh has been a controversial person his entire career. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/the-judicial-jihad-against-the-regulatory-state/2012/10/12/d9eb080c-13ca-11e2-bf18-a8a596df4bee_story.html?sw_bypass=true&utm_term=.0bc6d7af386c https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/the-judicial-jihad-a... https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2018/jul/25/amy-klobuchar/trump-brett-kavanaugh-scotus-cfpb-unconstitutional/ https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2018/jul... https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2018/08/20/oral-sex-what-brett-kavanaugh-wanted-ask-bill-clinton/1042861002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2018/08/20/oral...