2 ms·
The man deserves credit of course for helping create the first browsers and promoting the early web and his work for W3C. However, Tim's track record is not gre
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
The man deserves credit of course for helping create the first browsers and promoting the early web and his work for W3C. However, Tim's track record is not great when it comes to backing new versions of the web. E.g. Semantic Web never happened and arguably this is his latest attempt at flogging that dead horse. So, my prediction is that this won't get very far. It seems the website is a bit hand-wavy on the actual substance or vision and from what I'm seeing there's not actually a lot there. This looks like a research prototype to me.
I like the idea of decentralized as much as the next geek. However, there's a tendency of complex decentralized stuff being something that normal people don't really grasp or see the value of. Also, a lot of this value is not very tangible or even real. Most p2p systems have a hard time competing against a well run centralized system.
A lot of these decentralized Facebook/Twitter alternatives are being populated by people that, well, aren't that social. If you are like that, the empty room problem (you have no friends until world + dog joins) is not a big problem. You might even consider that a feature and not a bug. However, solving the empty room problem really is the key problem for social networks. How do you get all the social media whores, self pro-claimed influencers, etc. from endorsing your super duper decentralized platform and wanting to be there? Mostly that never happens.
- hutzlibu 8y ago"Mostly that never happens. " Might be because there are no decentralized competitors to facebook, who offer the same possibilities bugfree. Never seen that.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoSame isn't good enough. You need a killer app to get people to switch.
- hutzlibu 8y agoWhen you offer the same technical possibilities, but coorporation free, that is enough difference to get a critical mass of people to join. Signal for example still can't compete with WhatsApp on everything, but is good enough now to get some traction.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoThere have been plenty of attempts over the years. But even if you have the exact same feature set, looks, ux, etc., you still have an empty room. You need an incentive for people to actually switch. That's what's missing. Decentralized is an implementation detail for most users that they don't really understand or appreciate. I do believe there is an opportunity for something new to displace facebook. FB is not a healthy network at this point. It's shrinking and users are disengaging or even afraid to use it.