3 ms·
Ioannide's work claims that false research claims routinely makes it to publication, even in high-profile journals. Mochizuki has published a proof that many in
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
Ioannide's work claims that false research claims routinely makes it to
publication, even in high-profile journals. Mochizuki has published a proof
that many in the field believe is nonsense (unintelligible nonsense, at that).
That the shoddy research investigated by Ioannidis is shoddy because it misuses
statistics is besides the point. What matters is that the best efforts of
peer- review in highly respected venues, in "hard" science fields fails to
stop such work from being published.
Which makes the hoaxed fields (gender studies etc) not particularly special in
that respect.
>> The accusation being made here is that these fields are incapable of
separating absolute nonsense from genuine content.
That's also what Ioannides research concludes, except it does so for medicine,
neuroscience, etc.
In Mochizuki's case, his proof was published even though experts in the field
could not understand it and were not sure of its validity. It may yet prove to be nonsense, or, indeed- a hoax.
>> You're really misunderstanding Ionnandis' work if you think it is relevant to
this.
Obviously, I believe it's you who doesn't understand what you're talking about. But perhaps
we'll keep the discourse more civil by avoiding explicitly stated assumptions
about each other's cognitive abilities?