5 ms·

> The replication crisis is a perfect example of the problem faced by all fields, of papers of questionable veracity being accepted by peer-reviewed journals.

by darawk 8y ago

> The replication crisis is a perfect example of the problem faced by all fields, of papers of questionable veracity being accepted by peer-reviewed journals. You're absolutely right. Now, feel free to explain how that is relevant to THIS issue.

tomlock 8y ago
Because both address getting papers that are incorrect and have made up evidence into prominent peer-reviewed journals.
- darawk 8y ago
  Yes, but what is at issue is the nature of the papers that got past. The papers that passed peer review in the replication crisis were reasonable, but wrong. These papers were not.
  - tomlock 8y ago
    What makes you feel like you're an expert on what is and isn't reasonable?