3 ms·
Levine is great, but the headline (both the ones in the article, and the one here especially — which differ) suggest that there is no middle ground between stat
by loeg 8y ago
Levine is great, but the headline (both the ones in the article, and the one here especially — which differ) suggest that there is no middle ground between status quo five years ago and 100% index funds, no active investors at all. (Often journalists don't get to write their own headlines.)
I.e., grandparent commenter is responding reasonably to the headline, if not the article itself.
- yodon 8y agoIt's fine to comment on a headline but it's generally considered bad form here on HN to comment based just on reading the headline.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ucaetano 8y agoNot really, 2/3rds of the entire article, plus the title and subtitle are about index funds: > Are Index Funds Communist? > But when those thoughtful active analysts are replaced with passive index funds, the market stops serving that function. > Indexing is cheaper, yes, but that's because active management has positive externalities, and if no one will pay for it, those benefits will disappear. > But more fundamentally, there is an alternative view that the rise of passive investing will improve capital allocation > The passive investors can't influence relative prices > Their worry is that the growth in passive and quasi-passive products > Or I guess pure indexing -- everyone passively throws money at everything that there is, with no judgment at all -- is an imaginable fourth answer, and is strictly worse than the others.
- tanderson92 8y agoAs I explained elsewhere to you, not all passive or quasi-passive money is in indexed products. And furthermore, reading the article as I encouraged you originally to do, reveals it is not about index funds.
- loeg 8y ago> Not really, 2/3rds of the entire article, plus the title and subtitle are about index funds This is not responsive to my comment?