5 ms·
>> I would be extremely surprised if you could pass of work of such low quality in journals of comparable impact factor in [math, computer science, physics and
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> I would be extremely surprised if you could pass of work of such low quality in journals of comparable impact factor in [math, computer science, physics and economics].
What about medicine, genetics and neuroscience? These are the fields investigated by John Ioannidis, whom you've probably heard of [1]. He's the guy that published that paper titled "Why most published research findings are false" [2]. From the abstract of which, I quote:
Simulations show that for most study designs and settings, it is more likely for a research claim to be false than true. Moreover, for many current scientific fields, claimed research findings may often be simply accurate measures of the prevailing bias.
Note that that's pretty much the claim of the hoax- that the hoaxed fields are dominated by bias and the majority of their research claims are absurd (so, false, I guess).
If that's true of medicine and genetics, it's true of most of the hard sciences, and no doubt, also CS and economics. So there is no good reason to single out gender studies or feminist philosophy for this kind of fault, or in any case, the hoaxers would have made a much more meaningful contribution if they had hoaxed a maths or physics journal, rather than the ones they did.
Btw- in maths, a recent HN article discussed the Mochizuki proof of the ABC conjecture, that his fellow maths experts consider to be very badly mistaken (if I got that right) [3].
_______________________
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Ioannidis#Research_findings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Ioannidis#Research_findin...
[2] https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124 https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/jo...
[3] https://www.quantamagazine.org/titans-of-mathematics-clash-over-epic-proof-of-abc-conjecture-20180920/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/titans-of-mathematics-clash-o...
- darawk 8y agoI am familiar with all of the situations you've cited, and they are nothing like this one. You're really misunderstanding Ionnandis' work if you think it is relevant to this. He's making arguments about bad statistics, which is super important and valuable, but this has almost nothing to do with that. Again, the Mochizuiki situation is quite different. You're really not understanding these things if you think they're comparable. Mochizuiki's work is legitimate and real and serious. Whether or not it is correct is difficult to ascertain, because of its genuine complexity. The accusation being made here is that these fields are incapable of separating absolute nonsense from genuine content. Which means that their work is indistinguishable from nonsense and absurdity. The work that Ioannidis did demonstrates that people acting within a good framework are producing work with a higher error rate than you might expect given the claims they make. That work is extremely important. But it doesn't invalidate the field of economics, or medicine. This work attempts to invalidate the entire edifice that these disciplines are built upon. It is extremely different and not comparable at all.
- tomlock 8y agoThese disciplines aren't built on the edifice that you imagine they are. What you're doing, in examining the edification of certain disciplines, is quite postmodern. I encourage you to extend that examination to all fields.
- darawk 8y agoWhich disciplines aren't built on the edifice I imagine they are? If you're suggesting that math and physics aren't built on what I imagine them to be, then demonstrate your point.
- tomlock 8y agoAll of them. Every field is fallible, phrenology was once just science. Why would you think something like that couldn't happen again?
- darawk 8y agoYou seem to be arguing that all epistemologies are fallible and therefore they are all equivalent. This is a pretty silly line of argument. The fact that a thing is fallible does not mean that it is the equal of things that don't even bother with the truth.
- tomlock 8y agoSo, you feel like when someone says all fields are fallible and that you should examine their edification critically, that they are simultaneously making the claim that all fields are equivalent? Do you feel you are fallible in your identification of which fields are concerned with the truth and which ones aren't?
- darawk 8y agoI'm saying that you have made no argument whatsoever that math and physics are equivalently fallible to gender studies, you've merely insinuated it. If you've got an argument to make, feel free to make it. But citing the replication crisis does not cut it.