4 ms·
>> The whole point here is that you have these "conspicuously ideological" fields or subfields, which are not doing real scholarship, not interested in truth, b
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> The whole point here is that you have these "conspicuously ideological" fields
or subfields, which are not doing real scholarship, not interested in truth,
but which rather are pushing a specific position and attempting to label as
evil and shout down anyone who disagrees;
Yeah, look- it's not that simple. In academia, we have to allow discussion and
debate to be carried out freely, but obviously it doesn't make sense to
dictate the subject of a debate and call it "free"! And the only people who
are qualified to choose the subject of the debate are academics themselves-
because nobody else has the expertise to make that decision.
So if academics choose to debate identity politics and "Theory"- well, that's
what they get to debate. If the debate is done in a rotten manner that is not
conducive to good scholarship, now that's another matter, but if the question
is if those fields should exist, the answer is yes, and the reason is that
they do (it's a tautology, OK?).
It's a feature, not a bug. It's a bit like in a democracy you must allow
everyone their political opinion, even those people who are against democracy
itself? In academia, we must allow all academics the ability to investigate
the subjects of their interest, else we don't have academia, we just have a
closed club of people who agree with each other- so, just like the fields
targeted by the hoax.
- Sniffnoy 8y agoHuh? I'm not claiming that these topics should be off-limits; I'm saying that the actual existing departments presently studying them are rotten. In short I'm not sure we're disagreeing here. Edit: If you like, you can replace my use of "fields and subfields" above with "departments and segments of such". That's probably fairer in other ways, too.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoYeah, OK, maybe I misread your comment.