15 ms·
Hundreds of years from now, when this time period is documented in history books, my great great grandchildren will look back on our greed-driven for-profit hea
by ryandrake 8y ago
Hundreds of years from now, when this time period is documented in history books, my great great grandchildren will look back on our greed-driven for-profit healthcare system as a shameful black mark in American history, just like we look back at the history of slavery today. They’ll ask “How could a democracy have allowed random, treatable health conditions to ruin people financially?” They’ll be horrified by how greedy and barbaric we are as a people, same as how we look back at the Civil War era society that promoted slavery.
- danharaj 8y agoNo they won't, it'll be whitewashed in textbooks and only those who study history will know. There's already so many so-called black marks that are worse and already quietly overlooked.
- selestify 8y agoWhat are some of these worse black marks?
- lettergram 8y agoDuring elections people used to be bribed with alcohol. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/swilling-the-planters-with-bumbo-when-booze-bought-elections-102758236/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/swilling-the-pla... One of a thousand examples.
- satya71 8y agoColonialism is one of them. History books in US and UK still teach that the colonizers saved the savages and brought them to the modern age. They continue to completely ignore that most colonies underwent centuries long recession as a result of the repression. Japan was never colonized and became quite advanced.
- pertymcpert 8y agoNo they don't in the UK.
- IC4RUS 8y agoWhich books? I've read through a fair number of history books published in the US, and they have tended to have a strong focus on the problems caused by colonization while criticizing the idea of 'saving' the locals.
- dmd 8y ago> History books in US and UK still teach that the colonizers saved the savages and brought them to the modern age. My history books (1980s public school, New York, US) most definitely taught nothing of the sort.
- ianmcgowan 8y agoI don't think that's true. I went to school in the UK in the 80's and my kids are going to school in the US now, and this is far from what I remember then and not what I see now. "Colonial guilt" is how I would sum it up. Not to say there's not a lot of whitewashing and selective reporting, far from it. But it's probably been 50 years since "teach that the colonizers saved the savages".. You have a point about the economic impact of the colonialism, and the economic value that was extracted. At least in the case of the UK, that was made it a global power. That is usually not discussed much, because it's history, not economics...
- webkike 8y agoI wouldn’t argue it’s worse than slavery, but as a singular event Bikini Atoll was horrific.
- smacktoward 8y agoAsk a Native American.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tezza 8y agoSlavery Annihilation of local tribes by colonisers forced opium enslavement of China dividing up China between France/Britain/Japan pestilence from European cattle annihilating 2/3 of inland african people via starvation the policy of the Holy Roman Emperor and The Pope to keep german states at war with italian states emperor Chin executing the whole village where any crime at all occurred The Spanish Inquisition The Khmer Rouge The Long March under Mao Stalins purges and gulags the list goes on
- UpshotKnothole 8y agoThe original premise was that black marks will be overlooked. I don’t know how to break it to you, but the ones you’ve listed are infamous and hardly overlooked. Premise: No they won't, it'll be whitewashed in textbooks and only those who study history will know. There's already so many so-called black marks that are worse and already quietly overlooked. And you just offered a ton of support for the competing hypothesis that our period of history will be infamous along with the ones you’ve listed.
- tezza 8y agoyou dont need to break it to me... ask a group outside of HN and they will come up with a couple if you’re lucky. try it.
- UpshotKnothole 8y agoNo offense to this site, I like it a lot so far, but I wouldn’t favorably compare it in terms of non-technical knowledge to most of the educated population. You listed a ton of really infamous events, ones that are routinely covered in intro classes at all levels of schooling, and have entered even pop culture. If you think that most people are unaware of all, but a couple of them, you’re grossly underestimating people. I’d argue that the only two many people wouldn’t know are the actions of the pope one, and the Chin emperor. The rest are familiar to pretty much everyone who made it through high school.
- majewsky 8y ago
- danharaj 8y agoThis is a moving target; I haven't been in school for a while. Here's two: The complicity of US corporations in the holocaust. The way the US protected people who committed atrocities to gain a scientific advantage after WW2.
- Judgmentality 8y agoI'd love to learn more - got any sources?
- lev99 8y agoLies My Teacher Told Me by James W. Loewen talks a lot about how whitewashed, and classist history text books are, and why that is the case. A summary of the book is that history textbooks have a tendency to avoid showing anything negative done by great American historical figures because they are held up as heroes for people in imitate. There is a narrative of constant progress that is told in the textbooks that does not match with actual history. History textbooks avoid talking about class struggles altogether, because if they did they would be labeled as Marxist. There is a general avoidance of discussing immoral foreign policy. The book backs up these claims by citing many popular textbooks and how they cover, or don't cover, historical events. (The following summary of the book is my own understanding of the book's opinions and not necessarily my own. I haven't studied history enough to hold my own opinion.)
- jcranmer 8y agoThe US foreign policy for the Americas in the early 20th century is something that tends to be thoroughly ignored. Treatment of indigenous peoples around the world is also another big blinders, although the US has done one of the better jobs of being forthright about poor treatment (compared to Canada, say).
- andbberger 8y agoAnd let's not forget how the US rolled all over latin America during the cold war...
- rabidrat 8y agoTry "War is a Racket" by Smedley Butler, USMC major general.
- reefoctopus 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_People's_History_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_People's_History_of_the_Unit...
- readhn 8y agoIt depends on what political system we have by then. If we do develop further and progress to a one whole planet mentality (no countries/borders etc) then we will know our history as it was. If we continue on the current path then im afraid we'll still be divided with all the consequences (same old same old). " No they won't, it'll be whitewashed in textbooks and only those who study history will know. There's already so many so-called black marks that are worse and already quietly overlooked. "
- beambot 8y agoCan you name a political system that didn't selectively rewrite or selectively teach history? I think of it as a spectrum, but very non-ideal whichever direction you look.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoI'm not actually certain that the Civil War era is viewed universally as a barbaric time, or that slavery is universally viewed as a black mark in American History. There is still plenty of popular music and subcultures that look on those times positively, perhaps even fondly. In some sense the culture behind the civil war is still very strong in America, and whether or not it was bad is still heavily debated.
- save_ferris 8y agoWhat? There's certainly debate around whether or not slavery was the cause of the Civil War, but slavery is absolutely universally viewed as a black mark in American history.
- phil248 8y agoThese delusions that hateful ideas don't have any traction in America are exactly why Trumpism has been able to succeed. There are sizable groups of people in this country with terrifying beliefs. You've got to take off the blinders. "The Times found that nearly 20% of Trump supporters did not approve of freeing the slaves, according to a January YouGov/Economist poll" http://time.com/4236640/donald-trump-racist-supporters/ http://time.com/4236640/donald-trump-racist-supporters/
- pjc50 8y agoWell, apart from all those people who protested the removal of Confederate statues.
- markovbot 8y agoThose people will also be viewed as a black mark on American history
- 2342dk39dkjdj 8y agoThere's not really a debate about whether or not slavery was the cause of the civil war, at least not among historians. You can go a lot deeper on this if you want, but take for example one of the first sentences in the Mississippi Declaration of Secession: "Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery"
- gnopgnip 8y agoHow are nursing home costs handled in other healthcare systems?
- lovich 8y agoAre nursing homes even prevalent in other countries? When I visited Thailand they were appalled at idea of putting elderly relatives in a random building and not with family, but I don't know if they are the exception or the US is
- minipci1321 8y agoOne thing people don't usually mention alongside high cost of nursing homes, is that it seems to be pretty well bounded in time: see for example, https://www.geripal.org/2010/08/length-of-stay-in-nursing-homes-at-end.html https://www.geripal.org/2010/08/length-of-stay-in-nursing-ho... I had very similar figures (avg 18 months), although unofficial, from a person involved with nursing homes over here (western european well developed country with good medical system), although I obviously cannot cite. So yes, please visit them as soon as you can after admission, don't put away...
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI think comparing this to slavery, the Indian wars, Jim Crow, etc. more than a little hyperbolic. There's a big difference between using violence to control other people, take their land or systemic disenfranchisement and the best healthcare being affordable to a big chunk of the population. Things that are Really Bad(TM) involve people actively doing things that we consider highly immoral today. Healthcare is just a case of failing to find a workable solution. The situations are very different.
- detcader 8y agoIt's deeply immoral to use violence to control people. It's deeply immoral to hoard money and resources (to "be rich" in today's language) and ensure the system of resource hoarding continues over generations through lobbying and corruption. That's the extent of the comparison -- the magnitude of the immorality -- and I think it's fair?
- nonbel 8y ago>"It's deeply immoral to hoard money and resources" This sounds like "it's deeply immoral to plan ahead" to me.
- detcader 8y agoTo me, there's planning ahead, with a large emergency fund and survival supplies for one's family, and then there's hoarding money and resources. "When you start talking about whether it is moral to be rich, you end up heading down some difficult logical paths. If I am obligated to use my wealth to help people, am I not obligated to keep doing so until I am myself a pauper? Surely this obligation attaches to anyone who consumes luxuries they do not need, or who has some savings that they are not spending on malaria treatment for children. But the central point I want to make here is that the moral duty becomes greater the more wealth you have. If you end up with a $50,000 a year or $100,000 a year salary, we can debate what amount you should spend on helping other people. But if you earn $250,000 or 1 million, it’s quite clear that the bulk of your income should be given away. You can live very comfortably on $100,000 or so and have luxury and indulgence, so anything beyond is almost indisputably indefensible." ~ Nathan Robinson, It's Basically Just Immoral To Be Rich
- Carlton87 8y agoI find it funny that you think in hundreds of years we are not going to be greedy or barbaric. It is basically hardwired into the human condition.
- longerthoughts 8y agoCompletely agree but don't think that changes the likelihood of future generations looking back shamefully. They'll look back just as we do and say "at least we don't do that anymore". They'll be hypocrites, but it doesn't mean they'll be wrong about us.
- ronilan 8y agoFrom when it was sold[1]: > "I'm shocked it sold at all," Lederman's wife, Ellen, told The Associated Press on Friday. "We would let little kids play with it and have their picture taken." > Auction manager Laura Yntema told NBC News that the winning bid was placed online — but she declined to provide further information about the buyer, citing the auction house's confidentiality rules. So an anonymous person provided for Lederman’s retirement in exchange for “ownership” of a piece of metal, with little intrinsic value, no sentimental value, and that will forever be know as “Lederman’s Nobel medal” never as belonging to the buyer. Just another way to look at how the “mechanics of society” worked in the case. [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/physicist-leon-ledermans-nobel-prize-goes-auction-block-n365671 https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/physicist-leon-...
- lawlessquestion 8y agoFor one we are a Republic not a democracy. If we were a pure democracy its arguable whether we would be in better or worse shape. If we were a Republic as our constitution was drafted, prior to the supreme court gutting state and individual liberties with the commerce clause,etc. I think we would be in much better shape
- skh 8y agoWhat is the purpose of your first sentence? Colloquially we speak of democracy as being something with representation that is elected with a large majority of the adult population being eligible to vote. Surely you know this so I can't figure what the point of being so pedantic is. Your assertion in the last sentence certainly needs more evidence to support it. As it stands it's unlikely to sway anyone and quite frankly paints a picture of you being a fanatic. This is especially so since the Commerce Clause was the justification for the Civil Rights Act and the Civil Rights Act greatly increased individual liberties.
- mnm1 8y agoHundreds of years from now? I look at it that way now and I assume all decent people do too.
- ryandrake 8y agoWe evidently have many not-decent people who vote for like minded Congressional representatives. At least a majority otherwise this would have been fixed by now.