3 ms·
Won't these other competitors have to purchase some bandwidth from the government as well? Would that still be an "unregulated" industry? Could a firm that just
by jessaustin 8y ago
Won't these other competitors have to purchase some bandwidth from the government as well? Would that still be an "unregulated" industry? Could a firm that just wanted to serve a small local area get into this?
In the soft drink industry, no firm has to do anything but start mixing and bottling soft drinks. Which explains why there are hundreds of smaller firms, from the 7up-RC company on down. The moat that Coke and Pepsi have is maintained purely by marketing. There is no Federal Drinks Commission whose members expect lifetime sinecures from Pepsico.
You conclude with an astonishingly ahistorical explanation for current telco monopoly. Ma Bell was protected from competition by FCC for decades, and both the "divestiture" and the later "unbundling" were carefully choreographed by FCC and DoJ to arrange for just the reconsolidation we've seen since.
- rayiner 8y ago> Won't these other competitors have to purchase some bandwidth from the government as well? There's tons of bandwidth in the millimeter wave spectrum where key 5G deployments will happen: https://www.verizon.com/about/our-company/5g/what-millimeter-wave-technology https://www.verizon.com/about/our-company/5g/what-millimeter.... And the government is working to clear more. Proponents of regulation have this tendency to view things through a moral lens. "Wireless should be regulated because it uses public spectrum." But the question isn't whether regulation is morally justified, but whether it is economically efficient. That means the focus is not on whether some public resource is being used, but how many competitors can be sustained with those public resources. Even with LTE, there are four nationwide competitors, which is more competition than exists in many other markets. And 5G can support even more. Whether or not those competitors need to use public spectrum to provide their service, there will be enough competition to obviate the need to regulate. > The moat that Coke and Pepsi have is maintained purely by marketing. What you call a "moat" is in economics terms a "barrier to entry." And there's lots of different ones. E.g. anyone seeking to compete with Android and iOS have to account for the network effect caused by existing app libraries. Nothing makes the barriers to entry in 5G magically different from network effects or branding strengths or other barriers to entry that exist in other industries. The fact that a moat exists doesn't mean regulation is automatically warranted. Regulation is only warranted when the barriers are so high that there is no functioning competition. And experience shows that regulation is very hard, and markets have to get very dysfunctional before a government-regulated industry becomes preferable. > You conclude with an astonishingly ahistorical explanation for current telco monopoly. Ma Bell was protected from competition by FCC for decades, and both the "divestiture" and the later "unbundling" were carefully choreographed by FCC and DoJ to arrange for just the reconsolidation we've seen since. That's both irrelevant and proves my point. It's irrelevant because we're talking about wireless, which was built entirely post-deregulation. (And even in the context of wired broadband, most people get their broadband today from cable, and those networks were never regulated under the telephone regime. Instead, local governments handed out monopolies in return for grab-bag handouts, which is exactly why they should have minimal authority over deployment.) It also proves my point, because the treatment of AT&T is a product of how folks thought about utility regulation back then. (See: Master Switch). Back then, regulators thought competition was a bad thing. They thought it was better to have a tightly regulated monopoly. So the Communications Act of 1934 provides for the FCC to micro-manage telephone companies, telling them when they can build lines, etc. This was not unique to telecom. It goes back to the Interstate Commerce Commission and how they regulated railroads (and later trucking, airlines, etc.). They didn't trust competition, so they put regulators in charge of infrastructure deployment, pricing, etc. Starting in the 1960s and 1970s, Congress realized this was all nuts--antithetical to what we now know about competitive markets. So they deregulated vast swaths of the economy. In the 1990s, they applied the same ideas to telecom, prohibited granting regional monopolies, etc. The result was a massive boom in telecom investment.[1] This was not unique to the U.S., most of the developed world substantially copied our approach. To the extent that the 1996 Act has been less successful than intended, the blame squarely lies with municipal governments. Most cities make it illegal to build an MVP version of an ISP. You're required to either cover a whole city or nothing. And they use franchising powers to extort concessions (5% of gross revenues as franchise fees, free fiber for government buildings, etc.). Local governments are the ones who have created an environment that makes it unpalatable for new entrants to compete. 5G offers another bite at the apple. It dramatically lowers the "natural monopoly" aspect of telecom deployment. Even with very small cells, it eliminates the "last half mile" (and the massive fan-out that happens in the last half mile). The only thing that stands in the way is municipalities, who don't understand regulatory theory, just that they can use whatever permitting authority they have to extract grab-bag concessions. [1] If you doubt the success of the 1996 Act, consider this: U.S. broadband speeds are faster than Germany, the U.K., France, Spain, and Italy. In what other area of infrastructure does the U.S. outperform these countries? The answer is none. Our roads suck, our trains suck, our subways suck. But our broadband is faster! Compared to another highly-competitive industry--CPUs are maybe 100x faster for single-threaded code than in 1996. Your broadband is probably 1000-2000x faster. All this makes me wonder if the people who facilely declare the 1996 deregulation to be a failure are living on the same planet as me. Or, more cynically, it's such an astounding blow to their ideas about "enlightened regulators" running the economy that they have deny its success, regardless of facts.
- jessaustin 8y agoC'mon man, I post reliably enough on this topic that you know I'm not a "proponent of regulation". I'm the one who wants to see FCC shuttered completely. Let radio device manufacturers regulate themselves like they already do perfectly well in the wifi bands. ("But, but, long-distance interference!" Really? You were talking about millimeter wave. That's on the other side of wifi: why does that need regulation?) Failing that, let's have the advertised spirit of the 1996 Act, rather than its woeful intent and implementation. I would love to believe this vision of 5G you offer, of enough competition to actually change the character of internet access in USA. I love to imagine that innovation supported by ever smaller and more numerous connected devices might someday be possible. I love that on the wired side I can hire e.g. Jive or one of its many competitors for my business phone system and Netflix or one of its many competitors for personal entertainment. That services are not tied to the network is a basic internet design principle. Yet even in wired I still have to pay more for a data connection alone than for a data connection plus some stupid local phone or TV connection. (The only exceptions are where a local municipality has had the vision to defend local interests.) Wireless, of course, is much worse, e.g. with MNOs overcharging average users so as to subsidize whoever is using the favored online-service-of-the-month. I know they're overcharging because if I sign up with MVNO Ting I get the same service for less than half the price. Marketing is expensive, but so is buying FCC. Also yes I took Ec 10 and several additional courses; I don't require reminding that "moat" is a euphemism for "barrier to entry". It's telling that when speculating about new entrants, you come up with... Comcast and Google. Well yes these giant oligopolistic firms will continue to exist as such. That isn't exactly a wave of entrepreneurial investment like that we saw in the late 1990s. Investors learned from that debacle. When you pour many billions into a marketplace the regulator of which has been owned by one actor for six decades, that actor will end up with most of your investment. It will take a few decades for investors to forget that lesson. Sure, it's nice for backbone customers that long-distance data is still overbuilt even now. Somehow that doesn't help the average last-mile consumer. How do I know? What am I talking about? In a previous stage of my career I worked for both CLECs and ILECs. I've seen the change orders dropped on the floor by the hundreds, for no reason that VZN or SBC even cared to lie about. The entire UNE program, a centerpiece of the 1996 act, was a sham from the start. The incumbents were never held to any level of service at any level of interconnection, eventually their competitors just ran out of money, and they swept up the infrastructure and customer base for pennies on the dollar. ATT and VZN have used this windfall to dominate spectrum auctions and so inevitably the wireless market. They compete with each other as hard as e.g. Mastercard and Visa, about what one would expect from Ma Bell's two daughters. "Broadband investment" is a bizarre metric to even mention, when discussing a captured regulator of generations-old monopolistic firms. How did they afford that buildout? They let investors in victim firms pay for it. It is possible that the various parties who have been doing the same thing, in different guises, for 84 years will do something different in the near future. It is possible that in introducing 5G they are making a mistake on the order of allowing the microwave oven in the ISM band. Viewed over the long run, it just doesn't seem very likely. What seems more likely is that they will continue harvesting monopoly rents and spending some small portion of those rents on keeping their regulator captured and their customers without options. There are procedures for sharing pole space, and FCC has just put municipalities on notice that they will keep their thumb on that scale too.