4 ms·
The underlying message is that Boeing isn't confident they'll beat Crew Dragon to orbit. They've already stacked the deck with more funding due to their "legacy
by kevin_thibedeau 8y ago
The underlying message is that Boeing isn't confident they'll beat Crew Dragon to orbit. They've already stacked the deck with more funding due to their "legacy overhead" but apparently even that isn't enough.
- imglorp 8y agoIs Boeing having trouble competing on all of features, price, and schedule? I think the story is more complicated as always - If you watch Scott Manley's channel, I think there's a few mission profiles that ULA can do better than SpaceX. One launcher can't do everything well.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoI think right now Boeing is ahead schedule-wise, but it's a bit of a coin flip for who will launch first. I wouldn't be surprised if they're within 3 months of each other, both for the initial test and the first crewed test.
- greglindahl 8y agoNASA says Boeing is behind. This press release is dated today: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/launch-dates-to-be-updated-more-regularly-as-commercial-crew-flights-draw-nearer https://www.nasa.gov/feature/launch-dates-to-be-updated-more...
- hef19898 8y agoI dug into SpaceX a little bit deeper the last couple of days, mainly to get an answer to the question whether reusabel launchers are financially feasible or not. I did not find an answer to that question, instead I found some other intriguing data. The development sure is cheaper at SpaceX compared to Arianespace, so I assume the same is true for Boeing. On the launch costs, taken everything into account, including the WSJ article using SpaceX internal data up to 2015, there is not much of a difference between SpaceX and Arianespace on average. It seems that SpaceX is undercutting the commercial competition with government contracts. Also, Google most likely saved SpaceX from bancruptcy in 2016. That ULA, as a historical DoD monoplist, plays in different league all together is a different story. I am not yet finished, so yes I might be mistaken with my conclusion so far.
- greglindahl 8y agoSeems like you believe a lot of rumors you read on the Internet! SpaceX is a private company with very little financial data available.
- hef19898 8y agoWell, there was the internal data zhe wall Street journal reported on in 2017. And the SpaceX comments made in the follow up. And the funding history is available as well, how reliable crunchbase is for that I don't know. So there is no complete vacuum. Also, you have advertised costs on SpaceX website. It is at least enough to get a first idea of things. I don't have the numbers in front of me rigjt now, but I am more than happy to share them. Because my whole thought process and thus analysis was wrong it would really help to know that. EDIT: The rumors I read have been the reason I tried to chase down as much numbers and information I could by myself.
- greglindahl 8y agoI'm glad you convinced yourself, but this situation has been argued over for years by a lot of people on Reddit, and I really doubt you can bring any hard facts to the argument that aren't well-known.
- hef19898 8y agoSee, I am not convinced at all. It is reasonable to assume that SpaceX has lower development cost (it would be hard to be more expensive than Ariane and ULA so). Which means SpaceX reaches the program break-even point earlier. Launch costs on the other hand are driven by production cost mainly. And there I don't see any systematic advantage that would explain the lower prices SpaceX is advertising. I know that there is no such thing as a "standard" launch, but all numbers that are available point at higher prices than the $ 62M a Falcon 9 is advertised for. Reusable launchers are different story. And SpaceX is giving 30% discounts for them (source: SpaceX, Gwynn Shotwell). So yeah, if you can point out wrong assumptions or errors, I'm more than happy because I am not convinced of my analysis so far myself. EDIT: Typos... man, typing on the phone really is suboptimal for sentences with more than three words...