2 ms·
These aren't intended to be "beautiful" proofs, they are simple proofs. They can be followed without having to grok vast amounts of external material. They ar
by ColinWright 8y ago
These aren't intended to be "beautiful" proofs, they are simple proofs. They can be followed without having to grok vast amounts of external material. They are self-contained, without external dependencies. They are short, and while you may feel that they fail to impart insight, I'm not so sure. Having lived with these proofs for some years ( I knew them before I saw this series of blogs posts) I find that they are becoming simpler over time as I understand more about what's going on around them.
Fermat's Last Theorem is trivial to prove because we just quote the Taniyama-Shimura-Weil Theorem, observe a particular elliptic curve, and there you are. It's "simple," once you have T-S-W. But that's means it's not self-contained, and while it is probably more enlightening as to the underlying why all this works, it's not simple.
So your comment about using the zeta function and the periodicity requirement of infinite series exactly shows why your suggestion might be enlightening, but is not simple.
At least, not in any sense I would use.