2 ms·
Bad papers get published in all fields. Linking to one bad journal article shows nothing. Here, for example, is a reference to a bad paper published in a field
by foldr 8y ago
Bad papers get published in all fields. Linking to one bad journal article shows nothing.
Here, for example, is a reference to a bad paper published in a field which is not usually the target of this kind of criticism:
https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9602/rediscovery-of-calculus-in-1994-what-should-have-happened-to-that-paper https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9602/rediscover...
https://math.berkeley.edu/~ehallman/math1B/TaisMethod.pdf https://math.berkeley.edu/~ehallman/math1B/TaisMethod.pdf
- int_19h 8y agoTrue, but when such papers are discovered, they're usually torn down by people in the field. In this case, it was the other way around - all meaningful criticism came from the outside, and in response, researchers in the field mostly circled the wagons. Besides, the paper in question wasn't merely published - the author got a prestigious NSF award that lists that paper: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1253779 https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1253779 This, to me, implies that either such papers are considered broadly acceptable in the field, or they're not actually read. Not sure which is worse.
- foldr 8y agoHave you read the paper you linked to, or just the abstract and quotes in the right wing press? You're confused about how NSF grants work. The publication is listed as an output. The grant was awarded before that paper was published. The listing of the paper on that page implies nothing about its quality. My example paper was torn down by mathematicians, not diabetes researchers.