3 ms·
> there is an opportunity for upstarts who only do electric to take on gas cars. Sure. But the mistake everyone makes is that the drive train technology is not
by threeseed 8y ago
> there is an opportunity for upstarts who only do electric to take on gas cars.
Sure. But the mistake everyone makes is that the drive train technology is not what differentiates a car.
It's the brand, the design, quality of interior, availability etc. Those are much harder for upstarts to get right as we've seen with Tesla.
- wmf 8y agoAnd I don't know if Tesla's drive train is that far ahead. Cars like the i-Pace have copied the dual-motor "skateboard" chassis, reasonable range, fast charging, etc. while including all the benefits of established car design/manufacturing.
- SEJeff 8y agoAnecdotally, this teardown report seems to refute your statement a bit: https://cleantechnica.com/2018/02/19/tesla-model-3-stuns-german-engineers-wonders/ https://cleantechnica.com/2018/02/19/tesla-model-3-stuns-ger...
- threeseed 8y ago> was harshly critical of the build quality of the Model 3, calling it nearly as bad as a ’90s era Kia. Also it's obviously much simpler and cleaner to build a car with just a touchscreen as its main interface. But the problem is its a nightmare for driving.
- SEJeff 8y agoHave you ever driven one? I’ve got a Model 3 and find it a bit different but not too bad at all. I love that I can click the camera button and get a huge HD rear camera view. “Its a nightmare for driving” sounds an awful lot like you’ve never seriously driven one. I was leery of the speedometer being in the center and not behind the steering wheel, but it isn’t all that different from diving a Mini, where the speedometer is a giant dial in the center console.
- btilly 8y agoIt is not that the drive train differentiates the car. It is that the drive train constrains possible electric cars to be poor fits for the existing mass market. Which provides a market opportunity for manufacturers that focus on what is possible with the technology now, regardless of how well it fits in current Detroit marketing plans. By the time electric is capable of being used for comparable cars at comparable prices for established lines of cars for established auto companies, they will be up against entrants in electric cars that have lower margins and more experience. When existing car manufacturers try to switch over they will wind up offering an inferior car at a worse price than the upstarts. This is a story that has played out many times in technology, and it never goes well for the established industry giants. It doesn't matter if the competitors are delivering sports cars or glorified golf carts. What matters is that traditional auto companies with traditional dealer networks will be unable to compete head to head when they become competitive with the mass market. Everyone knows about Tesla. Go look at https://www.fastcompany.com/40517240/the-biggest-electric-vehicle-company-youve-never-heard-of https://www.fastcompany.com/40517240/the-biggest-electric-ve... for a company approaching the problem from the low end. There are a dozen more where BYD came from. And other markets where competitors are developing. There are many niches around the world for electric vehicles. They are filled with companies who are salivating at the juicy pork chop that is the US car market. Technology does not, yet, allow them to compete head to head in Detroit's main product categories. But when they finally can, established automakers won't stand a chance.
- threeseed 8y ago> they will wind up offering an inferior car at a worse price than the upstarts Jaguar I-Pace. Mercedes EQC. BMW iX3. Far superior to Tesla on all the metrics I mentioned before.
- r00fus 8y agoThe I-Pace is just starting sales. The EQC is not yet released. You can barely reserve the iX3. How are these even in the same ballpark as the Model S which has been out for 6 years and the Model 3 which has been selling in decent volume for months? We have very little data about how production models of these vehicles drive/maintenance/etc. It will be nice to see some competition to Telsa's Model X but none of them really compete with a Model 3 right now (ie, under $50k base).
- nickik 8y agoTesla has the most popular brand. Availability will be a huge problem for traditional makers as well, as we have already seen with all their electric cars. Its not clear at all that they can simply massively scale electronic cars. People who say that as soon as VW makes a electric car they can just produce millions is wildly optimistic. And quality of the interior is one of the easier things to improve. I think range, acceleration, mobile phone integration and digital features, 'autopilot' are far more important.